TMS-induced phase resets depend on TMS intensity and EEG phase

Brian Erickson, Brian Kim, Philip N. Sabes, Ryan Rich, Abigail Hatcher, Guadalupe Fernandez-Nuñez, Georgios Mentzelopoulos, Flavia Vitale, John D. MedagliaJournal of Neural Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) affects brain rhythms, specifically the µ-Alpha oscillations in the motor cortex. They found that both the intensity of the TMS pulse and the ongoing phase of the brain's own µ-Alpha rhythm critically influence how the brain's activity is reset. This suggests a new way to precisely control brain activity by timing TMS pulses relative to natural brain oscillations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Brain activity is characterized by rhythmic oscillations, and the phase of these oscillations (think of it like the peak or trough of a wave) is known to influence how the brain processes information and performs tasks. Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) is a non-invasive technique that can disrupt or reset these brain rhythms. However, to effectively use TMS for therapeutic or research purposes, we need a deeper understanding of how its parameters, particularly intensity, interact with the brain's ongoing state. Specifically, the authors aim to clarify how TMS intensity and the instantaneous phase of the µ-Alpha rhythm (a key motor cortex oscillation) jointly determine the extent and nature of TMS-induced phase resetting. This knowledge is crucial for developing more precise and controllable TMS protocols.

Methods

The researchers conducted a TMS-EEG (electroencephalography) experiment where they applied single-pulse TMS to the motor cortex at varying intensities (10% to 100% of Resting Motor Threshold - RMT). To understand the brain's state at the moment of stimulation, they used an offline autoregressive algorithm to estimate the phase of the µ-Alpha rhythm. Trials were then sorted based on whether the TMS pulse occurred near a µ-Alpha peak or trough. They also included auditory sham and parietal stimulation as control conditions to differentiate neural effects from peripheral sensory responses. Key metrics analyzed included Phase Locking Factor (PLF) to quantify the consistency of brain rhythms across trials and Transcranial Evoked Potentials (TEPs), specifically the N100 component, as a measure of cortical excitability. Statistical analyses involved non-parametric permutation tests to compare conditions and assess parametric relationships.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from human participants during the experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intensity and Phase are a Dynamic Duo: The core finding is that TMS-induced phase resetting isn't just about how strong the TMS pulse is; it's a complex interplay between TMS intensity and the brain's endogenous µ-Alpha phase at the moment of stimulation.
  • Low-Intensity TMS Resets, High-Intensity TMS Activates (Selectively): Low-intensity TMS seems to primarily "reset" existing oscillations. However, higher intensities appear to activate previously silent neurons, but only when the endogenous µ-Alpha rhythm is near its peak phase. This suggests a threshold effect that depends on the brain's readiness.
  • Phase Inversion at High Intensities: A striking observation was the inversion of the µ-Alpha phase after high-intensity TMS (90-100% RMT) when pulses were delivered near the peak of the endogenous rhythm. This indicates a significant disruption and reversal of the ongoing oscillatory pattern.
  • N100 as a Marker of Complex Interaction: The N100 component, often linked to cortical excitability, showed a nonlinear relationship with TMS intensity. This, along with the phase-dependent effects, suggests that TMS isn't simply adding energy but engaging more complex neural mechanisms.
  • Timing is Everything: The study strongly implies that by carefully timing TMS pulses relative to ongoing brain oscillations, we can achieve more targeted effects, potentially resetting or sustaining specific brain states.

Key Results

  • µ-Alpha phase resetting and N100 amplitude were found to depend parametrically on TMS intensity and were significantly different from auditory sham stimulation.
  • µ-Alpha phase inversion was observed after high-intensity TMS (90-100% RMT) when delivered near the peak of the endogenous µ-Alpha rhythm, but not when delivered near the trough.
  • The N100 amplitude showed a nonlinear relationship with TMS intensity, fitting a logarithmic function better than a linear one.
  • Phase Locking Factor (PLF) increased with TMS intensity above ~40% RMT, indicating increased oscillatory consistency.
  • The study suggests that the 70%-80% RMT range might be a particularly sensitive window for observing phase-dependent effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Peripheral Effects: While controls were used, distinguishing purely neural effects from peripheral somatosensory effects can be challenging. Multimodal approaches and direct neural recordings are suggested for disambiguation.
  • Parietal Stimulation: The parietal stimulation site did not evoke a motor-evoked potential (MEP), making direct comparison with motor cortex stimulation difficult and limiting interpretation.
  • Frequency Specificity: Due to the need for high signal-to-noise ratio for phase estimation, the study was limited to µ-Alpha frequencies. Future work could explore other frequencies.
  • Sub-threshold Focus: The study primarily focused on sub-threshold stimulation. Future research should explore supra-threshold stimulation and its phase/intensity-dependent effects, as these might involve different neural populations.
  • Sample Size: A larger sample size could help explore subtle effects and generalize findings.

Future work suggested includes exploring the sensitivity of EEG phase resetting as a predictor of cortical excitability modulation and investigating the role of different neural populations in the nonlinear N100 response. The authors also propose that their findings can guide the development of more effective and targeted rTMS protocols by explicitly aiming to induce specific resetting or additive effects based on brain state.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Objective</i>. The phase of the electroencephalographic (EEG) signal predicts performance in motor, somatosensory, and cognitive functions. Studies suggest that brain phase resets align neural oscillations with external stimuli, or couple oscillations across frequency bands and brain regions. Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) can cause phase resets noninvasively in the cortex, thus providing the potential to control phase-sensitive cognitive functions. However, the relationship between TMS parameters and phase resetting is not fully understood. This is especially true of TMS intensity, which may be crucial to enabling precise control over the amount of phase resetting that is induced. Additionally, TMS phase resetting may interact with the instantaneous phase of the brain. Understanding these relationships is crucial to the development of more powerful and controllable stimulation protocols.<i>Approach.</i>To test these relationships, we conducted a TMS-EEG study. We applied single-pulse TMS at varying degrees of stimulation intensity to the motor area in an open loop. Offline, we used an autoregressive algorithm to estimate the phase of the intrinsic<i>µ</i>-Alpha rhythm of the motor cortex at the moment each TMS pulse was delivered.<i>Main results</i>. We identified post-stimulation epochs where<i>µ</i>-Alpha phase resetting and N100 amplitude depend parametrically on TMS intensity and are significant<i>versus</i>peripheral auditory sham stimulation. We observed<i>µ</i>-Alpha phase inversion after stimulations near peaks but not troughs in the endogenous<i>µ</i>-Alpha rhythm.<i>Significance</i>. These data suggest that low-intensity TMS primarily resets existing oscillations, while at higher intensities TMS may activate previously silent neurons, but only when endogenous oscillations are near the peak phase. These data can guide future studies that seek to induce phase resetting, and point to a way to manipulate the phase resetting effect of TMS by varying only the timing of the pulse with respect to ongoing brain activity.
BibTeX
@article{erickson2024tms,
  author = {Brian Erickson and Brian Kim and Philip N. Sabes and Ryan Rich and Abigail Hatcher and Guadalupe Fernandez-Nuñez and Georgios Mentzelopoulos and Flavia Vitale and John D. Medaglia},
  title = {{TMS-induced phase resets depend on TMS intensity and EEG phase}},
  journal = {Journal of Neural Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1088/1741-2552/ad7f87},
}
Figure