Titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system for the treatment of distal tibiofibular syndesmosis injury.

Zhaofeng Jia, Jiwu Cheng, Hai‐Yan Zhong, Tinghui Xiao, Jinke Ren, Yimiao Lin, Wenjun Huang, Yujie Liang, Qisong Liu, Xiaoming ZhangPubMed 2019

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system for treating distal tibiofibular syndesmosis (DTS) injuries, a common complication of ankle sprains. The system aims to overcome limitations of existing methods by providing stable, yet flexible, fixation that restores natural joint function and allows for early weight-bearing, with no need for implant removal.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distal tibiofibular syndesmosis (DTS) injuries are frequently associated with ankle sprains and fractures. These injuries disrupt the stability of the ankle joint, leading to altered stress distribution, chronic pain, and the potential development of traumatic arthritis. Current treatment methods, particularly those involving screws, often have drawbacks such as soft tissue irritation, damage to the fixation from weight-bearing, and the need for secondary surgeries to remove implants. While newer elastic fixation techniques exist, they can sometimes lead to implant loosening or local inflammation. This paper addresses the need for a fixation method that offers robust stability, preserves joint mobility, minimizes complications, and avoids the necessity of hardware removal.

Methods

The study introduces and evaluates a "titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system." This technique modifies existing "Endobutton" fixation by replacing linear structures with a titanium cable. The procedure involves creating two parallel bone tunnels in the fibula, through which the titanium cable and a ring are passed and tightened to reduce and fix the DTS. This aims to restore the "isotonic strength" of the syndesmosis. The system is described as being easy to operate and cost-effective.

The clinical evaluation involved 36 patients with ankle fractures and DTS injuries treated with this system between January 2015 and June 2017. Patients underwent fracture repair and DTS fixation. Post-operative management included antibiotics, pain relief, and early mobilization. Efficacy was assessed using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle function score, comparison of ankle motion with the healthy side, and radiographic evaluation of fracture healing and implant stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on a clinical trial with 36 human patients.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the gap between rigid and elastic fixation: The titanium cable system appears to offer a blend of the stability of rigid fixation (like screws) and the flexibility of elastic methods, aiming for the best of both worlds.
  • Restoring "isotonic strength": The concept of restoring "isotonic strength" suggests an emphasis on replicating the natural biomechanical properties of the DTS, rather than just rigidly immobilizing it.
  • Minimizing complications: The system is designed to avoid common issues like screw loosening, soft tissue irritation, and the need for implant removal, which are significant patient burdens.
  • Early functional recovery: The ability to tolerate weight-bearing exercises and recover joint mobility relatively quickly is a key advantage highlighted.
  • No need for hardware removal: This is a significant patient-centric benefit, reducing the need for additional surgical procedures, associated costs, and recovery time.

Key Results

  • High recovery rate: Nearly all patients (33 out of 36) achieved satisfactory recovery, as indicated by the AOFAS scoring system at 12 months post-operation, with an average score of 97.42.
  • Excellent implant stability: Post-operative X-rays at 12 months showed the titanium cables were correctly positioned without any fracture or loosening. No degeneration or traumatic arthritis was observed.
  • Minimal complications: Only three patients experienced inflammation and infection, which resolved with antibiotics and physiotherapy. No patients had delayed union or non-union.
  • Early weight-bearing: Patients began gradual weight-bearing exercises between 8-12 weeks post-operation, with most being able to bear full weight by 12 weeks.
  • Functional recovery: At 12 weeks, 23 patients showed normal ankle performance, 10 had near-normal performance, and 3 had slightly affected performance compared to their healthy side.
  • No need for removal: The study suggests no need to remove the internal fixation, although 13 patients (36.11%) requested removal after 12 months.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small sample size: The authors acknowledge that the small sample size (36 patients) limits the statistical analysis.
  • Limited follow-up time: The follow-up period of 18-25 months may not be sufficient for evaluating long-term efficacy.
  • Lack of a surgical control group: The study did not include a direct comparison group undergoing a different standard surgical procedure.

The authors plan to address these limitations by establishing a randomized controlled trial, increasing the sample size, and extending the follow-up period to further evaluate the long-term efficacy of the titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Distal tibiofibular syndesmosis injury (DTS) occurs frequently with ankle sprains. Current treatments pose several limitations including causing soft tissue irritation, bringing damage to fixation secondary to weight-bearing, and requiring follow-up surgeries. Here, we investigated the clinical effects of a new technique, titanium cable isotonic annular fixation, for the treatment of DTS injury. From January 2015 to June 2017, 36 patients with ankle fractures and DTS injuries had their fractures repaired with the titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system. Recovery was scored by the AOFAS ankle function score system. We also assessed the differences in ankle motion between healthy and operative joints, and recorded the complications. All patients recovered from surgery without any serious complications. We followed all the cases for 18-25 months with an average follow-up of 21.26±3.23 months. 12 months after the operation, X-ray images showed that the titanium cables were fixed in the correct position without any fracture or loosening. Additionally, no degeneration or traumatic arthritis was observed in the ankle joint. There were no incision or bone mineral density changes between the titanium fix and tibiofibular bones. Nearly all patients recovered well except for three who developed inflammation and infection. However, these three patients recovered following 1 week of intravenous antibiotics and local radiofrequency physiotherapy. According to the AOFAS scoring system, all patients achieved satisfactory recovery 12 months post operation. Our titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system has both the advantages of elastic and rigid fixations. It can restore isotonic strength of the distal tibiofibular joint, and its biomechanical performance approaches normal physiological function. After the operation, patients tolerated weight-bearing exercise and recovered joint mobility. Finally, there is no need to remove the distal tibiofibular implant after 12 weeks. Overall, it is a highly effective surgical method to treat DTS injury.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2019titanium,
  author = {Zhaofeng Jia and Jiwu Cheng and Hai‐Yan Zhong and Tinghui Xiao and Jinke Ren and Yimiao Lin and Wenjun Huang and Yujie Liang and Qisong Liu and Xiaoming Zhang},
  title = {{Titanium cable isotonic annular fixation system for the treatment of distal tibiofibular syndesmosis injury.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2019},
}
Figure