Tipping Point Detection and Early-Warnings in climate, ecological, and human systems

Vasilis Dakos, Chris A. Boulton, Joshua Buxton, Jesse F. Abrams, David I. Armstrong McKay, Sebastian Bathiany, Lana Blaschke, Niklas Boers, Daniel Dylewsky, Carlos López-Martínez, Isobel Parry, Paul Ritchie, Bregje van der Bolt, Larissa van der Laan, Els Weinans, Sonia Kéfi2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews the last 20 years of research on "early warning signals" (EWSs) for detecting tipping points across various scientific fields. It finds that while EWSs are increasingly applied and generally perform well, challenges remain in their interpretation and application to complex, real-world systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tipping points are critical thresholds where a system undergoes abrupt, rapid, and often irreversible changes. These events, like ecosystem collapse or abrupt climate shifts, are usually undesirable. To anticipate them, scientists have developed "early warning signals" (EWSs) – statistical indicators that detect changes in a system's behavior as it approaches a tipping point. While the theoretical basis for EWSs has been around for decades, their practical application has exploded in recent years due to increased data availability and computational power. However, there's a lack of a clear overview of where, how, and which EWSs have been successfully used in real-world case studies across diverse scientific domains. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically reviewing the empirical literature.

Methods

The authors conducted a comprehensive literature review of studies published between 2004 and 2023 that empirically applied early warning signals. They searched for publications using keywords related to tipping points and various EWS terms. From the identified papers, they extracted information on the scientific domain, system studied, type of tipping point, data source and type, specific EWS metrics used, and the reported performance of these signals. They then classified and analyzed this information to provide an overview of EWS application, success rates, and challenges.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it reviews existing empirical studies that utilized a wide range of data sources. These include:

  • Remote-sensed data: Satellite imagery (e.g., for vegetation, sea surface temperature, cryosphere).
  • Field measurements: Data from ecological surveys, weather stations, medical records, etc.
  • Laboratory experiments: Controlled studies to simulate system dynamics.
  • Palaeo-reconstructions: Historical climate data.
  • Social data: Financial data, social media data.
  • Simulated data: Used in theoretical studies and for training machine learning models.

The review highlights that temporal data is the most common type used (77.7%), followed by spatial and spatiotemporal data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Broad Applicability: EWSs, particularly those based on Critical Slowing Down (CSD), are remarkably general and can theoretically be applied to many dynamical systems, explaining their widespread adoption across diverse fields.
  • CSD Dominance: The majority of EWSs are CSD-based, relying on indicators like increased variance and autocorrelation as a system loses stability before a tipping point.
  • Performance is Generally Positive: Despite acknowledged limitations, the majority of reviewed studies reported positive performance for EWSs in detecting tipping points.
  • Domain Diversification: While ecology and climate were early adopters, the use of EWSs has significantly diversified into health, social sciences, and physical sciences.
  • Health Sector Surprise: The high number of publications in the health domain, particularly using "dynamic network biomarkers," was an unexpected finding.
  • System-Specific vs. Generic: While generic CSD-based warnings are widely used, system-specific indicators (e.g., "dynamic network biomarkers" in health, "spatial variance" in ecology) are also crucial and often show positive results.
  • Challenges Persist: Despite successes, significant conceptual, operational, and methodological challenges remain, including dealing with fast changes, multiple drivers, limited data, and the non-specificity of generic warnings.

Key Results

  • 229 Empirical Studies Reviewed: The analysis is based on 229 publications from 2004-2023 that applied EWSs empirically.
  • EWS Usage Spread: Studies first appeared in ecology and climate in 2007, with health, social sciences, and physical sciences following after 2010.
  • Dominant Domains: Ecology accounts for the largest share of studies (43.6%), followed by health (22.6%), climate (14.6%), social sciences (12%), and physical sciences (7.6%).
  • Most Used EWSs: Variance, autocorrelation, and skewness are the most frequently used EWSs.
  • Positive Performance: Approximately 67.8% of studies reported a positive performance for EWSs. Only 3.4% reported negative performance.
  • CSD vs. Non-CSD: 74.9% of reclassified EWSs were CSD-based, while 25.1% were non-CSD-based.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Publication Bias: The high success rate might be influenced by a publication bias towards positive results. * Hindsight Application: Many studies are "hindsight" applications, where EWSs are tested after a tipping point has already occurred, potentially introducing bias. * Methodological Differences: Variations in statistical methods, hypothesis testing, and significance levels across studies make direct comparisons challenging. * Non-Specificity: Generic EWSs can detect smooth, reversible transitions, not just abrupt tipping points, leading to potential misinterpretations. * Multivariate Systems: Most EWSs are designed for unidimensional systems, and their application to high-dimensional, complex systems presents significant challenges. * Tipping Cascades: Detecting cascading tipping points (where one tipping event triggers another) is particularly difficult if systems are not directly linked or if the cascade is instantaneous.

Future Work: * System-Specific Indicators: Develop and integrate more system-specific indicators to complement generic ones. * Composite Metrics: Combine multiple EWSs or integrate them with other approaches (e.g., machine learning) to improve detection and reduce false positives. * Data Availability: Leverage the increasing availability of long-term, high-resolution data, especially from remote sensing, for more robust EWS analysis. * Understanding Drivers: Investigate EWSs on system drivers themselves to distinguish between gradual transitions and external forcing. * Testing in Real-Time: Move beyond hindsight applications to test EWSs in real-time for preventive and management purposes. * Standardization: Develop standardized methodologies for applying and evaluating EWSs across different domains.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tipping points characterize the situation when a system experiences abrupt, rapid and sometimes irreversible changes. Given that such changes are in most cases undesirable, numerous approaches have been proposed to identify if a system is close to a tipping point. Such approaches have been termed early-warning signals and represent a set of methods for identifying statistical changes in the underlying behavior of a system across time or space that would be indicative of an approaching tipping point. Although the idea of early-warnings for a class of tipping points is not new, in the last two decades, the topic generated an enormous amount of interest, mainly theoretical. At the same time, the unprecedented amount of data originating from remote sensing systems, field measurements, surveys and simulated data, coupled with innovative models and cutting-edge computing, has made possible the development of a multitude of tools and approaches for detecting tipping points in a variety of scientific fields. Yet, we miss a complete picture of where, how, and which early-warnings have been used so far in real-world case studies. Here we review the literature of the last 20 years to show how the use of these indicators has spread from ecology and climate to many other disciplines. We document what metrics have been used, their success as well as the field, system and tipping point involved. We find that, despite acknowledged limitations and challenges, in the majority of the case-studies we reviewed the performance of most early-warnings was positive in detecting tipping points. Overall, the generality of the approaches employed – the fact that most early-warnings can in theory be observed on any dynamical system – explains the continuous multitude and diversification in their application across scientific domains.
BibTeX
@misc{dakos2023tipping,
  author = {Vasilis Dakos and Chris A. Boulton and Joshua Buxton and Jesse F. Abrams and David I. Armstrong McKay and Sebastian Bathiany and Lana Blaschke and Niklas Boers and Daniel Dylewsky and Carlos López-Martínez and Isobel Parry and Paul Ritchie and Bregje van der Bolt and Larissa van der Laan and Els Weinans and Sonia Kéfi},
  title = {{Tipping Point Detection and Early-Warnings in climate, ecological, and human systems}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/egusphere-2023-1773},
}
Figure