Timing of odor stimulation does not alter patterning of olfactory bulb unit activity in freely breathing rats

Erik C. Sobel, David W. TankJournal of Neurophysiology 1993 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the rhythmic firing patterns observed in the olfactory bulb (OB) of rats, which are synchronized with breathing, are primarily driven by the direct stimulation of olfactory receptors during inhalation, rather than by internal brain signals tied to respiration. This finding suggests that the OB's intrinsic circuitry plays a key role in shaping these sensory responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The olfactory bulb (OB) in mammals exhibits a fascinating phenomenon: when an animal breathes in an odor, the activity of neurons within the OB becomes highly synchronized with the animal's respiratory cycle. This "respiratory patterning" is characterized by bursts of neural firing during inhalation and suppression of activity during exhalation. At first glance, this seems straightforward – odor molecules arrive with each breath, so neural activity should follow suit. However, the suppression of activity between breaths is more profound than a simple lack of stimulation, suggesting a more active inhibitory process.

The central question this paper addresses is the origin of this respiratory patterning. Two main hypotheses exist:

  1. Intrinsic OB circuitry: The rhythmic patterns are generated by the internal feedback loops and connections within the OB itself, driven by the periodic arrival of odor.
  2. Centrifugal inputs: Signals from other parts of the brain, synchronized with respiration, actively modulate OB activity, imposing the rhythmic pattern.

Previous studies have yielded conflicting results, often due to methodological limitations like disrupting brain pathways or not precisely controlling airflow. This paper aims to resolve this by carefully decoupling nasal airflow (where odor enters) from tracheal breathing (the animal's natural breathing rhythm) to isolate the effect of odor stimulation timing.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated experimental setup involving double tracheal cannulation in freely breathing rats. This technique allowed them to:

  • Dissociate nasal airflow from tracheal breathing: One tube was inserted into the trachea for natural breathing, while another tube was placed in the back of the nasal cavity. This second tube allowed for controlled delivery and removal of air (and odor) from the nasal passages, independent of the animal's own breathing.
  • Precisely control odor delivery: Amyl acetate-saturated air was delivered to the nose. The timing of this odor delivery could be precisely shifted relative to the animal's ongoing tracheal breathing.
  • Monitor airflow: Thermocouples were used to measure both tracheal breathing and nasal airflow, providing a clear picture of the respiratory cycle and the odor stimulus.
  • Record neural activity: Microelectrodes were used to record the activity of single neurons in the olfactory bulb.

The core experimental manipulation involved systematically delaying the onset of nasal airflow (odor stimulation) relative to the animal's tracheal breathing. This allowed them to test whether the OB neuron's firing pattern shifted along with the timing of the odor stimulus.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized recordings from 43 olfactory bulb neurons in 8 male Sprague-Dawley rats.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Odor receptor stimulation is the primary driver: The most significant finding is that the timing of odor stimulation relative to the animal's breathing does not alter the respiratory patterning of OB unit activity. This strongly suggests that the pattern is a direct consequence of olfactory receptors being stimulated by inhaled air.
  • Intrinsic OB circuitry is key: The persistence of patterning, even when nasal airflow is artificially timed, points to the internal circuitry of the OB as the main generator of these rhythmic responses.
  • Centrifugal inputs are likely modulatory, not primary: While the study doesn't rule out a role for brain signals synchronized with respiration, it indicates they are not the primary mechanism for establishing the basic respiratory pattern. They might fine-tune or modulate the pattern, but the fundamental rhythm originates from the odor stimulus itself.
  • "Inspiration" is crucial, "expiration" less so: Patterning was observed even when odor was delivered in isolated "inspirations" without intervening "expirations," suggesting that the "washout" of odor during exhalation isn't essential for the observed pattern.
  • Long-term stimulation reveals complex dynamics: Applying prolonged odor pulses revealed initial bursts of activity followed by inhibition, and then a rebound effect when the odor was removed. This highlights the dynamic nature of OB responses beyond simple rhythmic firing.

Key Results

  • Out of 43 examined OB cells, 29 fired maximally after inspiration, and 14 fired maximally after expiration.
  • In all 43 cells, the patterning of OB activity was synchronized with the time course of the nasal stimulation (odor delivery).
  • Crucially, this synchronization was independent of the point in the ongoing tracheal respiratory cycle at which the odor stimulation was applied. Shifting the timing of odor delivery did not shift the timing of the neural response pattern.
  • Patterning was observed even when odor was delivered as a series of "inspirations" without expirations, and it followed the time course of the odor stimulation even when it was longer and slower than normal breathing.
  • No patterning was observed during continuous odor stimulation or in the absence of odor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Centrifugal modulation is not entirely ruled out: While the study demonstrates that centrifugal inputs are not the primary driver of respiratory patterning, it acknowledges that they might still play a role in modulating the pattern, especially in isolated OB preparations where intrinsic circuitry might behave differently.
  • Mechanism of inhibition remains unclear: The paper suggests that the suppression of activity between inspirations might be due to mechanisms with longer time constants than typical mitral-granule-mitral feedback loops, possibly acting at the glomerular level.
  • Future directions: The authors propose using their double tracheal cannulation preparation to systematically vary the frequency, intensity, and duration of odor pulses in freely breathing animals to further investigate the underlying mechanisms of patterning and explore questions like depolarization-induced inactivation or long-lasting recurrent inhibition. They also suggest that understanding these dynamics is crucial for deciphering how odor information is coded by OB units.

Summary updated

Abstract

1. The effect of the timing between nasal airflow and ongoing tracheal respiration on single-unit activity in the olfactory bulb (OB) of the rat was examined. Nasal and tracheal breathing were dissociated with the use of a double tracheal cannulation technique that allowed independent control of nasal airflow and control of the synchronization of nasal airflow and tracheal breathing. 2. When amyl acetate-saturated air was presented to the nose, OB units showed a distinct reorganization of activity known as respiratory patterning. Of 43 cells examined, 29 fired maximally after inspiration, and 14 fired maximally after expiration. In all 43 cells the patterning of OB activity was synchronized with the time course of the nasal stimulation. This synchronization was independent of the point in the ongoing respiratory cycle (tracheal breathing) at which the odor stimulation was applied. 3. Patterning of OB single-unit activity was also observed when odor was applied as a series of "inspirations" without intervening expirations. Patterning was observed to follow the time course of the odor stimulation even when this was considerably longer and slower than normal breathing. No patterning of activity was observed during continuous odor stimulation or in the absence of odor stimulation. 4. It is concluded that respiratory patterning of OB single-unit activity in the rat is not directly dependent on centrifugal inputs synchronized to respiration. Rather, the observed pattern of neural activity reflects the phasic stimulation of the olfactory receptors with each inspiration and the dynamics of the circuitry intrinsic to the bulb itself.
BibTeX
@article{sobel1993timing,
  author = {Erik C. Sobel and David W. Tank},
  title = {{Timing of odor stimulation does not alter patterning of olfactory bulb unit activity in freely breathing rats}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.1993.69.4.1331},
}

Loading related content...

Figure