Timecourse of mirror and counter-mirror effects measured with transcranial magnetic stimulation

Andrea Cavallo, Cecilia Heyes, Cristina Becchio, Geoffrey Bird, Caroline CatmurSocial 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to reveal that human "mirror responses" (where observing an action activates the same motor programs used to perform it) emerge around 200 milliseconds after action onset. Crucially, they also show that "counter-mirror" training, which reverses these responses, affects them at the same timecourse, suggesting shared neural pathways and supporting the idea that mirror systems are learned through experience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "mirror neuron system" in humans, thought to be crucial for understanding actions and intentions, has been a hot topic for decades. While we know that observing an action can activate our own motor systems, we've had a poor understanding of how quickly this happens. This temporal aspect is critical: it tells us about the efficiency of the system and potentially the neural pathways involved. Furthermore, researchers have found that this mirror response can be reversed through "counter-mirror" training. However, it was unclear if these reversed responses emerged on the same timescale as the original mirror responses. This paper aims to precisely measure the timecourse of both mirror responses and the effects of counter-mirror training, providing crucial constraints on theories of mirror neuron function and origin.

Methods

The core technique employed here is single-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). TMS allows researchers to briefly and non-invasively stimulate specific areas of the brain. By applying TMS pulses at different time points after an observed action and measuring the resulting muscle activity (motor-evoked potentials, or MEPs) in specific hand muscles, the researchers could infer when the motor system was being activated by the observed action.

A key methodological innovation is the "two-action/two-muscle" design. Participants observed videos of either an index finger abduction or a little finger abduction. TMS pulses were delivered to the motor cortex, and MEPs were recorded from both the index finger muscle (first dorsal interosseous, FDI) and the little finger muscle (abductor digiti minimi, ADM). A true "mirror response" is indicated by a differential effect: the FDI muscle should show a larger MEP when observing an index finger action (its corresponding action) compared to a little finger action, and vice-versa for the ADM. This design helps rule out non-specific motor responses or general alerting effects.

Experiment 1 focused on establishing the timecourse of the mirror response by delivering TMS at five different time points (100, 150, 200, 250, and 300 ms) after the observed action onset. Experiment 2 then investigated the timecourse of counter-mirror effects by repeating the TMS measurements at key time points (200, 250, and 320 ms) after participants underwent counter-mirror sensorimotor training.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses controlled visual stimuli (videos of hand actions) and participant responses, but does not refer to pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mirror responses aren't instantaneous: The study firmly establishes that observing an action doesn't immediately trigger a matching motor program. There's a clear temporal window, suggesting a processing delay.
  • 200 ms is the magic number: Mirror responses, as defined by the muscle-specific differential activation, reliably emerge around 200 ms after the observed action begins. Earlier effects (100-150 ms) were found to be non-specific.
  • Counter-mirror effects mirror mirror effects: The most striking finding is that the effects of counter-mirror training occur at the same time points as the original mirror responses. This strongly suggests that both phenomena rely on similar underlying neural mechanisms and pathways.
  • Support for the associative account: The shared timecourse between mirror and counter-mirror responses provides robust support for the idea that mirror neuron properties are learned through sensorimotor experience (the "associative account"), rather than being purely innate. If counter-mirror effects were significantly slower, it might suggest a more indirect, rule-based processing route.
  • Constraints on social cognition: Knowing that mirror responses take around 200 ms to manifest has implications for how quickly these systems can contribute to complex social cognitive processes like understanding intentions or empathy.

Key Results

  • Experiment 1: A significant "mirror effect" (differential MEP amplitude between muscles and observed actions) was found at 200 ms, 250 ms, and 300 ms after action onset. No significant mirror effect was detected at 100 ms or 150 ms.
  • Experiment 2: Counter-mirror sensorimotor training significantly altered the mirror effect. Crucially, this alteration was observed at all tested time points (200, 250, and 320 ms), indicating that the effects of counter-mirror training follow the same temporal dynamics as the original mirror responses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Artificial Stimuli: The study used apparent motion from static images to create action stimuli. While this was crucial for isolating the timing of the response by controlling for movement phase, it's an artificial representation of real-world actions. Future work should investigate the timecourse with more naturalistic actions.
  • Limited Muscle Specificity: While the two-action/two-muscle design is powerful, it's still limited to specific hand muscles. The broader mirror system involves many more effectors and actions.
  • Prediction's Role: The authors acknowledge that prediction can influence motor responses and potentially the observed timecourse. Future research should further explore how predictive mechanisms interact with and modulate the timing of mirror responses, especially in more naturalistic settings.
  • Complexity of Actions: The study focused on simple finger abduction. Investigating the timecourse for more complex actions (e.g., grasping, reaching) is a logical next step, as these might recruit different or more extended neural processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The human mirror system has been the subject of much research over the past two decades, but little is known about the timecourse of mirror responses. In addition, it is unclear whether mirror and counter-mirror effects follow the same timecourse. We used single-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation to investigate the timecourse of mirror and counter-mirror responses in the human brain. Experiment 1 demonstrated that mirror responses can be measured from around 200 ms after observed action onset. Experiment 2 demonstrated significant effects of counter-mirror sensorimotor training at all timepoints at which a mirror response was found in Experiment 1 (i.e. from 200 ms onward), indicating that mirror and counter-mirror responses follow the same timecourse. By suggesting similarly direct routes for mirror and counter-mirror responses, these results support the associative account of mirror neuron origins whereby mirror responses arise as a result of correlated sensorimotor experience during development. More generally, they contribute to theorizing regarding mirror neuron function by providing some constraints on how quickly mirror responses can influence social cognition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cavallo2013timecourse,
  author = {Andrea Cavallo and Cecilia Heyes and Cristina Becchio and Geoffrey Bird and Caroline Catmur},
  title = {{Timecourse of mirror and counter-mirror effects measured with transcranial magnetic stimulation}},
  booktitle = {Social},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1093/scan/nst085},
}
Figure