Time-varying optimization of COVID-19 vaccine prioritization in the context of limited vaccination capacity

Shasha Han, Jun Cai, Juan Yang, Juanjuan Zhang, Qianhui Wu, Wen Zheng, Huilin Shi, Marco Ajelli, Xiao‐Hua Zhou, Hongjie YuNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a data-driven mechanistic model to optimize COVID-19 vaccine allocation strategies in China. It demonstrates that dynamically adapting vaccination priorities to the evolving epidemic can significantly reduce infections, hospitalizations, and deaths, outperforming static or random approaches, especially with increased vaccination capacity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented a massive challenge in vaccine distribution due to limited initial capacity. Simply vaccinating randomly or following a fixed, pre-determined priority list might not be the most effective way to curb the spread and its consequences. The problem is how to best allocate a finite supply of vaccines over time to achieve multiple public health goals (like minimizing deaths and infections) as the epidemic unfolds and our understanding of the virus and vaccine effectiveness evolves. This paper specifically addresses this challenge in the context of China's vaccination campaign.

Methods

The researchers developed a data-driven mechanistic model of SARS-CoV-2 transmission. This model uses an age-structured compartmental approach, dividing the population into susceptible, vaccinated (with varying degrees of protection), infectious, and recovered states. They employed a two-step optimization strategy:

  1. Myopic Optimal Strategy: This step optimizes vaccine allocation daily to minimize immediate risk metrics (infections, symptomatic cases, hospitalizations, ICU admissions, deaths). This approach prioritizes groups with the highest current risk.
  2. Approximated Optimization: Using the results from the myopic strategy, they then optimize over the entire simulation period (400 days) to find a more globally optimal, though approximated, solution.

They also explored various scenarios, including different vaccination capacities, vaccine efficacies (including "leaky" vaccine models), age-mixing patterns, and the impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) by fixing the reproduction number (R).

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • Contact data: 2017/2018 survey data for Shanghai, China, to estimate age-specific social contact patterns. This was extrapolated to the national level using bootstrap methods.
  • Population data: World Population Prospects 2019 for China to determine age group sizes.
  • Vaccination data: Daily vaccination numbers in China from March 1, 2021, to May 8, 2021, to inform the vaccination capacity.
  • Vaccine efficacy and risk factor data: Extracted from existing literature and clinical trial data for China and other regions.
  • Vaccine hesitancy data: From a large-scale telephone survey in China and a global survey.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Time-varying strategies are crucial: The most significant finding is that dynamically adjusting vaccine priorities as the epidemic evolves is far more effective than static or random approaches. This allows for adaptation to changing risk profiles across different age groups.
  • Capacity is king (especially early on): A high vaccination capacity, particularly in the initial phase of the campaign, is critical for realizing the substantial benefits of strategic prioritization. Increasing capacity to 2.5 million first doses per day or higher can dramatically reduce the overall burden.
  • Priorities are robust: Despite variations in assumptions about vaccine efficacy, hesitancy, and transmission dynamics, the highest priority age groups remained remarkably consistent across different optimization objectives.
  • Simultaneous optimization is possible: The time-varying approach allows for achieving multiple objectives (e.g., minimizing deaths and infections) simultaneously, which is a significant advantage over single-objective strategies.

Key Results

  • Optimal prioritization strategies can dramatically reduce COVID-19 burden, preventing an estimated 87.9–93.0% of deaths and 89.7–91.1% of infections compared to no vaccination.
  • These strategies significantly outperform a uniform (random mass vaccination) approach, achieving more than 87% reduction in risk metrics compared to less than 67% for the uniform strategy.
  • Boosting vaccination capacity to 2.5 million first doses per day (0.17% rollout speed) or higher is projected to greatly reduce COVID-19 burden, especially if a new wave starts with R ≤ 1.5.
  • The highest priority categories were consistent across a broad range of assumptions, increasing confidence in their applicability.
  • A high vaccination capacity in the early phase of the campaign is key to achieving the largest gains from strategic prioritization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The study used a deterministic model, which might not fully capture the stochastic nature of early epidemic phases. They also optimized for the first dose only, assuming the second dose follows a schedule, which might not be mathematically optimal.
  • Data Extrapolation: Contact patterns from Shanghai were extrapolated to all of China, which is a simplification.
  • NPI Assumption: The analysis assumed constant NPIs maintaining R=1.5 throughout the vaccination rollout, which might not reflect real-world scenarios where NPIs are adjusted.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their modeling framework is generalizable to other countries, allowing for country-specific adaptations based on socio-demographic features, epidemic situations, vaccination capacity, and ethical/political factors. They also highlight the need to potentially adapt vaccination choices based on implemented NPIs and age-specific vaccine efficacy heterogeneity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dynamically adapting the allocation of COVID-19 vaccines to the evolving epidemiological situation could be key to reduce COVID-19 burden. Here we developed a data-driven mechanistic model of SARS-CoV-2 transmission to explore optimal vaccine prioritization strategies in China. We found that a time-varying vaccination program (i.e., allocating vaccines to different target groups as the epidemic evolves) can be highly beneficial as it is capable of simultaneously achieving different objectives (e.g., minimizing the number of deaths and of infections). Our findings suggest that boosting the vaccination capacity up to 2.5 million first doses per day (0.17% rollout speed) or higher could greatly reduce COVID-19 burden, should a new wave start to unfold in China with reproduction number ≤1.5. The highest priority categories are consistent under a broad range of assumptions. Finally, a high vaccination capacity in the early phase of the vaccination campaign is key to achieve large gains of strategic prioritizations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2021time,
  author = {Shasha Han and Jun Cai and Juan Yang and Juanjuan Zhang and Qianhui Wu and Wen Zheng and Huilin Shi and Marco Ajelli and Xiao‐Hua Zhou and Hongjie Yu},
  title = {{Time-varying optimization of COVID-19 vaccine prioritization in the context of limited vaccination capacity}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-24872-5},
}
Figure