Time-optimal Control of independent Spin-1/2 Systems under Simultaneous Control

Domenico D’Alessandro, Xinhua Peng, Yunlan Ji, Ji Bian, Min Jiang2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first analytical solution and experimental demonstration of time-optimal control (TOC) for two independent spin-1/2 particles simultaneously controlled by a single magnetic field. By combining the Pontryagin Maximum Principle with a novel symmetry reduction technique, the authors achieve significantly faster quantum operations with high fidelity, paving the way for more efficient quantum control in complex systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum computing and control, achieving operations in the shortest possible time is crucial to minimize the impact of environmental noise and decoherence. This is known as the time-optimal control (TOC) problem. While TOC has been studied for single quantum systems, finding analytical solutions for multi-spin systems, especially when all spins are controlled simultaneously by a single field, has been a significant challenge. Previous approaches often relied on numerical methods, which can be computationally intensive and prone to convergence issues. This paper tackles the problem of finding an explicit, analytical solution for the time-optimal control of two independent spin-1/2 particles under a common magnetic field, a scenario common in experiments like zero-field NMR.

Methods

The authors employ a two-pronged approach:

  1. Pontryagin Maximum Principle (PMP): This is a standard mathematical framework for solving optimal control problems. They apply it to the quantum system described by a Hamiltonian that couples two independent spin-1/2 particles to a common magnetic field. The PMP helps to derive the general form of the optimal control and trajectory.
  2. Symmetry Reduction Technique: This is the novel contribution. The authors exploit the inherent symmetries of the quantum system and the control problem. By identifying an equivalence relation on the state space (SU(2) ⊗ SU(2)), they show that many different control problems are equivalent. This allows them to reduce the number of parameters to be optimized from six to three, significantly simplifying the problem and enabling the derivation of analytical solutions. They also characterize the "orbit space" of these equivalent states, which helps in understanding the problem's structure.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize a home-built zero-field NMR spectrometer with a 13C-formic acid sample.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Analytical Solution for Multi-Spin TOC: The most significant insight is the derivation of an explicit, analytical solution for TOC in a multi-spin system under simultaneous control. This bypasses the need for computationally expensive numerical simulations.
  • Symmetry as a Powerful Simplifier: The novel symmetry reduction technique is a key enabler. By recognizing that different final states can be reached with the same optimal time and control structure through symmetry transformations, the problem's complexity is drastically reduced.
  • Time-Optimal Control as a Benchmark: The derived TOC provides a theoretical lower bound on the time required to perform specific quantum operations, serving as a benchmark for evaluating other control strategies.
  • Experimental Validation in Zero-Field NMR: Demonstrating the TOC in a real-world zero-field NMR setup validates the theoretical framework and highlights its practical applicability.

Key Results

  • Analytical Solution: The paper provides explicit formulas for the time-optimal control fields and the resulting quantum trajectories for two independent spin-1/2 particles.
  • Significant Time Reduction: Experiments showed a 70-80% decrease in experiment duration compared to existing methods.
  • High Fidelity: The implemented TOC achieved an average gate fidelity of 99%.
  • Parameter Reduction: The symmetry reduction technique reduced the number of parameters to optimize from six to three.
  • Robustness: The TOC was shown to be robust against variations in the gyromagnetic ratio and pulse imperfections.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: While the method is a significant step, scaling it to systems with more than two spins while maintaining analytical tractability remains a challenge. The authors suggest that controlling N/2 pairs of spins independently might be a way forward.
  • General Final Conditions: The paper focuses on specific final conditions (e.g., single-spin rotations). Extending the analytical solution to arbitrary final states for multi-spin systems would be a valuable future direction.
  • Pulse Distortion Correction: The authors mention that pulse distortion due to bandwidth limitations is a source of error and suggest that techniques like pre-distortion could be explored to further improve performance.
  • Incoherent Errors: While the experiments achieved high fidelity, further investigation into mitigating incoherent errors in more complex scenarios could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

We derive the explicit solution of the problem of time-optimal control (TOC) by a common magnetic fields for two independent spin-1/2 particles. Our approach is based on the Pontryagin Maximum Princple (PMP) and a novel symmetry reduction technique. We experimentally implement the optimal control via a home-built zero and ultralow filed NMR spectrometer. This is the first analytical solution and experimental demonstration of time-optimal control in such a system and it provides a route to achieve time optimal control in more general quantum systems.
BibTeX
@misc{dalessandro2019time,
  author = {Domenico D’Alessandro and Xinhua Peng and Yunlan Ji and Ji Bian and Min Jiang},
  title = {{Time-optimal Control of independent Spin-1/2 Systems under Simultaneous Control}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/the-2nd-aqe-06232},
}

Loading related content...

Figure