Time-Frequency-Energy Characteristics Analysis of Vibration Signals in Digital Electronic Detonators and Nonel Detonators Exploders Based on the HHT Method

Haojie Yin, Hui Chen, Yin Feng, Jingkun Zhao2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the vibration signals generated by digital electronic detonators (DEDs) and nonel detonators (NDs) during small-section rock tunnel excavation. Using the Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT), the study reveals that while DEDs offer superior fragmentation, NDs, due to their inherent delay errors, can induce a beneficial chaotic superposition of vibration waves, leading to an average vibration reduction of 19.4% compared to DEDs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The civil explosive industry in China is rapidly transitioning towards digital electronic detonators (DEDs) due to their precise timing and enhanced safety features. However, the high cost of DEDs presents a significant barrier to their widespread adoption. Nonel detonators (NDs), while less precise, are more economical. This paper addresses the critical need to understand and compare the vibration characteristics and blasting effects of these two detonator types, particularly in the context of small-section rock tunnel excavation, where segmented simultaneous blasting is common. The goal is to provide a more rational basis for selecting the appropriate detonator technology, balancing safety, efficiency, and cost.

Methods

The core methodology employed in this study is the Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT). HHT is chosen for its ability to analyze nonlinear and non-stationary signals, which are characteristic of blast-induced vibrations. The HHT process involves:

  1. Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD): This technique decomposes the complex vibration signal into a set of intrinsic mode functions (IMFs), each representing a distinct oscillatory mode.
  2. Hilbert Transform: Applied to each IMF, this step allows for the calculation of instantaneous frequency and amplitude.
  3. Hilbert Spectrum: This provides a time-frequency representation of the signal's energy distribution.
  4. Instantaneous Energy Spectrum: Derived from the Hilbert spectrum, this quantifies the energy over time.

Additionally, the study utilized:

  • Wavelet Soft Threshold Denoising: To clean the raw vibration signals and isolate valuable components.
  • WipFrag Software: For particle size analysis to evaluate rock fragmentation effectiveness.

Datasets

The study utilized on-site vibration data collected during actual blasting operations in the Bei-Zhan iron ore mining area in Xinjiang, China. Specific details about the number of blasting events or the total volume of data collected are not explicitly quantified as a "dataset" in the traditional machine learning sense, but rather as experimental measurements from a real-world scenario.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Delay Error as a Vibration Reducer: The most surprising finding is that the inherent delay time errors in nonel detonators, often seen as a drawback, can actually lead to a beneficial "chaotic superposition" of vibration waves. This phenomenon, when occurring within specific intervals, results in a damping effect that significantly reduces overall vibration.
  • Detonator Trade-offs: DEDs excel at precise fragmentation, leading to smaller rock sizes. However, NDs, despite their less precise timing, can offer better vibration control in certain scenarios due to their delay error-induced damping.
  • HHT's EMD for Delay Identification: The study demonstrates that by analyzing specific IMFs (IMF1 for DEDs, IMF2 for NDs) derived from EMD, the actual delay times of detonators can be identified with high accuracy, surpassing traditional methods.
  • Frequency Band Energy Distribution: DEDs concentrate their blasting energy in a narrower frequency band (60-230 Hz), while NDs distribute energy more broadly, with a significant portion at lower frequencies. This broader distribution for NDs, while not necessarily indicating better protection against resonance, suggests a different energy dissipation mechanism.

Key Results

  • Vibration Reduction: Nonel detonators achieved an average vibration reduction of 19.4% per segment compared to digital electronic detonators, attributed to the chaotic superposition of vibration waves caused by delay errors.
  • Delay Accuracy: Digital electronic detonators demonstrated high delay accuracy, with an average delay time deviation of 6.7 ms (95.7% accuracy) for the analyzed segments, and 2.9 ms (98.1% accuracy) after excluding the first segment. Nonel detonators showed a higher average delay error of 75.6 ms (84.9% accuracy), indicating less precise timing.
  • Fragmentation: Digital electronic detonators produced smaller rock fragments, with a D50/X50 value of 128.7 mm, compared to nonel detonators with a D50/X50 of 265.28 mm. This suggests DEDs are more suitable for excavation requirements.
  • Vibration Decay: The vibration wave decay rate of digital electronic detonators was approximately four times faster than that of nonel detonators.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope: The study focused on small-section rock tunnel excavation. The findings might not directly translate to large-scale open-pit mining or other blasting scenarios.
  • Detonator Cost vs. Performance: While the study highlights the vibration reduction benefits of NDs, it acknowledges that DEDs offer superior fragmentation. Future work could explore hybrid initiation strategies that combine the benefits of both.
  • Randomness of Delay Errors: The authors note that the randomness of delay time errors in NDs makes it difficult to precisely predict superposition outcomes. Further research could focus on modeling and controlling these errors to optimize vibration reduction.
  • Resonance Conditions: While NDs showed a higher proportion of low-frequency energy, the paper concludes that this doesn't definitively prove better protection against resonance damage, suggesting further investigation into resonance conditions is needed.

The paper's findings provide valuable insights for optimizing blasting operations, potentially leading to more cost-effective and safer excavation practices by strategically employing the unique characteristics of both digital electronic and nonel detonators.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{yin2023time,
  author = {Haojie Yin and Hui Chen and Yin Feng and Jingkun Zhao},
  title = {{Time-Frequency-Energy Characteristics Analysis of Vibration Signals in Digital Electronic Detonators and Nonel Detonators Exploders Based on the HHT Method}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23125477},
}
Figure