Time-dependent diffusion of water in a biologicalmodel system.

Lawrence L. Latour, Karel Svoboda, Partha P. Mitra, Christopher H. SotakProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 1994 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses pulsed-field-gradient NMR to precisely measure how water diffusion changes over time within packed red blood cells (RBCs). They developed a new model that accurately links these diffusion measurements to key biological parameters like cell membrane permeability and the volume of extracellular space, offering a potential explanation for water diffusion changes in brain ischemia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how water moves across and within biological membranes is crucial for many physiological processes, from nutrient transport to cell volume regulation. In complex biological tissues, like the brain, water diffusion is influenced by a variety of factors: the intrinsic permeability of cell membranes, the amount of space between cells (extracellular volume), and the geometry of these spaces. Accurately quantifying these factors non-invasively has been challenging. Previous models often oversimplified the system, neglecting differences in diffusion coefficients within and outside cells, or the complex geometry of extracellular pathways. This lack of precise understanding limits our ability to interpret diffusion measurements in disease states, such as cerebral ischemia, where altered water movement is a key indicator.

Methods

The researchers employed a pulsed-field-gradient spin echo (PFG-NMR) technique to measure the time-dependent diffusion coefficient of water, denoted as $D(t)$. This technique is powerful because it's non-destructive and doesn't require chemical tracers, allowing for measurements over a wide range of observation times (from milliseconds to seconds). They specifically used packed red blood cells (RBCs) as a model system because their properties (cell size, membrane permeability, and extracellular volume fraction) can be independently controlled.

A key methodological contribution is the development and application of an effective medium theory (EMT). This theory generalizes previous models by accounting for:

  • Different diffusion coefficients inside ($D_{int}$) and outside ($D_{ext}$) the cells.
  • The volume fraction of extracellular fluid ($\phi$).
  • The membrane permeability ($\kappa$).
  • The geometry of the extracellular space, including parallel diffusion pathways.

They also analyzed the short-time behavior of $D(t)$, which is theoretically linked to the surface-to-volume ratio (S/V) of the membranes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used prepared samples of human and bovine red blood cells.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Extracellular Volume is a Major Player: The long-time diffusion constant ($D_{eff}$) is highly sensitive to the extracellular volume fraction ($\phi$). This suggests that changes in $\phi$ could be a primary driver of observed diffusion changes in biological tissues.
  • EMT for Realistic Modeling: The developed effective medium theory provides a more accurate framework for interpreting diffusion measurements in packed cell systems by incorporating crucial biological parameters like membrane permeability and extracellular space geometry.
  • Explaining Ischemia: The model offers a plausible explanation for the observed drop in water diffusion in the brain during early stages of ischemia. A reduction in extracellular volume, a known consequence of ischemia, can significantly decrease the overall diffusion coefficient.
  • Non-invasive S/V Measurement: Analyzing the short-time diffusion behavior of water provides a novel, non-invasive method to determine the surface-to-volume ratio of biological membranes, a parameter difficult to measure otherwise.

Key Results

  • Membrane Permeability Estimation: Using their EMT, the researchers estimated the membrane permeability ($\kappa$) of RBCs. For sample A, they found $\kappa \approx 6.3 \times 10^{-3}$ cm/s, which is in good agreement with previous measurements on isolated RBCs.
  • Effect of PCMBS: Treatment with p-chloromercuribenzene sulfonate (PCMBS), a known inhibitor of water channels, reduced the estimated membrane permeability by about 40% (from sample A to sample B), consistent with its known mechanism.
  • Impact of Extracellular Volume: Sample C, with a significantly reduced extracellular volume fraction ($\phi \approx 0$), showed a $D_{eff}$ that was 60% lower than sample A (which had a higher $\phi$), even though their membrane permeabilities were similar. This highlights the dominant role of $\phi$.
  • Surface-to-Volume Ratio: From the short-time diffusion data of human RBCs, they estimated the surface-to-volume ratio (V/S) to be approximately $0.72 \pm 0.15 \ \mu\text{m}^{-1}$, which aligns well with microscopic measurements.
  • Ischemia Model Prediction: Using typical parameters, their model predicted a 45% drop in $D_{eff}$ when the extracellular volume fraction decreases from 0.20 to 0.11, mirroring observations in ischemic brain tissue.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geometric Simplification: The EMT was derived for spherical cells. While the authors suggest the qualitative conclusions should hold for other geometries, further work could explore more complex shapes.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The calculation of membrane permeability ($\kappa$) is highly sensitive to the extracellular volume fraction ($\phi$). Accurately determining $\phi$ in experimental preparations remains a challenge.
  • Short-Time Measurement Limits: Reaching sufficiently short observation times to fully capture the predicted $V_t$ dependence of $D(t)$ was limited by technical factors like eddy currents. Future technical improvements in PFG-NMR could allow for more precise short-time measurements.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their model and approach can be extended to study diffusion in other biological tissues and to further investigate the role of membrane permeability and extracellular space in various physiological and pathological conditions. The ability to non-invasively determine S/V ratio is also a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Packed erythrocytes are ideally suited as a model system for the study of water diffusion in biological tissue, because cell size, membrane permeability, and extracellular volume fraction can be varied independently. We used a pulsed-field-gradient spin echo NMR technique to measure the time-dependent diffusion coefficient D(t) in packed erythrocytes. The long-time diffusion constant, D(eff), depends sensitively on the extracellular volume fraction. This may explain the drop in D(eff) during the early stages of brain ischemia, where just minutes after an ischemic insult the extra-cellular volume in the affected region of the brain is significantly reduced. Using an effective medium formula, we estimate the erythrocyte membrane permeability, in good agreement with measurements on isolated cells. From the short-time behavior of D(t), we determine the surface-to-volume ratio of the cells, approximately (0.72 micron)-1.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{latour1994time,
  author = {Lawrence L. Latour and Karel Svoboda and Partha P. Mitra and Christopher H. Sotak},
  title = {{Time-dependent diffusion of water in a biologicalmodel system.}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {1994},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.91.4.1229},
}
Figure