Tighter spectral bounds for the cut size, based on Laplacian eigenvectors

Karel Devriendt, Piet Van MieghemLinear 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "constrained relaxation" method to derive tighter spectral bounds for graph cut sizes. By incorporating Laplacian eigenvector information into a standard spectral relaxation approach, the authors achieve provably better bounds for problems like the Cheeger constant, Max Cut, and epidemic spread on networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the "cut size" of a graph – essentially, the number of edges connecting two partitions of its nodes – is crucial in many areas, from network analysis to algorithm design. Finding the exact minimum or maximum cut size is computationally hard (NP-hard). Spectral graph theory offers a way to approximate these bounds using eigenvalues of the graph's Laplacian matrix. However, existing spectral methods, while useful, often lack tightness. This paper aims to improve these spectral bounds by leveraging more information from the Laplacian's eigenvectors, going beyond just the eigenvalues.

Methods

The core contribution is the Constrained Relaxation (CR) method. It builds upon the Standard Relaxation (SR) method, which relaxes a combinatorial optimization problem into a spectral one. The SR method primarily uses Laplacian eigenvalues. The CR method enhances this by adding constraints derived from the properties of Laplacian eigenvectors. This leads to a more refined optimization problem with tighter bounds. The authors also introduce a CR-K variant, which offers a trade-off between tightness and computational complexity by considering the top K eigenvalues and their corresponding eigenvectors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and uses synthetic graph examples (Barabási-Albert, Erdős-Rényi, hypercube) for simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Eigenvectors Matter: Simply using eigenvalues for spectral bounds is a good start, but incorporating information from eigenvectors can significantly improve their accuracy.
  • Constrained Relaxation: By adding eigenvector-based constraints to the relaxation process, the authors create a more informed optimization problem, leading to tighter bounds.
  • Hierarchy of Bounds: The paper establishes a clear hierarchy: Exact bounds > CR bounds > SR bounds. This provides a framework for understanding the relative tightness of different spectral approaches.
  • Applications are Broad: The improved bounds have direct implications for well-known problems like the Cheeger constant, Max Cut, and modeling epidemic spread on networks, offering more precise characterizations and predictions.
  • Degree Heterogeneity: Simulations suggest that graphs with high degree heterogeneity (like Barabási-Albert) benefit more from the CR method compared to more homogeneous graphs (like Erdős-Rényi).

Key Results

  • Provably Tighter Bounds: The paper mathematically proves that the CR bounds are at least as tight as the SR bounds, and provides conditions (Corollary 1) under which they are strictly tighter.
  • Improved Applications:
    • Cheeger Constant: Tighter lower bounds are derived.
  • Max Cut: The CR method yields tighter spectral bounds for the Max Cut problem compared to SR.
  • Expander Mixing Lemma: The CR bounds lead to tighter versions of this lemma, improving the characterization of graph expansion.
  • Epidemics: The bounds provide a more accurate way to characterize the best and worst-case spreading behavior of diseases on networks.
  • Numerical Validation: Figures 1-3 demonstrate that the CR bounds consistently outperform SR bounds in simulations on various graph types, with significant improvements observed in some cases.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Closed-form vs. Numerical: While the CR-K bounds offer closed-form expressions, achieving the absolute tightest bounds might require numerical solutions, similar to the Goemans-Williamson bound for Max Cut.
  • Hypercube Specifics: For highly structured graphs like the hypercube, specialized bounds tailored to their properties can still outperform the general CR bounds, though the CR bounds are still valuable for their generality.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests generalizing these results to directed graphs and exploring further applications in network analysis and algorithm design. The unified framework for cut-set approximations is also a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{devriendt2019tighter,
  author = {Karel Devriendt and Piet Van Mieghem},
  title = {{Tighter spectral bounds for the cut size, based on Laplacian eigenvectors}},
  booktitle = {Linear},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.laa.2019.02.025},
}
Figure