Tight Regulation of Srs2 Helicase Activity Is Crucial for Proper Functioning of DNA Repair Mechanisms

Alex Bronstein, Shay Bramson, Keren Shemesh, Batia Liefshitz, Martin KupiecG3 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that even a slight increase in the DNA helicase Srs2 levels in yeast cells can lead to DNA repair defects and sensitivity to DNA damaging agents, but only in haploid cells. This toxicity is mediated by Srs2's helicase activity, not its ability to remove Rad51, and requires the HR machinery, highlighting the critical importance of tightly regulating Srs2 levels for maintaining genome stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells are constantly exposed to DNA damage from both external and internal sources. Repairing this damage is crucial for cell survival and preventing mutations that can lead to diseases like cancer. Homologous recombination (HR) is a major DNA repair pathway, and Srs2 is a key regulator of this process. While Srs2 is known to remove the Rad51 protein from single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) to prevent unwanted recombination, its precise role and regulation are not fully understood. The authors observed that simply adding an extra copy of the SRS2 gene, which only slightly increases Srs2 protein levels, causes significant sensitivity to DNA damaging agents in yeast. This sensitivity was unexpected and prompted the investigation into the underlying mechanisms and the specific conditions under which Srs2's activity becomes detrimental.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of standard molecular biology techniques in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae):

  • Yeast Genetics: Standard techniques were used to create and manipulate yeast strains, including gene deletions and the introduction of plasmids.
  • MMS Sensitivity Assays: Yeast cells were serially diluted and spotted onto plates containing varying concentrations of methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), a DNA damaging agent, to assess their survival and growth.
  • Western Blotting: Used to confirm protein levels of Srs2 and actin (as a loading control) in different yeast strains.
  • Recombination Assays: Strains with specific reporter constructs were used to measure the rates of gene conversion (GC) and direct-repeat recombination (DRR), key outcomes of HR.
  • Quantitative PCR (qPCR): Used to measure the mRNA levels of specific genes, particularly RDH54, to understand gene expression differences.
  • Mutational Analysis: Various srs2 mutants with alterations in specific functional domains (e.g., helicase domain, Rad51 interaction site, SUMOylation motif) were created and tested for their ability to cause MMS sensitivity.
  • Cell Cycle Analysis: Microscopic examination and doubling time measurements were used to assess the impact of Srs2 overexpression on cell cycle progression.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from yeast strains and plasmids created by the researchers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Srs2's Double-Edged Sword: While Srs2 is essential for preventing unwanted recombination, its activity is so potent that even a slight increase in its levels can be toxic, especially in the context of DNA damage. This highlights the extreme precision required in its regulation.
  • Haploid vs. Diploid Sensitivity: The striking difference in MMS sensitivity between haploid and diploid yeast cells when Srs2 is overexpressed is a major finding. This suggests distinct regulatory mechanisms or cellular contexts between these ploidy states.
  • Helicase Activity is Key, Not Rad51 Removal: Contrary to some previous assumptions, the study demonstrates that Srs2's toxicity is primarily due to its helicase activity, not its ability to dismantle Rad51 filaments. This shifts the focus to how Srs2's enzymatic function, rather than its interaction with a specific protein, drives the detrimental effects.
  • The Role of RDH54 and RAD59: The identification of RDH54 and RAD59 as crucial mediators of Srs2 toxicity in haploid cells is significant. Their repression in diploids likely explains the resistance observed in diploid cells.
  • DDT Pathway Independence: The toxicity of Srs2 overexpression is independent of the DNA damage tolerance (DDT) pathway, further distinguishing it from other known roles of Srs2.

Key Results

  • MMS Sensitivity: A single extra copy of SRS2 on a centromeric plasmid caused hyper-sensitivity to MMS in haploid yeast cells, but not in diploid cells.
  • Protein Levels: The extra SRS2 copy led to only a slight increase (<10-20%) in Srs2 protein levels, indicating high sensitivity to even minor changes.
  • HR Machinery Requirement: The MMS sensitivity caused by SRS2 overexpression was abolished in strains lacking key HR genes (RAD51, RAD52, RAD55, RAD57), confirming its reliance on the HR pathway.
  • RDH54 and RAD59 Suppression: Deleting RDH54 or RAD59 in haploid cells abolished the MMS sensitivity caused by SRS2 overexpression. Expression of the diploid-specific a1/a2 complex in haploids also suppressed this sensitivity, likely by repressing RDH54.
  • Helicase-Dead Mutant: A srs2 mutant lacking ATPase activity (srs2-K41A) failed to cause MMS sensitivity, demonstrating the essential role of helicase function.
  • Rad51 Interaction Mutant: A srs2 mutant unable to interact with Rad51 (srs2(Δ875-902), L844A) still caused MMS sensitivity, decoupling the toxicity from Rad51 displacement.
  • SUMOylation/Phosphorylation Independence: Srs2 mutants deficient in SUMOylation or phosphorylation still conferred MMS sensitivity, indicating these modifications are not required for this toxic effect.
  • Recombination Inhibition: Overexpression of SRS2 reduced the MMS-induced levels of both gene conversion (GC) and direct-repeat recombination (DRR) in haploid cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Toxicity: While the study pinpoints helicase activity and the involvement of RDH54/RAD59, the precise molecular events leading to toxic intermediate formation remain to be fully elucidated. The authors propose a model where Srs2 might interfere with later stages of HR, such as strand annealing or flap processing, but further investigation is needed.
  • Diploid Resistance Mechanism: The exact reasons for diploid resistance are inferred (e.g., repression of RDH54, alternative homology sources), but a deeper understanding of how the a1/a2 complex orchestrates this resistance would be valuable.
  • Broader Implications: The study focuses on yeast. Investigating whether similar regulatory principles apply to Srs2 homologs in higher eukaryotes and their roles in DNA repair and disease would be a logical next step.
  • Specific DNA Structures: Further research could explore which specific DNA structures Srs2's helicase activity targets to cause toxicity, beyond general HR intermediates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Proper DNA damage repair is one of the most vital and fundamental functions of every cell. Several different repair mechanisms exist to deal with various types of DNA damage, in various stages of the cell cycle and under different conditions. Homologous recombination is one of the most important repair mechanisms in all organisms. Srs2, a regulator of homologous recombination, is a DNA helicase involved in DNA repair, cell cycle progression and genome integrity. Srs2 can remove Rad51 from ssDNA, and is thought to inhibit unscheduled recombination. However, Srs2 has to be precisely regulated, as failure to do so is toxic and can lead to cell death. We noticed that a very slight elevation of the levels of Srs2 (by addition of a single extra copy of the <i>SRS2</i> gene) leads to hyper-sensitivity of yeast cells to methyl methanesulfonate (MMS, a DNA damaging agent). This effect is seen in haploid, but not in diploid, cells. We analyzed the mechanism that controls haploid/diploid sensitivity and arrived to the conclusion that the sensitivity requires the activity of <i>RAD59</i> and <i>RDH54</i>, whose expression in diploid cells is repressed. We carried out a mutational analysis of Srs2 to determine the regions of the protein required for the sensitization to genotoxins. Interestingly, Srs2 needs the HR machinery and its helicase activity for its toxicity, but does not need to dismantle Rad51. Our work underscores the tight regulation that is required on the levels of Srs2 activity, and the fact that Srs2 helicase activity plays a more central role in DNA repair than the ability of Srs2 to dismantle Rad51 filaments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bronstein2018tight,
  author = {Alex Bronstein and Shay Bramson and Keren Shemesh and Batia Liefshitz and Martin Kupiec},
  title = {{Tight Regulation of Srs2 Helicase Activity Is Crucial for Proper Functioning of DNA Repair Mechanisms}},
  booktitle = {G3},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1534/g3.118.200181},
}
Figure