TIE: Time-Informed Exploration for Robot Motion Planning

Sagar Suhas Joshi, Seth Hutchinson, Panagiotis TsiotrasIEEE RA-L 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Anytime sampling-based methods are an attractive technique for solving kino-dynamic motion planning problems. These algorithms scale well to higher dimensions and can efficiently handle state and control constraints. However, an intelligent exploration strategy is required to accelerate their convergence and avoid redundant computations. Using ideas from reachability analysis, this work defines a "Time-Informed Set", that focuses the search for time-optimal kino-dynamic planning after an initial solution is found. Such a Time-Informed Set (TIS) includes all trajectories that can potentially improve the current best solution and hence exploration outside this set is redundant. Benchmarking experiments show that an exploration strategy based on the TIS can accelerate the convergence of sampling-based kino-dynamic motion planners.

Introduction

In robot motion planning, finding the fastest (time-optimal) path is a critical requirement for many real-world applications. While sampling-based planners like RRT* are effective at finding initial solutions in complex, high-dimensional spaces, they are notoriously slow at refining these solutions toward optimality.

In geometric planning—where the goal is to find the shortest distance—researchers often use an "Informed Set" (an elliptical region between start and goal) to focus the search. However, when accounting for a robot's kino-dynamics (e.g., momentum, acceleration, and differential constraints), a simple geometric ellipse fails to capture the reachable physics of the system. TIE (Time-Informed Exploration) introduces a general, efficient framework to focus the search for time-optimal paths in these complex systems.

The Time-Informed Set (TIS)

The core contribution of this work is the Time-Informed Set (TIS). Mathematically, if a current solution takes $T$ seconds, the TIS is defined as the set of all states that could potentially be part of a trajectory that takes less than $T$ seconds.

Reachability and Ellipsoidal Approximations

The TIS is constructed by the intersection of two fundamental sets:

  1. Forward Reachable Set ($\mathcal{F}$): The states the robot can reach from the start within time $t$.
  2. Backward Reachable Tube ($\mathcal{R}_b$): The states from which the robot can reach the goal within the remaining time $T-t$.
The Time-Informed Set is visualized as the intersection of the forward reachable set (red) and the backward reachable tube (blue) at various time steps $t$ for a total budget $T$.

To make this computationally feasible for online planning, the authors utilize ellipsoidal calculus to create tight over-approximations of these sets. These ellipsoids can be pre-calculated offline, allowing the planner to perform rapid reachability checks during the search process. This ensures that the sampler only generates states within the TIS and the planner only adds vertices that have the potential to improve the current best time.

Benchmarking and Results

The TIE framework was integrated with the Stable Sparse RRT (SST) planner and evaluated across several simulated environments, including a 2D toy system, an 8D high-dimensional system, a 4D moon-lander, and a 6D planar quadrotor.

A comparison of search density between uniform sampling (top) and TIE-informed sampling (bottom). TIE drastically reduces redundant computations by focusing nodes in a narrow tube between the start and goal.

Key Findings

  • Accelerated Convergence: In all test cases, TIE reached lower-cost solutions significantly earlier than uniform sampling or simpler heuristics like informed propagation.
  • Scalability: The performance benefits of TIE became more pronounced as the dimensionality of the system increased, effectively mitigating the "curse of dimensionality" that typically plagues kino-dynamic planners.
  • Theoretical Generalization: The authors proved that for simple single-integrator systems, the TIS mathematically collapses into the standard prolate hyper-spheroid (ellipse) used in geometric planning, confirming that TIE is a true generalization of state-of-the-art informed sampling methods.

Conclusion

TIE provides a robust mathematical boundary for time-optimal exploration in kino-dynamic systems. While current implementations rely on ellipsoidal approximations suited for linear-affine systems, future work explores the use of Deep Learning (e.g., DeepReach) to learn value functions for highly non-linear systems. This would allow TIE to be applied to robots with even more complex physics, maintaining focused exploration without the computational burden of solving Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations online.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{joshi2021tie,
  author = {Sagar Suhas Joshi and Seth Hutchinson and Panagiotis Tsiotras},
  title = {{TIE: Time-Informed Exploration for Robot Motion Planning}},
  journal = {IEEE RA-L},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/lra.2021.3064255},
}
Figure