Tidal Flushing Rather Than Non-Point Source Nitrogen Pollution Drives Nutrient Dynamics in A Putatively Eutrophic Estuary

Johannes R. Krause, Michelle Gannon, Autumn Oczkowski, Morgan Schwartz, Lena K. Champlin, David Steinmann, Martha Maxwell-Doyle, Emily Pirl, Victoria M. Allen, Elizabeth WatsonWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses stable isotope analysis of carbon and nitrogen in Barnegat Bay, New Jersey, to reveal that tidal flushing, rather than non-point source pollution, is the primary driver of nutrient dynamics. The findings challenge conventional wisdom by showing that urban areas in the bay are not dominated by anthropogenic runoff, and highlight the critical role of oceanic exchange in maintaining water quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pinpointing the sources and impacts of non-point source nutrient pollution in estuaries is a significant challenge. These diffuse sources, like agricultural runoff and urban wastewater, can lead to eutrophication, causing issues such as harmful algal blooms, oxygen depletion, and habitat degradation. Traditional monitoring methods often struggle to disentangle the complex interplay of nutrient inputs, processing, and water movement within these systems. This paper aims to provide a more nuanced understanding of nutrient dynamics in the Barnegat Bay-Little Egg Harbor-Great Bay (BB-LEH-GB) system, a reportedly eutrophic estuary, by using stable isotopes to trace nutrient sources and pathways.

Methods

The researchers employed stable isotope analysis of carbon (δ<sup>13</sup>C) and nitrogen (δ<sup>15</sup>N) in various environmental samples, including sediment, suspended particulate matter (SPM), primary producers (plants), and consumers (animals). They collected samples from 35 stations across the BB-LEH-GB system, dividing it into four distinct geographic zones based on hydrological connectivity, bathymetry, and residence time. In addition to modern samples, they analyzed historical plant and shell samples dating back to the late 1800s to assess temporal trends. This isotopic data was integrated with water quality measurements and hydrological data (residence time, flushing characteristics) to create "isoscapes" (maps of isotopic distributions) and identify nutrient sources and processing pathways. Statistical analyses, including ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis tests, were used to determine significant differences in isotopic values between zones.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • Modern Samples: Collected in the summers of 2019 and 2020 from 35 assessment points in tidal wetlands and open water of the BB-LEH-GB system. This included SPM, soil, various plant species (e.g., Spartina alterniflora, Phragmites australis), and animal species (e.g., blue crab, mud snail, fiddler crab).
  • Historical Samples: Archival plant specimens (late 1800s to early 1940s) and mollusk shells (1880 to 1975) from museum collections.
  • Water Quality Data: Collected during this study (2019-2020) from tidal marsh channels and from open bay water (2018-2021) provided by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP).
  • Hydrological Data: Information on tidal prism, residence times, and flushing characteristics from previous studies and historical maps.
  • Landcover Data: From NOAA C-CAP and NJ DEP for the BB-LEH-GB watershed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tidal Flushing Dominates: The study strongly suggests that tidal flushing and oceanic exchange are the primary drivers of nutrient dynamics and water quality in Barnegat Bay, rather than direct non-point source pollution from urban areas.
  • Urban Areas Not Dominated by Runoff: Counterintuitively, the most urbanized and poorly flushed northern part of the estuary showed lower δ<sup>15</sup>N values, indicating that anthropogenic runoff is not the dominant nitrogen source there.
  • Oceanic Influence on Nitrogen: Nitrogen isotopes (δ<sup>15</sup>N) were most enriched near oceanic inlets, suggesting a significant contribution from offshore sources.
  • Historical Nitrogen Trends: Over time, δ<sup>15</sup>N values in the bay have decreased, particularly in consumers, which may reflect changes in oceanic influence, flushing, or the introduction of synthetic fertilizers.
  • Isoscapes as Powerful Tools: The study demonstrates the utility of combining carbon and nitrogen isoscapes with hydrological data to understand complex estuarine nutrient cycling and identify spatial and temporal patterns.

Key Results

  • The study identified four distinct geographic zones within the BB-LEH-GB system, each with unique isotopic baselines for carbon and nitrogen.
  • Carbon isotopes (δ<sup>13</sup>C) showed a clear terrestrial-to-marine gradient, with depleted values upstream and enriched values near oceanic inlets.
  • Nitrogen isotopes (δ<sup>15</sup>N) were generally enriched near oceanic inlets and depleted in areas with higher nutrient loading and longer residence times.
  • Historical samples showed higher δ<sup>15</sup>N values compared to modern samples, suggesting a shift in nutrient sources or processing over time.
  • The findings indicate that water quality issues are most pronounced in the poorly flushed areas of Barnegat Bay, reinforcing the importance of flushing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Atmospheric Deposition: The study acknowledges that atmospheric deposition of nitrogen was not directly measured but suggests it could be important for the nitrogen budget and that its isotopic composition would benefit future assessments.
  • Dissolved Nutrients: The authors note that analyzing stable isotope ratios of dissolved nutrients would have further enhanced their ability to identify nutrient sources and processing pathways.
  • Wastewater vs. Fertilizer: While wastewater discharge was historically significant, the study suggests that modern wastewater inputs are largely decoupled from nutrient enrichment in the northern bay. The role of fertilizer-derived nitrogen, while regulated, could be further investigated.
  • Future Hydrological Alterations: The study emphasizes the need for careful consideration of flushing and residence times when planning future alterations to the BB-LEH-GB's hydrologic conditions, such as inlet modifications or tidal control structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The effects of nonpoint source nutrients on estuaries can be difficult to pinpoint, with researchers often using indicator species, monitoring, and models to detect influence and change. Here, we made stable isotope measurements of nitrogen and carbon in sediment, water column particulates, primary producers, and consumers at 35 stations in the reportedly eutrophic Barnegat Bay (New Jersey) to assess N sources and processing pathways. Combined with water quality and hydrological data, our C and N isoscapes revealed four distinct geographic zones with diverging isotopic baselines, indicating variable nutrient sources and processing pathways. Overall, the carbon stable isotopes δ<sup>13</sup>C) reflected the terrestrial-marine gradient with the most depleted values in the urban and poorly flushed north of the estuary to the most enriched values in the salt marsh-dominated south. In contrast, the nitrogen stable isotope values δ<sup>15</sup>N) were most enriched near the oceanic inlets and were consistent with offshore δ<sup>15</sup>N values in particulate organic matter. Several biogeochemical processes likely alter δ<sup>15</sup>N, but the relatively lower δ<sup>15</sup>N values associated with the most urbanized area indicate that anthropogenic runoff is not a dominant N source to this area. Our findings stand in contrast to previous studies of similar estuaries, as δ<sup>15</sup>N signatures of biota in this system are inversely correlated to population density and nutrient concentrations. Further, our analyses of archival plant (<i>Spartina</i> sp., <i>Phragmites australis</i>) and shell (<i>Geukensia demissa, Ilyanassa obsoleta</i>) samples collected between 1880 and 2020 indicated that δ<sup>15</sup>N values have decreased over time, particularly in the consumers. Overall, we find that water quality issues appear to be most acute in the poorly flushed parts of Barnegat Bay and emphasize the important role that oceanic exchange plays in water quality and associated estuarine food webs in the lagoon.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{krause2022tidal,
  author = {Johannes R. Krause and Michelle Gannon and Autumn Oczkowski and Morgan Schwartz and Lena K. Champlin and David Steinmann and Martha Maxwell-Doyle and Emily Pirl and Victoria M. Allen and Elizabeth Watson},
  title = {{Tidal Flushing Rather Than Non-Point Source Nitrogen Pollution Drives Nutrient Dynamics in A Putatively Eutrophic Estuary}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w15010015},
}
Figure