Through your eyes: incongruence of gaze and action increases spontaneous perspective taking

Tiziano Furlanetto, Andrea Cavallo, Valéria Manera, Barbara Tversky, Cristina BecchioFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2013 · DOI

Abstract

What makes people spontaneously adopt the perspective of others? Previous work suggested that perspective taking can serve understanding the actions of others. Two studies corroborate and extend that interpretation. The first study varied cues to intentionality of eye gaze and action, and found that the more the actor was perceived as potentially interacting with the objects, the stronger the tendency to take his perspective. The second study investigated how manipulations of gaze affect the tendency to adopt the perspective of another reaching for an object. Eliminating gaze cues by blurring the actor's face did not reduce perspective-taking, suggesting that in the absence of gaze information, observers rely entirely on the action. Intriguingly, perspective-taking was higher when gaze and action did not signal the same intention, suggesting that in presence of ambiguous behavioral intention, people are more likely take the other's perspective to try to understand the action.

Introduction

When observing another person in a spatial environment, we often spontaneously adopt their coordinate system—a phenomenon known as Spontaneous Perspective Taking (SPT). For instance, if a person sitting across from you asks where an object is, you might describe its position from their "left" rather than your "right." While previous research established that the mere physical presence of a human body is insufficient to trigger SPT, the specific triggers—particularly the roles of eye gaze and hand actions—remained poorly understood. This research explores whether SPT serves a functional role in resolving behavioral ambiguity, essentially acting as a tool to "step into someone else's shoes" when their intentions are difficult to decipher.

Methods

The researchers conducted two behavioral experiments using 525 undergraduate students at the University of Turin. Moving beyond the static photographs common in previous literature, this study utilized dynamic video clips (approximately 4 seconds) to provide realistic cues of intentionality.

Experiment 1: Agency Levels

Participants (n=120) were shown one of four video conditions to test how increasing levels of perceived agency affected perspective taking:

  1. No Actor: A milk carton and a glass on a table.
  2. Static Actor: A person sitting behind the table, looking down.
  3. Gaze Only: The actor looks toward the glass.
  4. Gaze + Action: The actor looks toward and then reaches for the glass.

Experiment 2: Gaze-Action Congruency

Participants (n=405) watched videos where the relationship between gaze and action was manipulated:

  1. Congruent: Actor looks at and reaches for the glass.
  2. Blurred Gaze: Actor reaches for the glass, but their face is blurred to remove gaze information.
  3. Incongruent (Ambiguous): Actor reaches for the glass while looking in a different direction.
Experimental setup showing the actor and objects used in the video stimuli.

In both experiments, participants were asked a simple spatial question: "In relation to the glass, where is the milk carton?" Responses were categorized as First Person Perspective (1PP), Third Person Perspective (3PP), or Neutral.

Key Results

The Impact of Intentionality

Experiment 1 demonstrated a clear linear relationship between the actor's perceived intentionality and the likelihood of the observer adopting their perspective. While the "No Actor" condition yielded 0% 3PP responses, the presence of a static actor triggered 30% 3PP. This increased to 36.7% with gaze cues and peaked at 43.3% when both gaze and reaching actions were present.

The Ambiguity Boost

Experiment 2 revealed a counterintuitive finding: SPT was most frequent when the actor's behavior was ambiguous. When the actor reached for the glass while looking elsewhere (Incongruent condition), 3PP responses rose to 51.1%—the highest rate recorded in the study. In contrast, the Congruent condition (40.7%) and the Blurred condition (42.2%) showed significantly lower rates of perspective taking.

Discussion and Insights

SPT as Action Simulation

The findings reinforce the theory that perspective taking is a form of "embodied simulation." We do not merely observe a body; we mentally simulate their potential for interaction. The use of dynamic video likely contributed to higher overall SPT rates compared to previous studies using static images, as the unfolding of an action provides a more powerful social prime.

Resolving Behavioral Conflict

The "Ambiguity Boost" suggests that SPT is a cognitive resource deployed to resolve conflict. When gaze and action are mismatched, the observer's brain must work harder to understand the actor's goal. Adopting the actor's spatial perspective appears to be a mechanism used to make sense of these conflicting social signals.

Gaze vs. Action Priority

The results indicate that while gaze is a powerful cue, action is the primary driver of SPT. When gaze was removed via blurring, observers relied entirely on the hand action. However, when gaze was present but incongruent, it created a "functional necessity" for perspective taking to resolve the resulting ambiguity.

Limitations and Future Work

While these studies provide robust evidence for the functional role of SPT, they utilized relatively simple, non-social actions (reaching for milk). Future research should explore whether these effects scale to complex social interactions or high-stakes scenarios. Additionally, investigating "second-person" interactions—where the actor interacts directly with the observer—could reveal if interaction partner status further amplifies the tendency to adopt another's viewpoint.

Summary updated

Abstract

What makes people spontaneously adopt the perspective of others? Previous work suggested that perspective taking can serve understanding the actions of others. Two studies corroborate and extend that interpretation. The first study varied cues to intentionality of eye gaze and action, and found that the more the actor was perceived as potentially interacting with the objects, the stronger the tendency to take his perspective. The second study investigated how manipulations of gaze affect the tendency to adopt the perspective of another reaching for an object. Eliminating gaze cues by blurring the actor's face did not reduce perspective-taking, suggesting that in the absence of gaze information, observers rely entirely on the action. Intriguingly, perspective-taking was higher when gaze and action did not signal the same intention, suggesting that in presence of ambiguous behavioral intention, people are more likely take the other's perspective to try to understand the action.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{furlanetto2013through,
  author = {Tiziano Furlanetto and Andrea Cavallo and Valéria Manera and Barbara Tversky and Cristina Becchio},
  title = {{Through your eyes: incongruence of gaze and action increases spontaneous perspective taking}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2013.00455},
}
Figure