Threshold Switching Enabled Sub-pW-Leakage, Hysteresis-Free Circuits

Bojun Cheng, Alexandros Emboras, Elias Passerini, Mila Lewerenz, Ueli Koch, Lianbo Wu, Jiawei Liao, Fabian Ducry, Jan Aeschlimann, Taekwang Jang, Mathieu Luisier, Juerg LeutholdIEEE Transactions on Electron Devices 2021 · DOI

Abstract

In this article, we present ultralow leakage logic circuits by combining 3-D memristors with CMOS transistors. Significant leakage current reductions of up to 99% are found by experiments and simulation for a memristive hybrid-inverter if compared with a conventional inverter. Likewise, circuit simulations of memristive hybrid ring oscillators, NAND, or full adders show more than 100% gain in energy efficiency per cycle over state-of-the-art circuits. Importantly, the memristive circuits offer hysteresis-free operation. The hysteresis-free operation is due to properly engineered properties—such as the threshold voltage—of the memristors to match the circuit, as well as the self-adaptive filament diameter of our memristor during operation. Lastly, the memristors feature a $10^8$ ON-OFF ratio, enabling both high speed and low leakage (~10 fA) when integrated with a transistor. They also come with a well-controlled filament formation on a ~10-nm footprint, making them ideal to integrate with modern CMOS technology transistors.

Introduction: The Challenge of Static Leakage

As semiconductor technology scales down, transistors become increasingly "leaky." Even in an idle state, a small amount of current flows through CMOS circuits, a phenomenon largely dictated by the "Boltzmann Tyranny." This physical limit prevents standard transistors from switching "off" more sharply than 60 mV/decade at room temperature. For Internet of Things (IoT) devices that spend the vast majority of their lifespan in standby mode, this static power consumption is the primary bottleneck for battery life.

While "steep-slope" transistors have been proposed as a solution, they frequently suffer from hysteresis—a state where the turn-on and turn-off voltages differ. This behavior complicates logic design, making circuit behavior unpredictable. This paper introduces a hybrid approach using 3-D threshold-switching (TS) memristors to achieve sub-pW leakage without the drawbacks of hysteresis.

Device Architecture and Integration

The researchers developed a 3-D filamentary TS memristor designed for seamless integration with standard CMOS processes. The device structure consists of a silver (Ag) tip, a silicon dioxide ($SiO_2$) matrix, and a platinum (Pt) base.

3D schematic and TEM cross-section of the filamentary memristor showing the ~10-nm footprint.

This memristor is placed in series with the source of a standard nFET. It acts as a volatile switch: when the voltage across it reaches a specific threshold, a metallic filament forms, making it highly conductive (ON). When the voltage drops, the filament dissolves, returning the device to an insulating state (OFF) with an extremely low leakage current of approximately 10 fA. Because the $SiO_2$ matrix is used, these devices can be fabricated in the Back-End-of-Line (BEOL), saving valuable silicon area.

Electrical Characteristics and Hysteresis-Free Logic

The hybrid technology leverages a $10^8$ ON/OFF ratio to ensure high-speed operation while active and near-zero power consumption when idle. A key innovation is achieving hysteresis-free logic from inherently hysteretic memristive components.

Electrical characterization of the TS memristor: (a) I-V hysteresis loop, (b) self-adaptive voltage behavior, and (c) resistance switching over applied current.

The authors engineered the memristor's threshold voltage to align precisely with the circuit's switching point. Furthermore, the filament diameter is self-adaptive; it adjusts to the current required by the circuit while maintaining a constant voltage drop ($V_{m,hold}$). This self-regulation ensures clean logic transitions without the "lag" usually associated with memristive switching.

Performance Benchmarks

The study utilized experimental I-V characterization and Verilog-A modeling to simulate complex circuits, including 11-stage ring oscillators and NAND gates, using a 22-nm FD-SOI process. Performance was compared against standard CMOS-only circuits designed for identical power and speed targets.

  • Leakage Reduction: Experimental hybrid inverters demonstrated a 99% reduction in static leakage compared to conventional CMOS.
  • Energy Efficiency: Simulations showed over 100% gain in energy efficiency per clock cycle for NAND gates and Full Adders operating in near-threshold regimes (0.26 V to 0.4 V).
  • IoT Applicability: For low-frequency sampling (below 1 kHz), the hybrid circuits can save more than 50% of total energy.

Limitations and Future Outlook

Despite the significant gains, some challenges remain. The addition of a memristor in series introduces a small voltage drop ($V_{m,hold} \approx 0.12 V$), which slightly degrades the output voltage swing. Additionally, there is a physical filament formation delay of approximately 10 ps. While negligible for ultra-low-power IoT applications, this may limit use in high-performance computing. Future work will focus on tuning nFET thresholds to compensate for swing loss and evaluating the long-term endurance of these 3-D structures over billions of cycles.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this article, we present ultralow leakage logic circuits by combining 3-D memristors with CMOS transistors. Significant leakage current reductions of up to 99% are found by experiments and simulation for a memristive hybrid-inverter if compared with a conventional inverter. Likewise, circuit simulations of memristive hybrid ring oscillators, NAND, or full adders show more than 100% gain in energy efficiency per cycle over state-of-the-art circuits. Importantly, the memristive circuits offer hysteresis-free operation. The hysteresis-free operation is due to properly engineered properties-such as the threshold voltage-of the memristors to match the circuit, as well as the self-adaptive filament diameter of our memristor during operation. Lastly, the memristors feature a 10 <sup xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">8</sup> ON- OFF ratio, enabling both high speed and low leakage (~10 fA) when integrated with a transistor. They also come with a well-controlled filament formation on a ~10-nm footprint, making them ideal to integrate with modern CMOS technology transistors.
BibTeX
@article{cheng2021threshold,
  author = {Bojun Cheng and Alexandros Emboras and Elias Passerini and Mila Lewerenz and Ueli Koch and Lianbo Wu and Jiawei Liao and Fabian Ducry and Jan Aeschlimann and Taekwang Jang and Mathieu Luisier and Juerg Leuthold},
  title = {{Threshold Switching Enabled Sub-pW-Leakage, Hysteresis-Free Circuits}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/ted.2021.3075393},
}
Figure