Three-state nematicity and magneto-optical Kerr effect in the charge density waves in kagome superconductors

Yishuai Xu, Zhuoliang Ni, Yizhou Liu, Brenden R. Ortiz, Stephen D. Wilson, Binghai Yan, Leon Balents, Liang Wu, Wu, LiangarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered that kagome superconductors ($AV_3Sb_5$) undergo a dramatic "double" symmetry breaking at the onset of their charge density wave (CDW) phase. Using high-precision optical microscopy, the team demonstrated that these materials simultaneously break six-fold rotational symmetry (becoming "nematic") and time-reversal symmetry, providing strong evidence for the existence of exotic orbital loop currents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The kagome lattice—a pattern of corner-sharing triangles—is a playground for condensed matter physicists because its geometry naturally leads to "frustration," where electronic charges and spins can't easily settle into a standard state. Recently discovered kagome metals ($AV_3Sb_5$, where $A$ is Potassium, Rubidium, or Cesium) are particularly exciting because they exhibit both superconductivity and charge density waves (CDWs)—a periodic modulation of electron density.

However, two major debates have divided the community:

  1. Rotational Symmetry: Does the CDW phase maintain the lattice's original six-fold ($C_6$) symmetry, or does it break down into a two-fold ($C_2$) "nematic" state? Previous scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) studies saw nematicity only at very low temperatures, leaving it unclear if this was a fundamental property of the CDW itself.
  2. Time-Reversal Symmetry (TRS): Does the CDW state break TRS? Breaking TRS usually implies magnetism, but these materials have no local magnetic moments. Theorists have proposed "loop currents"—tiny circles of electricity flowing between atoms—as a way to break TRS without traditional magnetism, but direct evidence has been elusive.

Methods

The authors employed a suite of high-sensitivity, micron-scale optical probes to study single crystals of $KV_3Sb_5$, $RbV_3Sb_5$, and $CsV_3Sb_5$:

  • Scanning Birefringence Microscopy: This technique measures how the material changes the polarization of reflected light. If the material is six-fold symmetric, the signal should be isotropic; if it's nematic ($C_2$), the signal varies as the polarization angle rotates.
  • Polar Magneto-Optical Kerr Effect (MOKE): A classic probe for TRS breaking. It measures the tiny rotation of light's polarization caused by internal magnetic fields or orbital currents.
  • Circular Dichroism (CD): This measures the difference in how the material reflects left-handed vs. right-handed circularly polarized light. This was used to confirm that the TRS breaking was a bulk property and to rule out simple structural chirality.

Datasets

The study did not use external machine learning datasets. Instead, it generated original experimental data across the three chemical variants of the kagome superconductor family ($A = K, Rb, Cs$). The data includes spatial maps of birefringence and temperature-dependent plots of MOKE and CD signals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simultaneous Onset: The most striking finding is that rotational symmetry breaking and TRS breaking occur exactly at the same temperature ($T_{CDW} \approx 80\text{--}100\text{ K}$). This suggests that nematicity and loop currents are intrinsic, intertwined features of the CDW phase.
  • Three-State Nematicity: The researchers found three distinct types of domains, each oriented 120° apart. This "three-state" behavior confirms the system is choosing one of three equivalent directions, breaking the $C_6$ symmetry.
  • The $\pi$-Phase Shift Model: To explain how a $2 \times 2$ superlattice (which is normally $C_6$ symmetric) could appear nematic, the authors propose a "staggered" stacking model. If the CDW pattern in one layer is shifted by a phase of $\pi$ relative to the layer below it, the overall bulk symmetry is reduced to two-fold.
  • Evidence for Loop Currents: Because the MOKE and CD signals appear without any detectable magnetic moments, the results point directly toward the long-sought chiral flux CDW—a state where orbital loop currents create a tiny, spontaneous magnetic flux.

Key Results

  • Universal Behavior: All three compounds ($K, Rb, Cs$) showed the same symmetry-breaking patterns, proving this is a fundamental characteristic of the $AV_3Sb_5$ family.
  • Domain Imaging: The team successfully imaged nematic domains on the scale of 100 µm. This explains why macroscopic transport measurements often see "smeared" results—they are averaging over multiple domains.
  • Quantitative MOKE: The MOKE signals were small but clear (e.g., ~0.27 mRad in $RbV_3Sb_5$), indicating a very weak but persistent TRS-breaking order parameter.
  • Centrosymmetry Confirmed: Using Second Harmonic Generation (SHG), they confirmed the crystals remain centrosymmetric, ruling out structural "handedness" as the cause of the circular dichroism and reinforcing the TRS-breaking conclusion.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper provides strong evidence for loop currents, the microscopic pinning mechanism—why the MOKE signal keeps the same sign even after cooling the sample multiple times—remains a mystery. The authors suggest some unknown defect or internal strain might be "training" the domains.

Furthermore, while this study clarifies the nature of the CDW phase, the interplay with superconductivity remains the next frontier. If the CDW breaks TRS, it could lead to "unconventional" superconductivity, where the electron pairs themselves might inherit this broken symmetry. Future experiments will likely focus on how these loop currents evolve as the material transitions into its superconducting state at even lower temperatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The kagome lattice provides a fascinating playground to study geometrical frustration, topology and strong correlations. The newly-discovered kagome metals AV$_3$Sb$_5$ (where A can refer to K, Rb, or Cs) exhibit phenomena including topological band structure, symmetry-breaking charge-density waves and superconductivity. Nevertheless, the nature of the symmetry breaking in the charge-density wave phase is not yet clear, despite the fact that it is crucial in order to understand whether the superconductivity is unconventional. In this work, we perform scanning birefringence microscopy on all three members of this family and find that six-fold rotation symmetry is broken at the onset of the charge-density wave transition in all these compounds. We show that the three nematic domains are oriented at 120$^\circ$ to each other and propose that staggered charge-density wave orders with a relative $π$ phase shift between layers is a possibility that can explain these observations. We also perform magneto-optical Kerr effect and circular dichroism measurements. The onset of both signals is at the transition temperature, indicating broken time-reversal symmetry and the existence of the long-sought loop currents in that phase.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2022three,
  author = {Yishuai Xu and Zhuoliang Ni and Yizhou Liu and Brenden R. Ortiz and Stephen D. Wilson and Binghai Yan and Leon Balents and Liang Wu and Wu, Liang},
  title = {{Three-state nematicity and magneto-optical Kerr effect in the charge density waves in kagome superconductors}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2204.10116},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.10116},
}
Figure