Three Gorges Dam: friend or foe of riverine greenhouse gases?

Jinren Ni, Haizhen Wang, Tao Ma, Rong Huang, Philippe Ciais, Zhe Li, Yue Yao, Jinfeng Chen, Bin Li, Yuchun Wang, Maosheng Zheng, Ting Wang, Alistair G.l. BorthwickNational 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Contrary to the common assumption that large dams are significant greenhouse gas (GHG) emitters, this study reveals that the Three Gorges Dam (TGD) has led to a substantial decrease in CO2, CH4, and N2O emissions along the 4300 km Yangtze River. This reduction is attributed to complex physical and biogeochemical adjustments both upstream and downstream of the dam, highlighting the critical need for whole-system analyses of dam impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The prevailing view is that large dams, particularly reservoirs, act as significant sources of greenhouse gases (GHGs) like carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O). This perception stems from the altered environmental conditions within reservoirs, which can promote GHG production. However, most previous studies have focused on the immediate vicinity of reservoirs, neglecting the broader, long-term impacts on the entire river system. This paper addresses the question of whether the world's largest dam, the Three Gorges Dam (TGD), aligns with this general understanding or if its impact extends beyond the reservoir area in a way that might alter the overall GHG balance of the river. The authors aim to provide a comprehensive, whole-river assessment of the TGD's influence on GHG fluxes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess GHG fluxes across the 4300 km Yangtze River. They utilized a 30-year dataset (1990-2015) of water quality indices from 43 hydrological stations.

  • CO2 Calculation: Dissolved CO2 concentrations were calculated using the well-established CO2SYS model.
  • CH4 and N2O Estimation: Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) were developed and trained to estimate dissolved CH4 and N2O concentrations. The ANNs for CH4 used inputs such as chemical oxygen demand, dissolved oxygen, water temperature, pH, and nitrogen species. For N2O, inputs included NH4+, NO2-, NO3-, dissolved oxygen, water temperature, and pH.
  • GHG Flux Calculation: Both dissolved and emitted GHG fluxes were estimated. Emission rates were measured using the static floating chamber technique, and concentrations were determined using gas chromatography. The air-water interface flux was calculated using a two-layer diffusive gas exchange model, with the gas transfer coefficient (k600) being a key parameter.
  • Spatial and Temporal Analysis: The study analyzed both temporal trends (before and after TGD operation in 2003) and spatial variations along the river's main stem and its tributaries.

Datasets

  • Water Quality Data: Monthly water quality monitoring data collected by the Changjiang Water Resources Commission from 1990 to 2015, encompassing 43 hydrological stations. This included parameters like pH, total alkalinity, HCO3-, water temperature, pCO2, and dissolved CO2.
  • GHG Measurements: Simultaneous sampling of hydrological, environmental, and GHG constituents was conducted in spring and autumn of 2014 along the 4300 km stretch. Additional monthly sampling occurred from November 2014 to September 2015 at six stations.
  • Literature Data: Data from previous studies conducted at certain sites along the Yangtze River were incorporated to supplement the datasets, particularly for model establishment and validation.
  • Atmospheric CH4 Data: Monthly averaged global background atmospheric CH4 concentrations were obtained from the NOAA/CMDL/CCGG air sampling network.
  • Wind Speed Data: Wind speed data near hydrological stations were extracted from the China Meteorological Data Sharing Service System.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Large-Dam Effects" are Spatiotemporally Extensive: The study strongly suggests that the impacts of large dams like the TGD are not confined to the immediate reservoir area but can significantly alter biogeochemical processes over hundreds or even thousands of kilometers downstream.
  • Complex Interactions Drive GHG Changes: The observed reductions in GHG emissions are not due to a single factor but a complex interplay of physical (e.g., altered flow velocity, riverbed scouring) and biogeochemical (e.g., carbonate equilibrium shifts, changes in methanogenesis and denitrification) processes.
  • Upstream vs. Downstream Contrasts: While GHG emissions (particularly CH4) increased upstream of the TGD due to reservoir conditions, the downstream effects, driven by factors like riverbed scouring, led to a net decrease in overall emissions for the entire river system.
  • Importance of Whole-System Budgeting: The findings underscore the critical need for comprehensive, whole-system analyses when evaluating the environmental impacts of large infrastructure projects like dams, rather than focusing solely on localized effects.

Key Results

  • Significant GHG Reduction: The TGD has caused significant drops in annual average emissions of CO2, CH4, and N2O over the 4300 km Yangtze River stretch.
  • Reduced Export to Sea: Annual export of CO2, CH4, and N2O to the sea has decreased by 79%, 50%, and 9%, respectively.
  • CO2 Dynamics: Annual average pCO2 in the mainstream dropped from 2526 μatm (pre-2003) to 1336 μatm (post-2003). This decline was most pronounced in the middle and lower reaches.
  • CH4 Dynamics: While CH4 increased upstream, there was a net reduction of approximately 17% along the whole mainstream after TGD impoundment. Emitted CH4 flux decreased from 3.3 to 2.7 Gg C yr⁻¹.
  • N2O Dynamics: N2O flux emissions over the mainstream decreased from 0.44 to 0.41 Gg N yr⁻¹. Dissolved N2O concentrations also declined, particularly in the middle reach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge that their results are based on models (CO2SYS, ANNs) and empirical formulas, and sensitivity analyses were performed to address uncertainties.
  • Future Work: The paper highlights the need for continued monitoring and research to fully understand the long-term, system-wide impacts of large dams on GHG emissions and biogeochemical cycles. The authors suggest that future research should focus on the complex interactions between physical and biogeochemical processes to refine our understanding of these impacts. The study also implies that understanding the "offset distance" where dam-induced GHG increases are balanced by downstream reductions is crucial for future dam planning and management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dams are often regarded as greenhouse gas (GHG) emitters. However, our study indicated that the world's largest dam, the Three Gorges Dam (TGD), has caused significant drops in annual average emissions of CO<sub>2</sub>, CH<sub>4</sub> and N<sub>2</sub>O over 4300 km along the Yangtze River, accompanied by remarkable reductions in the annual export of CO<sub>2</sub> (79%), CH<sub>4</sub> (50%) and N<sub>2</sub>O (9%) to the sea. Since the commencement of its operation in 2003, the TGD has altered the carbonate equilibrium in the reservoir area, enhanced methanogenesis in the upstream, and restrained methanogenesis and denitrification via modifying anoxic habitats through long-distance scouring in the downstream. These findings suggest that 'large-dam effects' are far beyond our previous understanding spatiotemporally, which highlights the fundamental importance of whole-system budgeting of GHGs under the profound impacts of huge dams.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ni2022three,
  author = {Jinren Ni and Haizhen Wang and Tao Ma and Rong Huang and Philippe Ciais and Zhe Li and Yue Yao and Jinfeng Chen and Bin Li and Yuchun Wang and Maosheng Zheng and Ting Wang and Alistair G.L. Borthwick},
  title = {{Three Gorges Dam: friend or foe of riverine greenhouse gases?}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwac013},
}
Figure