Three-Dimensional Visualization and Characterization of Polymeric Self-Assemblies by Transmission Electron Microtomography

Hiroshi Jinnai, Takeshi Higuchi, Xiaodong Zhuge, Akihito Kumamoto, Kees Joost Batenburg, Yuichi IkuharaAccounts 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Self-assembling structures in polymeric systems, specifically block copolymers (BCPs), have been investigated using three-dimensional transmission electron microtomography (3D-TEM). BCPs form nanoscale periodic structures known as microphase-separated structures, which are critical for developing high-performance membranes and data storage media. As these structures become increasingly complex, 3D imaging is required for accurate characterization. This article demonstrates that 3D-TEM is an essential tool for studying BCP nanostructures, particularly during dynamical order-order transitions (OOTs) and under confined conditions. By utilizing advanced reconstruction algorithms and contrast enhancement techniques, the authors move toward real-time 3D structural observation of polymer materials.

Introduction

Block copolymers (BCPs) are the architects of the nanoworld, spontaneously self-assembling into periodic structures such as spheres, cylinders, and gyroids. These morphologies are vital for next-generation technologies, including high-density data storage and filtration membranes. However, traditional 2D TEM imaging often fails to capture the complexity of these 3D volumes, as it collapses a complex volume into a flat projection. Characterizing "frustrated" phases or dynamic transitions requires a more robust 3D approach.

Schematic of block copolymer self-assembled morphologies including perforated lamella, double gyroid, cylinder, and Fddd structures.

Methodology

The researchers employed 3D-TEM, which involves tilting a specimen through a wide range of angles to capture 2D projections for computational 3D reconstruction. To study dynamic processes like OOTs, the authors used a "snapshot" technique, freezing the polymer mid-transition to image the boundary between phases.

To overcome the limitations of beam-sensitive soft materials, two key developments were implemented:

  1. Unstained STEM Imaging: By optimizing Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) parameters, contrast was generated based on density differences between polymer blocks, avoiding the structural alterations caused by heavy-metal stains.
  2. TVR-DART Algorithm: The introduction of the Total Variation Regularized Discrete Algebraic Reconstruction Technique allowed for high-quality 3D images from as few as 21 projections. This resulted in a 70-fold reduction in electron dose compared to conventional methods.

Results and Discussion

The application of 3D-TEM revealed that phase transitions in polymers are path-dependent. In the transition between double gyroid and cylindrical structures, the epitaxial relationship changes depending on the direction of the transition. Specifically, in thin-film OOTs, the {121} plane of a gyroid transforms into hexagonally perforated lamellar (HPL) layers.

3D-TEM snapshots showing the boundary structures and transitions between different microphase-separated morphologies.

Furthermore, BCPs under confinement (e.g., within cylindrical pores or spherical nanoparticles) exhibit "frustrated" morphologies that do not exist in bulk. These include single and double helices and "tennis ball" structures. 3D-TEM snapshots provided excellent agreement with theoretical Monte Carlo and cell dynamics simulations, validating these complex 3D mappings.

Conclusion

3D-TEM is a definitive tool for unlocking the secrets of polymer self-assembly. While current studies focus on static snapshots of dynamic processes, the reduction in electron dose achieved through TVR-DART and the elimination of staining protocols bring the field closer to true in situ, real-time 3D observation (4D-TEM). Future work will integrate these techniques with specialized sample stages to watch polymer "nanomachines" assemble in real-time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Self-assembling structures and their dynamical processes in polymeric systems have been investigated using three-dimensional transmission electron microscopy (3D-TEM). Block copolymers (BCPs) self-assemble into nanoscale periodic structures called microphase-separated structures, a deep understanding of which is important for creating nanomaterials with superior physical properties, such as high-performance membranes with well-defined pore size and high-density data storage media. Because microphase-separated structures have become increasingly complicated with advances in precision polymerization, characterizing these complex morphologies is becoming increasingly difficult. Thus, microscopes capable of obtaining 3D images are required. In this article, we demonstrate that 3D-TEM is an essential tool for studying BCP nanostructures, especially those self-assembled during dynamical processes and under confined conditions. The first example is a dynamical process called order-order transitions (OOTs). Upon changing temperature or pressure or applying an external field, such as a shear flow or electric field, BCP nanostructures transform from one type of structure to another. The OOTs are examined by freezing the specimens in the middle of the OOT and then observing the boundary structures between the preexisting and newly formed nanostructures in three-dimensions. In an OOT between the bicontinuous double gyroid and hexagonally packed cylindrical structures, two different types of epitaxial phase transition paths are found. Interestingly, the paths depend on the direction of the OOT. The second example is BCP self-assemblies under confinement that have been examined by 3D-TEM. A variety of intriguing and very complicated 3D morphologies can be formed even from the BCPs that self-assemble into simple nanostructures, such as lamellar and cylindrical structures in the bulk (in free space). Although 3D-TEM is becoming more frequently used for detailed morphological investigations, it is generally used to study static nanostructures. Although OOTs are dynamical processes, the actual experiment is done in the static state, through a detailed morphological study of a snapshot taken during the OOT. Developing time-dependent nanoscale 3D imaging has become a hot topic. Here, the two main problems preventing the development of in situ electron tomography for polymer materials are addressed. First, the staining protocol often used to enhance contrast for electrons is replaced by a new contrast enhancement based on chemical differences between polymers. In this case, no staining is necessary. Second, a new 3D reconstruction algorithm allows us to obtain a high-contrast, quantitative 3D image from fewer projections than is required for the conventional algorithm to achieve similar contrast, reducing the number of projections and thus the electron beam dose. Combining these two new developments is expected to open new doors to 3D in situ real-time structural observation of polymer materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jinnai2017three,
  author = {Hiroshi Jinnai and Takeshi Higuchi and Xiaodong Zhuge and Akihito Kumamoto and Kees Joost Batenburg and Yuichi Ikuhara},
  title = {{Three-Dimensional Visualization and Characterization of Polymeric Self-Assemblies by Transmission Electron Microtomography}},
  booktitle = {Accounts},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.accounts.7b00103},
}
Figure