Three-Dimensional Turbulent Simulation of Bivariate Normal Distribution Protection Device

Jing Liu, Zongyu Li, Hanming Huang, Weiwei Lin, Zhilin Sun, Fanjun ChenJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel bridge pier scour protection device shaped like a bivariate normal distribution (BND) and simulates its effectiveness using a 3D turbulent model. The BND significantly reduces downflow, vortex intensity, and bed shear stress compared to traditional conical protection, offering a more robust solution for preventing bridge scour.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bridge piers are vulnerable to scour, a process where flowing water erodes the riverbed around them, potentially compromising bridge stability. Existing scour protection methods, while helpful, have limitations, particularly in managing complex flow patterns like horseshoe vortices and intense shear stresses. This paper addresses the need for more effective and adaptable scour protection by proposing and evaluating a new "Bivariate Normal Distribution" (BND) shaped device. This design aims to better deflect water flow and mitigate the forces that cause scour.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional turbulent simulation using the SST k-ω model, a standard approach for modeling complex fluid flows. To validate their numerical model, they conducted physical experiments using conical surfaces as a benchmark. The simulation focused on analyzing key flow characteristics: longitudinal water flow, downflow, vorticity intensity, and shear stress. They compared the performance of their novel BND device against a traditional conical protection device. The BND's shape was mathematically defined by a bivariate normal distribution function, allowing for precise geometric modeling.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations and physical model experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The BND's Shape Matters: The unique concave shape of the BND, derived from a normal distribution, is key to its effectiveness. It allows for a smoother transition of water flow, preventing abrupt changes that can lead to scour.
  • Downflow Mitigation: The BND significantly reduces the intensity and alters the distribution of the downflow in front of the pier, a primary driver of scour.
  • Vortex Suppression: The BND is much more effective at weakening the horseshoe vortex, a powerful swirling flow that erodes the riverbed. The main vortex flux within the BND was found to be 33% lower than in a conical surface.
  • Shear Stress Reduction: The BND dramatically lowers the maximum bed shear stress and, crucially, reduces the area where high shear stress occurs, especially at the edges, thus preventing edge scouring.
  • Gradual Boundary Layer Separation: Unlike the abrupt separation seen with conical surfaces, the BND promotes a gradual boundary layer separation, leading to more stable flow and less scouring potential.

Key Results

  • Downflow Velocity: Peak downflow velocity in front of the pier was approximately 70% of the longitudinal flow velocity, occurring within a relative water depth of (-0.45, 0.67).
  • Vortex Flux: The main vortex flux within the BND was 33% lower than that within a conical surface.
  • Maximum Shear Stress Coefficient: The BND achieved a maximum shear stress coefficient of 9, effectively isolating the bed from high shear stress.
  • Edge Shear Stress: The edge shear stress of the BND was only one-third of that of the conical surface, significantly reducing the risk of edge scouring.
  • Width Optimization: Expanding the BND width beyond 4 times the pier diameter showed diminishing returns in terms of scour protection, suggesting an optimal range for practical application.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study primarily focuses on numerical simulations of the surface and does not include sediment transport modeling. This means the direct impact of sediment-laden flow on scour was not investigated. Additionally, the current research is limited to circular bridge piers, and the application potential for other pier shapes has not been explored. Future work should focus on incorporating sediment transport, testing the BND design on various pier shapes, and exploring its performance under different hydrodynamic and sedimentary conditions. The authors also suggest that future research should consider the cost-effectiveness of wider BNDs to achieve optimal protection.

Summary updated

Abstract

In response to the deficiencies in existing bridge pier scour protection technologies, this paper introduces a novel protective device, namely a normal distribution-shaped surface (BND) protection devices formed by rotating a concave normal curve. A three-dimensional turbulent SST k−ω model is constructed, and physical model experiments of conical surfaces are conducted to validate the mathematical model. The simulation analyzes longitudinal water flow, downflow, vorticity intensity, and shear stress within normal and conical surfaces. The results show that the downflow distribution in front of the pier spans a relative water depth of (−0.45, 0.67), with a peak velocity approximately 70% of the longitudinal flow velocity. Circulation forms within the surfaces, with the main vortex flux inside the BND being 33% lower than that inside the conical surface. The maximum shear stress coefficient inside the BND can reach 9, and the protective surface isolates the bed from the flow to prevent scouring by high shear stress. The velocity gradient at the edge of the surface is small, and the edge shear stress of the 3D normal distribution-shaped surface (BND) protection device is only one-third of that of the conical surface, preventing edge scouring. The large shear stress and its distribution area decrease monotonically with the increase in surface width. When the surface width is four times the diameter, the distribution range of the shear stress coefficient greater than 1 is very small. The study of three-Dimensional turbulence within the BND provides a numerical basis for an anti-scour design.
BibTeX
@article{liu2024three,
  author = {Jing Liu and Zongyu Li and Hanming Huang and Weiwei Lin and Zhilin Sun and Fanjun Chen},
  title = {{Three-Dimensional Turbulent Simulation of Bivariate Normal Distribution Protection Device}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse12040602},
}
Figure