Three-dimensional shock tube flows for dense gases

Alberto GuardoneJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel numerical method for simulating three-dimensional, non-ideal gas flows, specifically focusing on the formation of "rarefaction shock waves" in dense gases. The study reveals that even with an imperfect diaphragm burst in a shock tube, these exotic waves can form, though their strength is reduced compared to ideal scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical gasdynamics describes shock waves as either compression waves or isentropic expansion waves. However, for certain fluids, particularly those near their liquid-vapor critical point (often termed BZT fluids), the fundamental derivative of gasdynamics, $\Gamma$, can be negative. This condition allows for the existence of "non-classical" waves, including rarefaction shock waves, which behave differently from their classical counterparts.

Experimental investigations of these non-classical phenomena, especially in shock tubes, are challenging. Preliminary trials have shown that the imperfect bursting of a shock tube diaphragm, a common occurrence, introduces significant three-dimensional disturbances. These disturbances complicate the clear observation and interpretation of non-classical wave behavior, making it difficult to isolate and study phenomena like rarefaction shocks. This paper aims to address this by developing and applying a robust numerical method to simulate these complex, three-dimensional, non-ideal gas flows, specifically focusing on the impact of a partial diaphragm burst.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of a novel numerical scheme for solving the three-dimensional Euler equations for non-ideal fluids. Key aspects of the methodology include:

  • Non-Ideal Thermodynamics: The scheme is designed to handle complex thermodynamic models beyond the ideal gas assumption. Specifically, it employs the Martin-Hou equation of state, which is suitable for modeling dense gases near their saturation curve.
  • Edge-Based Finite-Volume Scheme: A standard finite-volume method is used on unstructured grids to discretize the Euler equations.
  • Extended Roe Linearization: A significant contribution is the generalization of the Roe linearization technique to accommodate arbitrary non-ideal thermodynamic models. This is crucial for accurately capturing the behavior of non-classical waves. The method involves solving a system of equations to determine an intermediate state for the Roe matrix.
  • Iterative Newton Method: For solving the non-linear equations arising from the non-ideal thermodynamics, an iterative Newton method is employed. This method is applied to determine the intermediate temperature and specific volume.
  • Entropy Fix: The Harten & Hyman entropy fix is utilized to ensure the correct physical behavior of the numerical solution, particularly for non-classical waves.
  • Three-Dimensional Simulation: The numerical scheme is applied to a fully three-dimensional computational domain, which is essential for capturing the complex flow structures resulting from an asymmetric diaphragm burst.

Datasets

The paper uses experimental data for validation and comparison.

  • Dilute Air Shock Tube Data: Numerical simulations for air under dilute gas conditions are compared with experimental results from Persico et al. (2005) to validate the numerical methodology and the treatment of imperfect diaphragm bursts.
  • Dense Gas (PP10) Shock Tube Experiment: The study is motivated by and aims to interpret preliminary experimental results from a dense gas shock tube experiment involving fluid PP10, as reported by Fergason (2001) and Fergason et al. (2003).

No new datasets are introduced; rather, existing experimental data is used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-Classical Waves from Imperfect Bursts: The simulations demonstrate that even a partial, non-instantaneous diaphragm burst in a shock tube can lead to the formation of a rarefaction shock wave (RSW), a non-classical phenomenon.
  • Three-Dimensional Effects: The asymmetry of a partial diaphragm burst creates significant three-dimensional flow structures, including vortex shedding and diffracted waves, which influence the overall wave field.
  • RSW Strength Reduction: The pressure jump across the rarefaction shock wave formed from a partial diaphragm burst is predicted to be weaker (approximately 19% less) than that from a complete burst.
  • Negative Mass Flow Peculiarity: The occurrence of negative mass flow through the rarefaction shock wave leads to a limited interaction with the contact surface near the diaphragm, a distinct characteristic of non-classical regimes.
  • Numerical Scheme Robustness: The developed numerical scheme is capable of handling complex non-ideal thermodynamics and three-dimensional geometries, providing a valuable tool for studying these phenomena.
  • Experimental Challenges: The study highlights that experimental measurements of wave speed can be affected by pressure disturbances past the RSW, stemming from wave reflections at the tube surface, which can reduce measurement accuracy.

Key Results

  • The numerical simulations successfully reproduce the qualitative features of dilute gas shock tube flows with partial diaphragm bursts, showing good agreement with experimental data for air.
  • For dense gas (PP10) simulations with a partial diaphragm burst, the formation of a single rarefaction shock front is observed sufficiently far from the diaphragm.
  • The pressure difference across the rarefaction shock wave resulting from a partial burst is found to be 0.81 atm, compared to 1.00 atm for a complete burst.
  • The wave speed and Mach number for the rarefaction shock wave are similar for both partial and complete bursts (31.61 m/s, Mach 1.014 for partial vs. 31.70 m/s, Mach 1.017 for complete).
  • The simulations reveal that the compression wave following the rarefaction shock wave does not coalesce into a compression shock in the non-classical regime, but rather spreads out.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Diaphragm Dynamics: The current simulations assume an instantaneous or simplified diaphragm opening and do not fully model the complex fluid-diaphragm interaction during the burst. This is noted as a potential source of discrepancy, especially in the near-field.
  • Thermodynamic Model Accuracy: The accuracy of the Martin-Hou model for fluid PP10, particularly near the critical point and saturation curve, is acknowledged as potentially questionable, which could affect the precise predictions of $\Gamma$ and other thermodynamic properties.
  • Grid Resolution: While grid convergence studies were performed, the paper notes that for certain complex phenomena like Mach reflection, the grid resolution might be insufficient to capture all details.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future experimental investigations of non-classical shock tube flows of dense gases should consider more reliable diaphragm opening mechanisms, such as fast-opening valves, to improve repeatability and reduce the impact of diaphragm dynamics. Further research could also explore the influence of viscosity and thermal conductivity on these flows.

Summary updated

Abstract

The formation process of a non-classical rarefaction shock wave in dense gas shock tubes is investigated by means of numerical simulations. To this purpose, a novel numerical scheme for the solution of the Euler equations under non-ideal thermodynamics is presented, and applied for the first time to the simulation of non-classical fully three-dimensional flows. Numerical simulations are carried out to study the complex flow field resulting from the partial burst of the shock tube diaphragm, a situation that has been observed in preliminary trials of a dense gas shock tube experiment. Beyond the many similarities with the corresponding classical flow, the non-classical wave field is characterized by the occurrence of anomalous compression isentropic waves and rarefaction shocks propagating past the leading rarefaction shock front. Negative mass flow through the rarefaction shock wave results in a limited interaction with the contact surface close to the diaphragm, a peculiarity of the non-classical regime. The geometrical asymmetry does not prevent the formation of a single rarefaction shock front, though the pressure difference across the rarefaction wave is predicted to be weaker than the one which would be obtained by the complete burst of the diaphragm.
BibTeX
@article{guardone2007three,
  author = {Alberto Guardone},
  title = {{Three-dimensional shock tube flows for dense gases}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1017/s0022112007006313},
}
Figure