Three-Dimensional Modeling for the Internal Shorting Caused Thermal Runaway Process in 20Ah Lithium-Ion Battery

Xinyu Liu, Zhifu Zhou, Wei‐Tao Wu, Linsong Gao, Yang Li, Heng Huang, Zheng Huang, Yubai Li, Yongchen SongEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a 3D numerical model to simulate thermal runaway in a 20Ah lithium-ion battery caused by internal short circuits. The study reveals that while the short circuit's area, penetration depth, and position have minor impacts, its resistance and the external convective heat transfer coefficient significantly influence thermal runaway propagation, with higher heat dissipation being key to suppression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lithium-ion batteries are crucial for modern technologies like electric vehicles, but their safety, particularly concerning thermal runaway, remains a significant challenge. Thermal runaway is a dangerous self-accelerating chain reaction that can lead to fires or explosions. Internal short circuits are a major contributor to this phenomenon, often stemming from manufacturing defects or mechanical abuse. Understanding the precise mechanisms and influential factors of internal short-circuit-induced thermal runaway is vital for designing safer batteries and preventing catastrophic failures. While previous studies have explored this, a comprehensive 3D simulation that couples electrochemical and thermal models to analyze the impact of various internal short circuit parameters on a large-format battery is still needed.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-scale, multi-domain (MSMD) modeling approach within ANSYS Fluent. This involved two main stages:

  1. Electrochemical Modeling (ECM): An Equivalent Circuit Model (ECM) was used to simulate the initial electrochemical reactions and heat generation during the internal short circuit. This stage captures the abrupt temperature and voltage changes at the onset of the short.
  2. Thermal Runaway Modeling: Following the ECM stage, a four-reaction thermal runaway model was activated. This model simulates the subsequent exothermic reactions that drive the rapid temperature increase and propagation of thermal runaway.

The internal short circuit itself was simulated using a "patch" function in ANSYS Fluent, representing it as a high-rate discharge with extremely low resistance. The study then systematically varied several parameters: internal short circuit area, resistance, penetration depth, convective heat transfer coefficient, and short circuit position, to observe their effects on thermal runaway.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The model parameters were derived from existing literature (Refs [40-48]).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Convection is King for Suppression: The most impactful finding is that a high convective heat transfer coefficient (representing efficient cooling) can significantly suppress thermal runaway propagation. This highlights the importance of effective thermal management systems.
  • Resistance is a Major Driver: Conversely, a lower internal short circuit resistance leads to higher short-circuit current, more heat generation, and thus a greater risk and severity of thermal runaway.
  • Area, Depth, and Position Matter Less (Relatively): The study found that the size of the short circuit area, how deep it penetrates, and its exact location within the battery have a comparatively minor influence on the overall thermal runaway process, especially in the initial stages.
  • Coupled Modeling is Crucial: The paper emphasizes the need for a coupled electrochemical-thermal model to accurately capture the entire thermal runaway process, from the initial short circuit to the subsequent chain reactions.

Key Results

  • Internal Short Circuit Area: The average cell temperature showed minimal impact from changes in the short circuit area in the initial 50 seconds. After this, temperature increased proportionally with area, indicating more heat generation in larger short circuits.
  • Internal Short Circuit Resistance: As resistance increased, short-circuit current and heat generation decreased, leading to lower average battery temperatures. This effect was significant, with lower resistances causing much higher peak temperatures.
  • Internal Short Circuit Penetration Depth: The average temperature increased with penetration depth, but the effect was weak, with 50% and 75% penetration yielding very similar results. The maximum temperature remained largely unaffected across different depths.
  • Convective Heat Transfer Coefficient: Increasing the convective heat transfer coefficient dramatically reduced thermal runaway propagation. A coefficient of 100 W/(m²·K) showed significant runaway, while higher values (up to 10,000 W/(m²·K)) effectively suppressed it, keeping temperatures below 500K.
  • Internal Short Circuit Position: The position had a minimal impact on electrochemical characteristics and thermal runaway, with the middle position showing slightly higher average temperatures compared to corner positions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Achieving High Convection: The authors note that achieving the high convective heat transfer coefficients that effectively suppress thermal runaway is challenging in real-world cell surfaces.
  • Experimental Validation: While the model was validated against a thermal abuse experiment (acupuncture), further experimental validation for internal short circuit scenarios would strengthen the findings.
  • Simplified Internal Short Circuit: The internal short circuit was modeled as a simplified patch with a defined resistance. More complex models could incorporate the evolving nature of internal shorts.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that understanding these factors is crucial for developing strategies to suppress thermal runaway propagation and reduce the frequency of battery accidents. Future work could focus on optimizing thermal management systems based on these insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Better understanding of how internal short circuit causes thermal runaway will benefit the engineering for safer lithium-ion batteries. In this study, three-dimensional (3D) numerical simulations of a 20Ah lithium battery under internal shorting condition are performed. The effects of internal short circuit area, resistance, penetration depth, convective heat transfer coefficient and internal short circuit position, on the thermal runaway are investigated with the simulations in this work. This study demonstrates that the average cell temperature is only weakly affected by the internal short circuit area, penetration depth, and position. On the other hand, the internal short circuit resistance and the convective heat transfer coefficient have large impacts on the thermal runaway propagation in the lithium-ion battery. A high convective heat transfer coefficient can effectively suppress the thermal runaway propagation. However, such a high convective heat transfer coefficient is hard to achieve at the cell surface.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022three,
  author = {Xinyu Liu and Zhifu Zhou and Wei‐Tao Wu and Linsong Gao and Yang Li and Heng Huang and Zheng Huang and Yubai Li and Yongchen Song and Yubai Li and Yongchen Song},
  title = {{Three-Dimensional Modeling for the Internal Shorting Caused Thermal Runaway Process in 20Ah Lithium-Ion Battery}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15196868},
}
Figure