Three-Dimensional Fully π-Conjugated Macrocycles: When 3D-Aromatic and When 2D-Aromatic-in-3D?

Ouissam El Bakouri, Dariusz W. Szczepanik, Kjell Jorner, Rabia Ayub, Patrick Bultinck, Miquel Solà, Henrik OttossonJournal of the American Chemical Society 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper clarifies the definition of "3D-aromaticity" in π-conjugated molecules. The authors argue that many recently reported 3D-aromatic macrocycles are actually "2D-aromatic-in-3D," meaning they possess 2D aromatic circuits within a 3D structure, rather than true three-dimensional aromaticity. This distinction is crucial for understanding and designing novel aromatic systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The concept of aromaticity, traditionally associated with planar molecules like benzene, has been extended to more complex, three-dimensional structures. However, the term "3D-aromaticity" has been applied broadly to various systems exhibiting electron delocalization in three dimensions. This has led to ambiguity and a lack of a strict, universally accepted definition. Specifically, researchers have debated whether certain puckered or cage-like π-conjugated macrocycles, which exhibit significant electron delocalization and sometimes satisfy electron counting rules like 6n+2, are truly 3D-aromatic or simply 2D-aromatic systems embedded in a 3D framework. This paper aims to resolve this ambiguity by proposing a rigorous theoretical framework and applying it to analyze these complex molecules.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of qualitative theoretical analysis and quantum chemical calculations.

  • Qualitative Theory: They build upon established concepts of 2D aromaticity (Hückel's rule) and the theoretical underpinnings of true 3D-aromaticity, which requires specific orbital degeneracies (at least triply degenerate MOs) and symmetry properties.
  • Quantum Chemical Calculations: They utilize density functional theory (DFT) with the B3LYP functional and the 6-311G(d,p) basis set for geometry optimizations and electronic structure calculations. For selected species, they also employ the CAM-B3LYP functional.
  • Aromaticity Descriptors: To assess aromatic character, they use a suite of computational tools:
  • Electron Density of Delocalized Bonds (EDDB): This method quantifies electron delocalization, which is considered a key indicator.
  • Nucleus-Independent Chemical Shifts (NICS): Used to probe magnetic aromaticity.
  • Anisotropy of Induced Current Density (ACID) plots and Gauge-Including Magnetically Induced Currents (GIMIC): These techniques visualize and quantify magnetically induced ring currents.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical analysis and computational modeling of specific molecular structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strict Definition of 3D-Aromaticity: The paper proposes four necessary conditions for true 3D-aromaticity: (i) at least triply degenerate MOs (or similar orbital topology), (ii) a closed-shell electronic structure with a 6n+2 electron count (for specific symmetries), (iii) extensive electron delocalization involving the entire molecule, and (iv) similar electronic and magnetic properties in all three spatial directions.
  • "2D-Aromatic-in-3D" Classification: Many previously labeled "3D-aromatic" macrocycles, like compounds 1-3 and their derivatives, are reclassified as "2D-aromatic-in-3D." This means their aromaticity arises from the presence of multiple 2D Hückel-aromatic circuits within their three-dimensional structures, rather than true 3D delocalization.
  • Naphthalene Analogy: These "2D-aromatic-in-3D" macrocycles are shown to be expanded versions of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) like naphthalene, where the π-electron delocalization follows pathways analogous to those in 2D systems.
  • Coincidental 6n+2 Counts: The paper highlights that for macrocycles with three tethers of equal length, the π-electron count can coincidentally be 6n+2, mimicking a criterion for 3D-aromaticity, but this does not imply true 3D aromaticity.
  • Challenges in Designing True 3D-Aromatics: Designing molecules that meet all criteria for true 3D-aromaticity is extremely challenging, particularly in achieving the required orbital degeneracies and ensuring radial π-orbital orientation without compromising delocalization.
  • Size Limitation for Aromaticity: The study suggests a potential size limitation for achieving certain types of aromaticity, similar to observations in spherical aromaticity.

Key Results

  • Compounds 1-3 and their related species (e.g., 1⁶⁺) are reclassified as "2D-aromatic-in-3D," not truly 3D-aromatic. Their aromatic character stems from multiple 2D Hückel-aromatic circuits.
  • The electron counts of 6n+2 in some of these macrocycles are found to be coincidental, arising from structural symmetry rather than inherent 3D aromaticity.
  • Computational analyses (EDDB, NICS, ACID) consistently show that while these molecules exhibit significant electron delocalization, it is primarily confined to 2D-like pathways within the 3D framework.
  • Attempts to design truly 3D-aromatic π-conjugated molecules, particularly tetrahedral and cubic structures, face significant hurdles in achieving the necessary orbital degeneracies and radial electron delocalization.
  • Species like P₄ and Si₄⁴⁻, previously considered 3D-aromatic based on NICS values, show negligible electron delocalization according to EDDB, questioning their classification.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the B3LYP functional may overestimate aromaticity, but argues this is appropriate for strong conclusions.
  • The design of truly 3D-aromatic π-conjugated molecules remains a significant challenge, with no experimentally realized long-lived species identified to date.
  • The paper notes that the definition of 3D-aromaticity needs to be placed on a solid foundation to maintain its utility.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors emphasize the need for designing and analyzing new compounds that push the boundaries of chemical bonding understanding.
  • Further exploration into designing molecules that meet the strict criteria for true 3D-aromaticity is suggested, particularly focusing on achieving the necessary symmetry and orbital properties.
  • The paper calls for a more rigorous definition and application of the term "3D-aromaticity" to ensure its meaningfulness in chemical bonding analyses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Several fully π-conjugated macrocycles with puckered or cage-type structures were recently found to exhibit aromatic character according to both experiments and computations. We examine their electronic structures and put them in relation to 3D-aromatic molecules (<i>e.g.</i>, <i>closo</i>-boranes) and to 2D-aromatic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Using qualitative theory combined with quantum chemical calculations, we find that the macrocycles explored hitherto should be described as 2D-aromatic with three-dimensional molecular structures (abbr. 2D-aromatic-in-3D) and not as truly 3D-aromatic. 3D-aromatic molecules have highly symmetric structures (or nearly so), leading to (at least) triply degenerate molecular orbitals, and for tetrahedral or octahedral molecules, an aromatic closed-shell electronic structure with 6<i>n</i> + 2 electrons. Conversely, 2D-aromatic-in-3D structures exhibit aromaticity that results from the fulfillment of Hückel's 4<i>n</i> + 2 rule for each macrocyclic path, yet their π-electron counts are coincidentally 6<i>n</i> + 2 numbers for macrocycles with three tethers of equal lengths. It is notable that 2D-aromatic-in-3D macrocyclic cages can be aromatic with tethers of different lengths, <i>i.e.</i>, with π-electron counts different from 6<i>n</i> + 2, and they are related to naphthalene. Finally, we identify tetrahedral and cubic π-conjugated molecules that fulfill the 6<i>n</i> + 2 rule and exhibit significant electron delocalization. Yet, their properties resemble those of analogous compounds with electron counts that differ from 6<i>n</i> + 2. Thus, despite the fact that these molecules show substantial π-electron delocalization, they cannot be classified as true 3D-aromatics.
BibTeX
@article{bakouri2022three,
  author = {Ouissam El Bakouri and Dariusz W. Szczepanik and Kjell Jorner and Rabia Ayub and Patrick Bultinck and Miquel Solà and Henrik Ottosson},
  title = {{Three-Dimensional Fully π-Conjugated Macrocycles: When 3D-Aromatic and When 2D-Aromatic-in-3D?}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.1c13478},
}

Loading related content...

Figure