Theta operators, refined delta conjectures, and coinvariants

Michele D’Adderio, Alessandro Iraci, Anna Vanden WyngaerdCINECA IRIS Institutial Research Information System (University of Pisa) 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new family of "Theta operators" that allow the authors to propose refined versions of existing conjectures in the field of symmetric functions, specifically the Delta conjecture. These new conjectures have implications for understanding coinvariant spaces and have connections to combinatorial objects like Dyck paths.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of symmetric functions is a rich area of combinatorics and algebra, with deep connections to representation theory and algebraic geometry. Several important conjectures, such as the Delta conjecture and the shuffle conjecture, relate symmetric functions to combinatorial objects like Dyck paths. These conjectures often involve parameters like $q$ and $t$, and researchers are constantly seeking to refine them, understand their underlying structure, and extend them to new settings.

This paper addresses the need for a more refined understanding of the Delta conjecture, particularly its "compositional" and "touching" aspects. The authors aim to introduce a new tool – the Theta operators – to formulate and prove these refined conjectures, thereby extending existing results and opening up new avenues of research. They also seek to connect these refined conjectures to other areas, such as the Dyck path algebra and the study of super-diagonal coinvariants.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the introduction of a new family of linear operators on symmetric functions, denoted by $\Theta_f$, where $f$ is itself a symmetric function. These "Theta operators" are defined using existing operators like $\Pi$ and $\Pi^{-1}$ and have the property of preserving the degree of homogeneous symmetric functions.

The authors then use these Theta operators to:

  • Formulate refined conjectures: They propose "compositional Delta conjectures" and "touching generalized Delta conjectures" that refine existing ones.
  • Prove specific cases: They prove the $k=0$ case of their compositional Delta conjecture and the $k=0$ case of their touching generalized Delta conjecture.
  • Relate to existing work: They show how their conjectures connect to the 4-variable Catalan theorem of Zabrocki and the Dyck path algebra of Carlsson and Mellit.
  • Extend results: They extend the shuffle theorem and the square theorem to generalized settings.
  • Conjecture formulas for coinvariants: They propose formulas for the Frobenius characteristic of super-diagonal coinvariants, extending previous work.

The proofs rely heavily on the established machinery of symmetric function theory, including Macdonald polynomials, nabla and Delta operators, and various combinatorial definitions related to Dyck paths and their labellings.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Theta Operators: The introduction of Theta operators provides a new algebraic tool to explore and refine existing conjectures in symmetric functions. Their structure allows for the formulation of more detailed combinatorial statements.
  • Compositional Refinement: The paper demonstrates how to refine the Delta conjecture by considering the "composition" of Dyck paths, which relates to the distances between points where the path touches the diagonal. This leads to a deeper understanding of the combinatorial objects involved.
  • Connecting Different Areas: The work bridges the gap between symmetric function conjectures, combinatorial objects (Dyck paths), and algebraic structures (Dyck path algebra, coinvariant spaces), highlighting the interconnectedness of these fields.
  • Generalization is Key: The authors successfully generalize existing theorems like the shuffle theorem and the square theorem, showing how the new framework can encompass and extend prior results.

Key Results

  • Compositional Delta Conjecture: A new conjecture is proposed, refining the Delta conjecture by considering the "composition" of Dyck paths.
  • Touching Generalized Delta Conjecture: A further refinement is introduced, incorporating "touching points" of Dyck paths.
  • Proof of $k=0$ Cases: The $k=0$ case of the compositional Delta conjecture and the touching generalized Delta conjecture are proven.
  • Connection to Catalan and Shuffle Theorems: The 4-variable Catalan theorem is shown to be a specific case of the compositional Delta conjecture, and the generalized shuffle theorem is proven.
  • Conjectures for Super-Diagonal Coinvariants: Formulas for the Frobenius characteristic of super-diagonal coinvariants are conjectured, extending previous work.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conjectural Nature: While many results are proven, some key formulas, particularly for super-diagonal coinvariants and a combinatorial interpretation at $q=1$, remain conjectures.
  • Finding a dinv Statistic: A significant open problem is finding a specific "dinv statistic" that would fully capture the symmetric function in the context of super-diagonal coinvariants.
  • Generalization of Theta Operators: The authors suggest that exploring formulas for Theta operators in terms of the Dyck path algebra could be a step towards proving the operator Delta conjecture.
  • Schur Positivity: The paper ends with a conjecture about Schur positivity related to Theta operators, suggesting further avenues for investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce the family of Theta operators Θf indexed by symmetric functions f that allow us to conjecture a compositional refinement of the Delta conjecture of Haglund, Remmel and Wilson [23] for Δe′en. We show that the 4-variable Catalan theorem of Zabrocki [31] is precisely the Schröder case of our compositional Delta conjecture, and we show how to relate this conjecture to the Dyck path algebra introduced by Carlsson and Mellit in [6], extending one of their results. Again using the Theta operators, we conjecture a touching refinement of the generalized Delta conjecture for ΔhΔe′en, and prove the case k=0, which was also conjectured in [23], extending the shuffle theorem of Carlsson and Mellit to a generalized shuffle theorem for Δh∇en. Moreover we show how this implies the case k=0 of our generalized Delta square conjecture for [Formula presented], extending the square theorem of Sergel [27] to a generalized square theorem for Δh∇ω(pn). Still the Theta operators will provide a conjectural formula for the Frobenius characteristic of super-diagonal coinvariants with two sets of Grassmannian variables, extending the one of Zabrocki in [30] for the case with one set of such variables. We propose a combinatorial interpretation of this last formula at q=1, leaving open the problem of finding a dinv statistic that gives the whole symmetric function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dadderio2021theta,
  author = {Michele D’Adderio and Alessandro Iraci and Anna Vanden Wyngaerd},
  title = {{Theta operators, refined delta conjectures, and coinvariants}},
  booktitle = {CINECA IRIS Institutial Research Information System (University of Pisa)},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.aim.2020.107447},
}
Figure