Thermophoretically induced large-scale deformations around microscopic heat centers

Mate Puljiz, M. Orlishausen, W. Köhler, Andreas M. MenzelThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Selectively heating a microscopic colloidal particle embedded in a soft elastic matrix is a situation of high practical relevance. For instance, during hyperthermic cancer treatment, cell tissue surrounding heated magnetic colloidal particles is destroyed. Experiments on soft elastic polymeric matrices suggest a very long-ranged, non-decaying radial component of the thermophoretically induced displacement fields around the microscopic heat centers. We theoretically confirm this conjecture using a macroscopic hydrodynamic two-fluid description. Both thermophoretic and elastic effects are included in this theory. Indeed, we find that the elasticity of the environment can cause the experimentally observed large-scale radial displacements in the embedding matrix. Additional experiments confirm the central role of elasticity. Finally, a linearly decaying radial component of the displacement field in the experiments is attributed to the finite size of the experimental sample. Similar results are obtained from our theoretical analysis under modified boundary conditions.

Introduction

In applications like hyperthermic cancer treatment, magnetic nanoparticles are embedded in cancer tissue and heated using external fields to destroy malignant cells. Researchers previously noticed that heating a single particle in a soft elastic matrix (like a polymer gel) caused the surrounding matrix to move outward. The mystery was the scale of this movement. Experimental evidence suggested these "thermophoretically induced" deformations were incredibly long-ranged. In fact, it was conjectured that in an infinite system, the magnitude of this displacement wouldn't decrease at all as you moved away from the heat source. This paper seeks to bridge the gap between experimental observation and physical theory, explaining exactly how local heating translates into global deformation.

Methods

The authors employ a dual approach to investigate this phenomenon. Theoretically, they use a macroscopic hydrodynamic two-fluid description, treating the system as two interpenetrating components: a liquid solvent and an elastic polymer network. By linearizing the equations for concentration, entropy density, and displacement, they derived analytical solutions for how the polymer network responds to a point-like heat source.

Experimentally, gold nanoparticles (GNPs) were embedded into a strongly entangled, ultra-high-molecular-weight polymer network (polystyrene in toluene). A focused laser heated a single "center" GNP, and the movement of surrounding non-heated GNPs (acting as tracers) was tracked using phase-contrast microscopy.

Experimental setup showing the microscope, laser, and the displacement of tracer particles in the polymer network.

Key Insights and Theoretical Framework

The core finding is that elasticity acts as a long-range conductor. In a pure liquid, heating causes thermophoresis, but the effect is localized. In an elastic matrix, the polymer strands are interconnected. When the temperature gradient pushes the polymer at one point, the elastic "mesh" transmits that force across the entire system.

The theory confirms that in an idealized infinite system, the radial displacement $u(r)$ contains a constant term ($u_0$). This means the entire matrix would shift outward by the same amount, regardless of distance from the heat source. While a constant displacement across an infinite volume sounds like it would require infinite energy, the authors point out that the $1/r$ temperature profile of a steady heat source also implies an infinite input of heat energy in an infinite system.

Experimental Results and Boundary Effects

The experiments showed a clear linear decay of displacement with distance, which perfectly matched the theoretical model when modified for finite boundary conditions ($u(R) = 0$). Because the experimental sample is confined between two rigid plates, the displacement is forced to zero at the walls, turning a constant shift into a linear slope.

Displacement of tracer particles as a function of distance from the heat center for different laser powers, showing linear decay.

Key results include:

  • Theoretical Proof: The authors derived a general solution for the displacement field: $u(r) = u_0 + u_{-2}/r^2$. The $u_0$ term represents the non-decaying component.
  • Reversibility: The deformations were shown to be directed and reversible. When the laser was turned off, the tracer particles moved back toward their original positions as the network relaxed.
  • Network Dependence: The effect was only observed in high-molecular-weight entangled networks. In low-molecular-weight samples, tracers simply showed random Brownian motion, proving that the long-range effect is strictly a property of the matrix's elasticity.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study provides the first theoretical confirmation that the elasticity of the environment, coupled with thermophoresis, creates displacement fields that do not decay with distance in an infinite system. The current theory is linearized, making it most accurate in the "far-field." Future research should explore dynamic responses, the interaction of multiple heat centers, and testing the theory on complex biological tissues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Selectively heating a microscopic colloidal particle embedded in a soft elastic matrix is a situation of high practical relevance. For instance, during hyperthermic cancer treatment, cell tissue surrounding heated magnetic colloidal particles is destroyed. Experiments on soft elastic polymeric matrices suggest a very long-ranged, non-decaying radial component of the thermophoretically induced displacement fields around the microscopic heat centers. We theoretically confirm this conjecture using a macroscopic hydrodynamic two-fluid description. Both thermophoretic and elastic effects are included in this theory. Indeed, we find that the elasticity of the environment can cause the experimentally observed large-scale radial displacements in the embedding matrix. Additional experiments confirm the central role of elasticity. Finally, a linearly decaying radial component of the displacement field in the experiments is attributed to the finite size of the experimental sample. Similar results are obtained from our theoretical analysis under modified boundary conditions.
BibTeX
@article{puljiz2016thermophoretically,
  author = {Mate Puljiz and M. Orlishausen and W. Köhler and Andreas M. Menzel},
  title = {{Thermophoretically induced large-scale deformations around microscopic heat centers}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4948729},
}

Loading related content...

Figure