Thermonuclear 17O(n, γ)18O Reaction Rate and Its Astrophysical Implications

Liyong Zhang, J. J. He, Motohiko Kusakabe, Zhenyu He, Toshitaka KajinoThe Astrophysical Journal 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a significantly revised and much larger thermonuclear reaction rate for 17O(n,γ)18O, crucial for understanding nucleosynthesis in stars. This new rate, up to 80 times higher than previous estimates, dramatically impacts the production of 18O and 19F in certain stellar environments, particularly in asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The accurate calculation of reaction rates is fundamental to understanding how elements are synthesized in stars. The 17O(n,γ)18O reaction plays a role in the production of heavier elements, particularly in the s-process (slow neutron capture process) which occurs in stars like AGB stars and massive stars. Previous estimates of this reaction rate had large uncertainties and were often based on limited experimental data or theoretical models that might not be fully applicable to light nuclei. This led to significant discrepancies in stellar models. This paper aims to provide a more precise and reliable rate for 17O(n,γ)18O by employing a comprehensive theoretical calculation, addressing the need for better constraints in nucleosynthesis studies.

Methods

The authors calculated the 17O(n,γ)18O reaction rate by combining direct-capture (DC) and resonant-capture contributions. They used the RADCAP code for DC calculations, incorporating Woods-Saxon potentials and Coulomb potentials. For resonant contributions, they employed the Breit-Wigner formula. A key aspect was the inclusion of a subthreshold state, which was calculated for the first time and found to dominate the cross-section at low energies. Uncertainties were estimated using a Monte Carlo approach. For higher temperatures, they normalized existing evaluated data (ENDF/B-VIII) to their calculated cross-sections.

Datasets

The paper utilizes nuclear level schemes and spectroscopic factors from existing literature (e.g., Tilley et al. 1995, Li et al. 1976). They also compare their results with evaluated nuclear reaction data libraries such as ENDF/B-VIII.0, JEFF3.3, and ROSFOND2010. Stellar models for s-process and r-process nucleosynthesis were based on existing codes and observational data for specific stars (e.g., LP625-44 and CS31062-012).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Dramatically Increased Rate: The most striking finding is that the new 17O(n,γ)18O rate is significantly larger (up to 80 times) than previously adopted rates, especially in the temperature range relevant for AGB stars.
  • Dominance of the Subthreshold State: The authors' novel calculation of a subthreshold state for 17O(n,γ)18O revealed its crucial role in determining the cross-section at low neutron energies.
  • Impact on AGB Stars: The enhanced rate leads to substantial increases (20-40 fold) in 18O and 19F abundances in metal-deficient AGB stars, significantly altering predictions for s-process element production in these stars.
  • Negligible Impact on Massive Stars: In massive stars, where 17O abundance is naturally low, the increased rate has a minimal effect on the weak s-process.
  • "Loophole" Effect in r-process: A peculiar "loophole" effect was observed in r-process models without fission recycling, where the enhanced rate significantly altered abundances. However, this effect was largely washed out when fission recycling was considered.
  • Discrepancies with Evaluated Libraries: The study highlights significant discrepancies between their calculated rate and those found in major nuclear data libraries, suggesting a need for re-evaluation of existing data.

Key Results

  • The new 17O(n,γ)18O rate is up to 80 times larger than the JINA REACLIB rate in the temperature range of 0.01-2 GK.
  • In metal-deficient AGB stars, 18O and 19F abundances are enhanced by factors of ~20-40.
  • The impact on weak s-process in massive stars is negligible.
  • In collapsar r-process models without fission recycling, abundances can change by an order of magnitude, but this difference is almost entirely eliminated when fission recycling is included.
  • The neutron burst r-process model shows a marginal impact from the new rate due to competing reactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Verification Needed: The authors emphasize that experimental data for the 17O(n,γ)18O reaction is scarce, with only the thermal cross-section being available. They call for further experimental clarification, particularly for cross-sections above 10⁻⁵ MeV, and suggest time-reversal photo-dissociation experiments as a potential avenue.
  • Uncertainties in Competing Reactions: The paper notes that the 14C(α,γ)18O reaction rate also has significant uncertainties, which can affect the precise determination of 18O abundance in s-process models. More precise measurements of this reaction are strongly recommended.
  • Fission Recycling in r-process: The study highlights the critical role of fission recycling in r-process nucleosynthesis, which can mask the effects of changes in other reaction rates. Further theoretical and experimental studies on fission in superheavy nuclei are encouraged.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract A new thermonuclear 17 O( n , γ ) 18 O rate is derived based on a complete calculation of the direct-capture (DC) and resonant-capture contributions, for a temperature region up to 2 GK of astrophysical interest. We have first calculated the DC and subthreshold contributions in the energy region up to 1 MeV, and estimated the associated uncertainties by a Monte Carlo approach. It shows that the present rate is remarkably larger than that adopted in the JINA REACLIB in the temperature region of 0.01 ∼ 2 GK, by up to a factor of ∼80. The astrophysical impacts of our rate have been examined in both s -process and r -process models. In our main s -process model, which simulates flash-driven convective mixing in metal-deficient asymptotic giant branch stars, both 18 O and 19 F abundances in interpulse phases are enhanced dramatically by factors of ∼20–40 due to the new larger 17 O( n , γ ) 18 O rate. It shows, however, that this reaction hardly affects the weak s -process in massive stars since the 17 O abundance never becomes significantly large in the massive stars. For the r -process nucleosynthesis, we have studied impacts of our rate in both the collapsar and neutron burst models, and found that the effect can be neglected, although an interesting loophole effect is found owing to the enhanced new rate, which significantly changes the final nuclear abundances if fission recycling is not involved in the model; however, these significant differences are almost completely eliminated if the fission recycling is considered.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022thermonuclear,
  author = {Liyong Zhang and J. J. He and Motohiko Kusakabe and Zhenyu He and Toshitaka Kajino},
  title = {{Thermonuclear <sup>17</sup>O(n, γ)<sup>18</sup>O Reaction Rate and Its Astrophysical Implications}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ac4697},
}
Figure