Thermoelastic properties and thermal evolution of the Martian core from ab initio calculated ferromagnetic Fe-S liquid

Weijie Li, Zi Li, Zhe Ma, Jie Zhou, Cong Wang, Ping ZhangarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers used advanced ab initio simulations to reveal that the Martian core—a liquid iron-sulfur (Fe-S) mix—is likely in a thoroughly ferromagnetic state. This magnetic property unexpectedly slashes the core's thermal conductivity by half, providing a new lens through which to view the Red Planet's cooling history and the mysterious "iron snow" that may be falling deep within its interior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mars is a planet of magnetic contradictions. While it lacks a global magnetic field today, its crustal rocks are strongly magnetized, suggesting it once possessed a powerful internal dynamo. To understand why this dynamo died out and what the core looks like today, scientists need to know the "thermoelastic properties" (how the material compresses and reacts to heat) and thermal conductivity of the core's material.

The challenge is that the Martian core is a high-pressure, high-temperature liquid of iron and sulfur. Recreating these conditions in a lab is incredibly difficult. Previous models often relied on simplified assumptions about the core's magnetic state, which can lead to wildly different predictions about how fast the planet cooled and whether it has a solid inner core, a fully liquid one, or a "slushy" zone of crystallizing iron.

Methods

The authors employed Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD), a computational method that simulates the behavior of atoms from first principles (quantum mechanics) rather than empirical data.

Key technical highlights include:

  • VASP Code: Used for plane-wave density functional theory calculations.
  • Hubbard U Model (DFT+U): This was implemented to accurately capture the electronic correlations in iron, which is notorious for being difficult to model. They calculated a U value of ~4.3 eV for these specific conditions.
  • Multivariate Polynomial Fitting: Instead of using standard equations of state (EoS) that might lose precision, they fitted their calculated pressure-volume-temperature (P-V-T) and energy-volume-temperature (E-V-T) data to a custom polynomial. This allowed them to derive properties like bulk modulus and sound velocity directly from definitions.
  • Kubo-Greenwood Formula: Used to calculate electrical and thermal conductivity from the simulated electronic structures.

Datasets

This study does not use traditional "big data" sets. Instead, it generates its own data through simulations of a 128-atom supercell (96 Fe atoms and 32 S atoms, representing a 16 wt.% sulfur concentration).

  • Constraints: The researchers used recent seismic data from the NASA InSight mission to set boundary conditions, such as a core radius of ~1830 km and a mean core density of 5.7–6.3 g/cm³.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Ferromagnetic Surprise: The most significant finding is that liquid $Fe_{0.75}S_{0.25}$ remains in a ferromagnetic state under Martian core conditions (16–40 GPa and 1600–2600 K). This contradicts some previous assumptions that the liquid would be non-magnetic or paramagnetic.
  • Magnetism as an Insulator: Because the liquid is ferromagnetic, its thermal conductivity is remarkably low—only 21–23 W/m/K. This is roughly half the value calculated when magnetism is ignored.
  • The "Iron Snow" Verification: By plugging their new, lower conductivity values into planetary evolution models, the authors found that the "iron snow" model (where iron crystals form at the top of the core and sink) is highly plausible if the current temperature at the core-mantle boundary is below the melting point of the Fe-S mix.

Key Results

  • Thermal Conductivity: Confirmed at 21–23 W/m/K for the ferromagnetic state, compared to 40–55 W/m/K in non-magnetic calculations.
  • Sound Velocity: Calculated P-wave velocities range from 4.21 to 5.19 km/s, which aligns well with experimental data and seismic observations from InSight.
  • Equation of State: The team produced a high-accuracy EoS (within 1% standard error) that allows for the calculation of adiabatic bulk modulus and thermal expansion coefficients across the entire Martian core pressure range.
  • Evolution Scenarios: The paper concludes that Mars currently experiences either simple "secular cooling" (if the core is still quite hot) or an "iron snow" regime, but a solid Fe-S inner core is likely a feature of the planet's future, not its present.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few areas for further exploration:

  • Sulfur Concentration: While they focused on 16 wt.% sulfur (based on InSight data), they note that varying sulfur levels and the ferromagnetic state itself could further influence thermoelastic properties in ways not fully explored here.
  • Mantle Interaction: The model for heat flowing out of the core (the $Q_{cmb}$) is parameterized. Since core evolution is heavily dictated by how the mantle removes heat, more integrated core-mantle coupling models would be the next logical step.
  • Radioactive Elements: The study assumes no radioactive elements in the core; if present, these would provide an internal heat source that could alter the cooling timeline.

Summary updated

Abstract

The accurate thermoelastic properties and thermal conductivity are crucial in understanding the thermal evolution of the Martian core. A fitting method based on the ab initio calculated pressure-volume-temperature data is proposed in the formulation of the equation of state with high accuracy, by which the pressure and temperature dependent thermoelastic properties can be directly calculated by definitions. The ab initio results show that the liquid Fe0.75S0.25 under Martian core condition is thoroughly in the ferromagnetic state, without existing spin crossover. The liquid Fe0.75S0.25 in magnetic calculation owns a low thermal conductivity (21~23 W/m/K) when compared with non-magnetic calculation at the same state. Based on the Insight estimated and ab initio calculated properties of the Martian core, the iron snow model is verified when the current temperature at the core-mantle boundary is below the core melting temperature, and the simply secular cooling model is verified on the contrary.
BibTeX
@misc{li2023thermoelastic,
  author = {Weijie Li and Zi Li and Zhe Ma and Jie Zhou and Cong Wang and Ping Zhang},
  title = {{Thermoelastic properties and thermal evolution of the Martian core from ab initio calculated ferromagnetic Fe-S liquid}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.16542},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16542},
}
Figure