Thermodynamic Modeling of the Uranium–Tellurium System: Estimation of the Uncertainties by a Bayesian Approach

Christine Guéneau, Eva Lawrence, Thierry Klein, Fabrice GamboaThermo 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a thermodynamic model for the Uranium-Tellurium (U-Te) system, crucial for understanding irradiated nuclear fuel behavior. It uniquely employs a Bayesian approach to quantify uncertainties in the model's parameters and their impact on predicted thermodynamic properties and phase diagrams, revealing significant uncertainties due to limited experimental data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nuclear fuel, particularly in fast reactors, undergoes significant chemical changes due to irradiation and high temperatures. Fission products like Cesium (Cs), Tellurium (Te), Iodine (I), and Molybdenum (Mo) migrate within the fuel pellet, creating complex chemical environments. To accurately predict the behavior and safety of these fuels, thermodynamic models of multi-component systems involving these fission products are essential. This paper focuses on the Uranium-Tellurium (U-Te) sub-system, a key component of these complex fuel environments. The challenge lies in the scarcity and inconsistency of existing experimental data for the U-Te system, especially for the liquid phase, making it difficult to build a reliable thermodynamic model and, critically, to understand the uncertainty associated with such models.

Methods

The study utilizes the CALPHAD (Calculation of Phase Diagrams) method to model the thermodynamic properties of the U-Te system. This involves defining Gibbs energy functions for various phases. A key innovation is the application of a Bayesian approach to estimate uncertainties. Specifically, they employ a conjugate prior probability distribution, which allows for analytical posterior probability distributions and credible intervals for thermodynamic quantities. This contrasts with many other Bayesian methods that rely on computationally intensive Monte Carlo simulations. The Bayesian framework is used to propagate uncertainties from experimental data through the model parameters to the final thermodynamic predictions and phase diagrams.

Datasets

The study relies on a critical review and selection of existing experimental and estimated data from the literature for the U-Te system. This includes:

  • Crystal Structure Data: Primarily from reviews and specific studies on UTe, U2Te3, U3Te5, and a-UTe2.
  • Phase Diagram Data: Data from differential thermal analysis (DTA) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) experiments, particularly in the UTe-Te region.
  • Thermodynamic Data:
    • Standard entropies estimated by Westrum.
  • Heat capacity estimations (using Kopp-Neumann law) from Wolf.
  • Enthalpy of formation data from Baskin et al. for UTe and U3Te4.
  • Estimated enthalpy of formation data from Czechowicz for other compounds.
  • Vapor pressure measurements for two-phase regions (UTe + U3Te4, U3Te5 + UTe2, U2Te5 + UTe3).

Notably, no direct experimental thermodynamic data for the liquid U-Te phase was available.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data Scarcity Drives Uncertainty: The most significant insight is the profound impact of limited and inconsistent experimental data on the reliability of thermodynamic models. The U-Te system, despite its importance, suffers from a lack of comprehensive data, particularly for the liquid phase and certain solid compounds.
  • Bayesian Uncertainty Quantification is Crucial: Applying a Bayesian approach reveals that while the CALPHAD model can reproduce some experimental data well, the uncertainties in the model parameters are substantial. This is attributed to having too many parameters (22) for too few data points (around 120).
  • Analytical Bayesian Approach is Efficient: The use of a conjugate prior distribution for the Bayesian inference provides analytical solutions for posterior distributions and credible intervals. This significantly speeds up uncertainty analysis compared to purely simulation-based methods, making it more practical for complex systems.
  • Inconsistencies Matter: The paper highlights inconsistencies between different types of experimental data (e.g., enthalpy of formation vs. vapor pressure for UTe), which makes it challenging to find a single set of parameters that fits all data well. This leads to discrepancies in specific predictions, such as the enthalpy of formation for UTe.
  • Phase Diagrams Remain Uncertain: While the UTe-Te part of the phase diagram is relatively well-established, the U-UTe region and specific invariant reactions show significant uncertainty due to sparse data. The Bayesian analysis quantifies this uncertainty, showing estimated melting temperature uncertainties of up to 100 K for some compounds.

Key Results

  • The developed CALPHAD model shows good agreement with experimental vapor pressure data and the enthalpy of formation for U3Te4.
  • The enthalpy of formation for UTe is underestimated by approximately 13% compared to measured values, likely due to inconsistencies in the input data.
  • The Bayesian uncertainty analysis reveals that the model has large uncertainties for some calculated thermodynamic quantities and phase transitions, particularly for the liquid phase and in regions with limited experimental data.
  • The estimated uncertainty for the melting temperature of U3Te4 is around 100 K.
  • The analytical Bayesian approach allows for the calculation of posterior probability distributions and credible intervals, which are presented for enthalpies of formation, entropies, and partial pressures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The paper explicitly states that there is a lack of experimental data for the liquid U-Te phase. Furthermore, experimental data for enthalpy of formation and heat capacity for many solid compounds are either estimations or show large discrepancies.
  • Parameter Count vs. Data: The authors note that the number of model parameters (22) is high relative to the available experimental data points (around 120), contributing to large uncertainties.
  • Inconsistent Data: Inconsistencies between different experimental datasets (e.g., enthalpy of formation vs. vapor pressure) hinder the development of a perfectly fitting model.
  • Future Work Recommendations:
    • New experimental measurements are crucial, including heat capacity, enthalpy of formation for compounds, and chemical potentials/activities for the liquid phase.
  • Phase diagram data in the U–UTe2 region are particularly needed.
  • The authors plan to apply this Bayesian methodology to ternary systems and to couple it with multi-physics codes for more comprehensive uncertainty propagation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under irradiation, the formation of fission products in the (U,Pu)O2 fuel with time has a substantial effect on its chemistry. In particular, migration of the most volatile fission products (Cs, Te, I, Mo) from the center to the periphery of the fuel pellet is induced by the large radial thermal gradient. To predict the thermodynamic properties of the irradiated fuel, thermodynamic modeling of the complex multi-component (Cs-I-Te-Mo)–(U-Pu)–O system is performed using the CALPHAD method. In this work, the thermodynamic assessment of the U–Te sub-system is performed. The literature review reveals a lack of experimental data as well as scattering and inconsistency of some of the data. In particular, no thermodynamic data exist on the liquid. From this review, input thermodynamic and phase diagram data are carefully selected. The Gibbs energy functions are then adjusted by fitting these data. An overall good agreement is obtained with all the selected data except for the enthalpy of formation for UTe which is underestimated by 13% by our model. This could be due to an inconsistency between the enthalpy of formation and vapor pressure data. In a second step, the uncertainties on the thermodynamic parameters and their propagation on the calculated thermodynamic and phase diagram data are estimated using a Bayesian approach. The analysis shows that there are too many parameters (22) for too few data points (120 points). The uncertainties are thus large on some of the calculated data. Moreover the inconsistency of some of the data and the lack of thermodynamic data for the liquid makes the model uncertain. New experimental data such as heat capacity, enthalpy of formation for the compounds, and chemical potentials or activities for the liquid phase would improve the reliability of our model. Measurements of phase diagram data in the U–UTe2 region are also required. However this work provides the first detailed uncertainty analysis of the U–Te CALPHAD model. Moreover our approach, contrary to other Bayesian methods, provides an analytical posterior probability distribution and analytical credible intervals for the calculated thermodynamic quantities. It also speeds up the simulation of the uncertainty estimations on the phase diagram.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gueneau2022thermodynamic,
  author = {Christine Guéneau and Eva Lawrence and Thierry Klein and Fabrice Gamboa},
  title = {{Thermodynamic Modeling of the Uranium–Tellurium System: Estimation of the Uncertainties by a Bayesian Approach}},
  booktitle = {Thermo},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/thermo2010003},
}
Figure