Thermodynamic Investigation of the Effect of Interface Curvature on Solid-Liquid Equilibrium and Its Application to Zinc-Air Battery Electrolyte at Low Temperature

Fanghui LiuUniversity 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This thesis develops a thermodynamic framework to predict how curved interfaces at the nanoscale affect the freezing and melting behavior of multicomponent solutions. This is crucial for understanding and designing systems like zinc-air batteries that operate at low temperatures and involve confined electrolytes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The behavior of materials at the micro and nanoscale is significantly influenced by the curvature of their interfaces. While this effect has been studied for single-component systems (like pure water freezing), it's less understood for multicomponent systems, which are more common in real-world applications. Specifically, the paper addresses the challenge of predicting the solid-liquid equilibrium (freezing and precipitation) of solutions confined within nanoscale pores, a phenomenon critical for the performance of technologies like zinc-air batteries in cold environments. Existing models often simplify interfaces as flat or don't fully account for the complexities of multicomponent mixtures under confinement.

Methods

The core of this work involves deriving a generalized thermodynamic model for solid-liquid equilibrium in confined multicomponent systems. This derivation, based on Gibbsian thermodynamics, accounts for thermal, mechanical, and chemical equilibrium conditions. A key contribution is showing the equivalence between the Gibbs-Thomson and Ostwald-Freundlich equations in this generalized form. The authors then apply this model to two specific cases:

  1. Water/Glycerol System: This binary system is used to illustrate the effect of interface curvature on the entire phase diagram, including the eutectic point.
  2. Aqueous Electrolytes for Zinc-Air Batteries: Here, the model is used to predict the freezing behavior of electrolytes, incorporating nanoscale confinement effects and the nonideality of solutions using the osmotic virial equation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on fitting existing experimental data from literature for osmotic virial coefficients and activity coefficients.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Curvature Matters at the Nanoscale: The shape of interfaces, especially at the nanoscale, profoundly alters phase behavior, leading to significant shifts in freezing and melting points compared to bulk materials.
  • Unified Framework: The derived thermodynamic model unifies concepts from Gibbs-Thomson and Ostwald-Freundlich equations, providing a more general approach to understanding curvature effects in solid-liquid equilibrium for multicomponent systems.
  • Eutectic Point Sensitivity: The eutectic point (the lowest melting point in a binary system) is shown to be sensitive to interface curvature, shifting in both temperature and concentration as pore size decreases.
  • Zinc-Air Battery Relevance: The study directly applies these principles to electrolytes used in zinc-air batteries, demonstrating how nanoscale confinement in battery components can significantly lower freezing points, which is critical for low-temperature operation.
  • Additives and Confinement Synergy: The research highlights that both chemical composition (additives) and physical confinement (nanopores) play crucial roles in determining the freezing point of battery electrolytes.

Key Results

  • A generalized thermodynamic equation was derived that describes solid-liquid equilibrium in multicomponent systems with curved interfaces, applicable across the entire composition range.
  • For the water/glycerol system, it was shown that decreasing capillary radius leads to a significant depression of freezing and precipitation points, as well as shifts in the eutectic point temperature and concentration.
  • For zinc-air battery electrolytes, the model predicted that nanoscale confinement (e.g., in a 10 nm pore) can lower the freezing point by approximately 10 °C.
  • The study also quantified the impact of various additives on electrolyte freezing points, showing that they can further lower the freezing temperature, especially in conjunction with confinement.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Constant Interfacial Tension: The study assumes interfacial tensions are constant and independent of temperature, concentration, and curvature. In reality, these can vary, and more accurate predictions would require this data.
  • Zero Contact Angle Assumption: For simplicity, the calculations often assume a zero contact angle between the solid-liquid interface and the capillary wall. This might exaggerate the predicted freezing point depression.
  • Temperature-Independent Margules Parameters: The Margules model parameters for the water/glycerol system were treated as temperature-independent, which is an approximation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that more accurate predictions could be made if experimental data for glycerol solid-liquid interfacial tension were available. The developed thermodynamic method can be extended to other applications involving aqueous solutions in nanoscale confinement, such as water purification, desalination, and organ-on-chip devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Micro and nanoscale confinements and local curvatures, which are ubiquitous in natural and man-made materials and systems, cause significant impact on thermodynamic phase behavior. This effect has been extensively studied for single component solid's liquid phase transitions, but rarely for multicomponent systems. Using Gibbsian thermodynamics, we derived an expression to describe the thermodynamic solid'liquid equilibrium for multicomponent systems, where the equation takes thermal, mechanical and chemical equilibrium conditions into account. This derivation highlights the equivalence of general forms of the Gibbs'Thomson and Ostwald'Freundlich equations. We show the effect of the radius of curvature of the solid'liquid interface on the phase diagram, where the equation can be applied to the entire composition range. The equation can predict the effect of curvature on both the freezing and precipitating processes, thus a precise expression for the curvature-induced eutectic point shift is also derived. The water/glycerol system, which has complete mixing of the two components in the liquid phase but nearly pure solid phases during freezing and precipitating processes, is chosen to explore these equations. Here, we predict the curvature effect on the freezing and precipitating process of the entire phase diagram, and the eutectic point temperature and concentration shift with curvature. We also applied the equations to the freezing behavior of the aqueous electrolytes that are actively used in zinc'air batteries. The osmotic virial equation is an accurate, straightforward way to describe the nonideality of aqueous solution as a function of concentrations. Here, osmotic virial coefficients of various electrolytes which are commonly used are found by fitting literature data, and the nanoscale confinement effect on the freezing point of electrolyte systems is also investigated. The theoretical studies in this thesis, which used thermodynamic analysis to investigate the nanoscale confinement effect on multicomponent solid'liquid equilibrium systems, can find crucial applications in cryobiology, soil science, synthetic nanoporous materials and other various nanoscience fields.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2018thermodynamic,
  author = {Fanghui Liu},
  title = {{Thermodynamic Investigation of the Effect of Interface Curvature on Solid-Liquid Equilibrium and Its Application to Zinc-Air Battery Electrolyte at Low Temperature}},
  booktitle = {University},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7939/r3qf8k08s},
}
Figure