Thermodynamic Experiments and Modelling of Cyclopentane Hydrates in the Presence of NaBr, KBr, K2SO4, NaBr–KBr, NaCl–NaBr, KCl–KBr, Na2SO4–K2SO4, and CaCl2–MgCl2

Trung-Kien Pham, Quynh-Trang Thi Hoang, Le Chen, Thien Hien Tran, Koemhong Bun, Ngo Thi Hong Le, Son Ho-Van, Van-Hieu Ngo, Quang-Duyen Le, Madina Naukanova, Muhammad Abuhuraira, Ana Cameirão, Jérôme Douzet, Jean‐Michel Herri, Baptiste BouillotWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents new experimental data on the phase equilibrium of cyclopentane hydrates (CPH) in the presence of various salts relevant to seawater desalination. The findings reveal that increasing salt concentration inhibits hydrate formation, with specific cation and anion orders influencing this effect. Four thermodynamic models were evaluated, with the ABOC approach showing the best predictive accuracy for CPH equilibrium temperatures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water scarcity is a growing global concern, driving the need for efficient and sustainable desalination technologies. Hydrate-based desalination (HBD) is a promising approach that leverages the ability of certain molecules (hydrate formers) to crystallize with water, excluding salts from the hydrate structure. Cyclopentane (CP) is an attractive hydrate former because it can form hydrates at low temperatures and atmospheric pressure, making it potentially more energy-efficient and safer than high-pressure alternatives. However, a comprehensive understanding of CPH phase equilibrium in the presence of diverse salt mixtures, common in natural waters, is crucial for designing and optimizing HBD systems. This paper addresses this gap by experimentally determining CPH phase equilibrium data for several novel salt systems and evaluating the performance of existing thermodynamic models in predicting these conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed two experimental procedures to determine the phase equilibrium temperatures of cyclopentane hydrates (CPH) in the presence of various salts:

  • Quick Dissociation Procedure: This method aims for rapid estimation of the equilibrium temperature. It involves forming CPH, then allowing it to dissociate by gradually increasing the temperature. The point of sharp temperature rise is taken as the equilibrium temperature.
  • Slow Dissociation Procedure: This method is designed for greater accuracy. It involves a more controlled and prolonged dissociation process with finer temperature increments, allowing for a more precise determination of the equilibrium point where CP, CPH, and the aqueous phase coexist.

The experimental data were then used to evaluate four thermodynamic modeling approaches:

  • SFPD (Standard Freezing Point Depression) Approach: Based on Hildebrand and Scott's equation, used to model water activity in salt solutions.
  • HLS (Hu-Lee-Sum) Correlation: Based on the principle of freezing point depression and the equality of water fugacity in hydrate and liquid phases.
  • Kihara Approach: A well-established model that describes clathrate hydrate equilibrium using chemical potentials and cavity interactions.
  • ABOC (Activity-Based Occupancy Correlation) Approach: A simpler model that relates the occupancy factor of CP to water activity.

The accuracy of each model was assessed by calculating the Average Absolute Deviation (AAD) between predicted and experimental equilibrium temperatures.

Datasets

The study generated new experimental phase equilibrium data for cyclopentane hydrates (CPH) in the presence of the following salt systems at various concentrations:

  • NaBr
  • KBr
  • K2SO4
  • NaBr–KBr
  • NaCl–NaBr
  • KCl–KBr
  • Na2SO4–K2SO4
  • CaCl2–MgCl2

These datasets were then used to validate the performance of the SFPD, HLS, Kihara, and ABOC thermodynamic models. The paper also references existing literature data for comparison and validation of the experimental setup and methodology.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Salt Inhibition is Key: The presence of salts significantly lowers the equilibrium temperature of CPH formation, confirming their role as hydrate inhibitors. This is crucial for understanding how HBD would perform with real seawater.
  • Concentration Matters Most: The inhibitory effect of salts is strongly dependent on their concentration. Higher salt concentrations lead to lower equilibrium temperatures, meaning more cooling is required to form hydrates.
  • Cation Hierarchy: The inhibitory effect of cations follows a specific order: Mg²⁺ > Ca²⁺ > Na⁺ > K⁺. This suggests that cations with higher charge density have a stronger impact on hydrate formation.
  • Anion Influence: Among halide anions, Br⁻ shows a stronger inhibitory effect on equilibrium temperature compared to Cl⁻.
  • Model Performance Varies: While all four models showed reasonable agreement with the experimental data, the ABOC approach emerged as the most accurate and reliable for predicting CPH equilibrium temperatures, especially at higher salt concentrations.
  • Quick vs. Slow Dissociation: The quick dissociation method tends to yield slightly higher equilibrium temperatures (0-1.2 °C difference) compared to the slow method, likely due to incomplete dissociation and heat transfer effects. The slow method is therefore preferred for more precise data.

Key Results

  • The experimental equilibrium temperatures for CPH in the tested saline solutions ranged from 6.3 °C down to -4 °C, depending on the salt type and concentration.
  • The ABOC approach provided the best overall prediction accuracy, with an Average Absolute Deviation (AAD) of less than or equal to 0.38 °C.
  • The Kihara and ABOC methods generally outperformed SFPD and HLS, with AADs less than or equal to 0.49 °C and 0.38 °C, respectively.
  • The HLS correlation showed less reliable predictions for certain salts like K2SO4 and the CaCl2-MgCl2 mixture, with AADs up to 0.79 °C.
  • All four modeling approaches demonstrated a reliable capacity to predict hydrate formation temperatures, with overall AADs less than or equal to 0.79 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Uncertainties: The study acknowledges potential experimental uncertainties, particularly noted for a 10 wt.% NaBr solution, which showed significant errors across all modeling methods.
  • Limited Salt Systems: While a good range of salts was tested, future work could explore CPH in multi-salt mixtures that more closely mimic real seawater compositions.
  • Model Optimization: Further optimization of the modeling approaches is suggested to reduce AADs, especially for predicting equilibrium points in complex, multi-component brine systems.
  • Kinetic Studies: The authors highlight that this thermodynamic data is crucial for future kinetic studies, which are essential for designing and optimizing practical HBD applications.
  • Energy Efficiency: The paper reiterates that HBD operates at low temperatures and atmospheric pressure, requiring minimal energy and avoiding specialized high-pressure equipment, making it a promising, cost-effective, and safer desalination technology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Water shortage has been a serious issue for many years. Hydrate-based desalination (HBD) technology is a potential candidate for this solution. The present study investigates the use of Cyclopentane (CP) as a hydrate former for desalination through crystallization at low temperatures and atmospheric pressure. The primary objective of this work is to provide phase equilibrium data for CP hydrates (CPH) in the presence of novel salt systems, including NaBr, KBr, K2SO4, NaBr–KBr, NaCl–NaBr, KCl–KBr, Na2SO4–K2SO4, and CaCl2–MgCl2. Phase equilibrium temperatures were determined using both rapid and slow dissociation procedures. The van der Waals and Platteeuw-based Kihara (Kihara) approach, Hu-Lee-Sum (HLS) correlation, Standard Freezing Point Depression (SFPD) approach, and Activity-Based Occupancy Correlation (ABOC) were applied to model these new experimental data. The experimental results demonstrate that the differences between the quick and slow procedure data range from 0 °C to 1.2 °C. In addition, the increasing salt concentration enhances the inhibitory effect on hydrate formation. Furthermore, the influence of cations on the equilibrium temperature follows the decreasing order of Mg2+ > Ca2+ > Na+ > K+. In terms of halide anions, Br− exhibits a stronger impact on equilibrium temperature compared to Cl−. The thermodynamic modeling results (for all four models) show good agreement with the experimental data with the average absolute deviation (AAD) of less than or equal to 0.79 °C. The ABOC approach proves to be the most effective among the four methods evaluated for accurately reproducing the equilibrium temperature of CPH, with AAD less than or equal to 0.38 °C.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pham2025thermodynamic,
  author = {Trung-Kien Pham and Quynh-Trang Thi Hoang and Le Chen and Thien Hien Tran and Koemhong Bun and Ngo Thi Hong Le and Son Ho-Van and Van-Hieu Ngo and Quang-Duyen Le and Madina Naukanova and Muhammad Abuhuraira and Ana Cameirão and Jérôme Douzet and Jean‐Michel Herri and Baptiste Bouillot},
  title = {{Thermodynamic Experiments and Modelling of Cyclopentane Hydrates in the Presence of NaBr, KBr, K2SO4, NaBr–KBr, NaCl–NaBr, KCl–KBr, Na2SO4–K2SO4, and CaCl2–MgCl2}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17192916},
}

Loading related content...

Figure