Thermo-Optic Response and Optical Bistablility of Integrated High-Index Doped Silica Ring Resonators

Junkai Hu, Jiayang Wu, Di Jin, Sai T. Chu, Brent E. Little, Duan Huang, Roberto Morandotti, David MossSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper thoroughly investigates the thermo-optic properties of high-index doped silica (HIDS) microring resonators, providing a comprehensive characterization of their thermo-optic coefficient, optical-to-thermal conversion efficiency, and thermal conductivity. These findings are crucial for designing and optimizing HIDS-based photonic devices for various applications, including optical switching and signal processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The thermo-optic effect, where temperature changes alter a material's refractive index, is a fundamental mechanism for light manipulation in integrated photonics. While extensively studied in materials like silicon and silicon nitride, the thermo-optic behavior of high-index doped silica (HIDS) in microring resonators, a promising platform for nonlinear optics and integrated devices, remained less understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by providing a detailed experimental and theoretical analysis of HIDS's thermo-optic response, enabling better control and utilization of this effect in HIDS devices.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of experimental measurements and theoretical modeling. They fabricated HIDS microring resonators using standard CMOS-compatible processes. Their experimental characterization involved:

  • Transmission Spectroscopy: Measuring the transmission spectra of the HIDS MRRs under varying chip temperatures to observe resonance wavelength shifts.
  • Input Power Sweeps: Analyzing how resonance wavelengths and output power change with increasing input optical power to study optically induced thermo-optic effects and optical bistability.
  • Polarization Control: Utilizing a polarization controller to precisely measure TE and TM polarized light responses.

The theoretical analysis involved:

  • Scattering Matrix Method: Fitting experimental spectra to extract device parameters like coupling coefficients and round-trip amplitude transmission.
  • Lumerical FDTD Software: Simulating optical mode profiles and temperature distributions to extract material properties like thermo-optic coefficients and thermal conductivity.
  • Heat Equation Modeling: Applying the heat equation to understand heat generation and propagation within the waveguide.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements from fabricated devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HIDS as a Promising Material: HIDS exhibits a good balance of thermo-optic properties, making it suitable for various photonic applications.
  • Dominance of Thermo-Optic Effect: For HIDS, the thermo-optic effect is the primary driver of nonlinear optical responses at typical CW power levels, unlike silicon where free-carrier dispersion can also play a significant role.
  • Anisotropy in HIDS: While there's a slight difference in thermo-optic coefficients and thermal conductivity between TE and TM modes, it's attributed to the waveguide's asymmetric cross-section rather than inherent material anisotropy.
  • Optical Bistability Achieved: The study demonstrates clear optical bistability in HIDS microring resonators, a phenomenon crucial for optical switching and logic gates. The hysteresis loop's behavior (opening and shifting) with increasing detuning is well-characterized.
  • Low Thermal Conductivity Advantage: HIDS's relatively low thermal conductivity, compared to silica, is beneficial for applications like thermal mode locking in optical microcomb generation, as it leads to a slower thermal response that can be leveraged for stable operation.

Key Results

  • Thermo-optic Coefficient: Average values of ~1.49 × 10⁻⁵ /°C (TE) and ~1.44 × 10⁻⁵ /°C (TM) were obtained, showing good agreement between polarizations.
  • Optically Induced Thermo-Optic Process Efficiency (n₂): Average values of ~3.1 × 10⁻¹⁴ cm²/W (TE) and ~2.7 × 10⁻¹⁴ cm²/W (TM) were extracted, confirming the dominance of the thermo-optic effect over the Kerr effect.
  • Thermal Conductivity: Average values of ~0.66 W/(m·°C) (TE) and ~0.96 W/(m·°C) (TM) were measured, which are lower than silica.
  • Optical Bistability Threshold: The input power threshold for optical bistability increased with increasing wavelength detuning.
  • Comparison with Other Materials: HIDS shows a higher thermo-optic coefficient than silica but lower than silicon nitride and silicon. Its thermal conductivity is the lowest among the compared materials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Asymmetric Waveguide Cross-Section: The observed differences in TE and TM mode responses are attributed to the waveguide's asymmetric cross-section, which could be addressed in future designs for more isotropic behavior.
  • Power-Dependent Variations: Minor fluctuations in the extracted n₂ values across different input powers were observed, which the authors suggest might be due to measurement errors, indicating a need for further investigation into power stability.
  • Future Applications: The authors highlight the implications of these findings for optical microcombs, integrated photonic devices, and applications in classical and quantum computing. Further exploration of HIDS for high-performance nonlinear thermo-optic devices is encouraged.

Summary updated

Abstract

The engineering of thermo-optic effects has found broad applications in integrated photonic devices, facilitating efficient light manipulation to achieve various functionalities. Here, we perform both an experimental characterization and a theoretical analysis of these effects in integrated microring resonators made from high-index doped silica, which have had many applications in integrated photonics and nonlinear optics. By fitting the experimental results with theory, we obtain fundamental parameters that characterize their thermo-optic performance, including the thermo-optic coefficient, the efficiency of the optically induced thermo-optic process, and the thermal conductivity. The characteristics of these parameters are compared to those of other materials commonly used for integrated photonic platforms, such as silicon, silicon nitride, and silica. These results offer a comprehensive insight into the thermo-optic properties of doped silica-based devices. Understanding these properties is essential for efficiently controlling and engineering them in many practical applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2023thermo,
  author = {Junkai Hu and Jiayang Wu and Di Jin and Sai T. Chu and Brent E. Little and Duan Huang and Roberto Morandotti and David Moss},
  title = {{Thermo-Optic Response and Optical Bistablility of Integrated High-Index Doped Silica Ring Resonators}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23249767},
}

Loading related content...

Figure