Thermally assisted lubricity and negative work tails in sliding friction

Franco Pellegrini, Emanuele Panizon, Giuseppe E. Santoro, Erio TosattiPhysical Review. B./Physical Review. B 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper explores the fundamental connection between two phenomena in nanoscale friction: thermally assisted lubricity (TAL) and negative dissipated work (NDW) events. Using the one-dimensional Prandtl-Tomlinson model, we identify a general crossover when the total frictional work per cycle crosses the thermal energy threshold, $k_B T$. Below this crossover, the system exhibits linear viscous friction (TAL regime), and the Jarzynski equality (JE) is numerically verifiable. Above it, the system enters a hard stick-slip regime where JE verification requires exponentially large sampling. We also derive a parameter-free formula for the linear friction coefficient, significantly improving upon previous empirical models.

Introduction: The Nanoscale Friction Problem

At the macroscopic scale, friction is typically described by simple empirical laws. However, at the nanoscale, the behavior of a slider—such as an atomic force microscope (AFM) tip—is dominated by discrete "stick-slip" events as it moves over an atomic potential. Under specific conditions of high temperature or low velocity, this jerky motion transitions into a smooth, viscous-like regime known as thermally assisted lubricity (TAL).

Simultaneously, the Jarzynski Equality (JE) provides a bridge between non-equilibrium work and equilibrium free energy. Its validity hinges on the existence of rare thermal fluctuations that result in negative work—essentially "free lunches" where the environment gives energy back to the slider. This paper seeks to determine if a rigorous physical link exists between the onset of smooth sliding and the observability of these thermodynamic fluctuations.

Methods: Modeling the Slider

The researchers utilized the Prandtl-Tomlinson (PT) model, which represents a point mass slider dragged by a spring over a sinusoidal potential. To analyze the system, they applied adiabatic perturbation theory to the Fokker-Planck equation, allowing them to track the evolution of the slider's position probability distribution. These theoretical findings were validated through extensive overdamped Langevin dynamics simulations, spanning a wide range of temperatures ($k_B T = 0.01$ to $0.05$) and velocities.

Key Insights: The $k_B T$ Crossover

The central finding is that the transition between friction regimes is governed by the thermal energy, $k_B T$. When the average work per cycle $\langle W \rangle$ is less than $k_B T$, the system resides in the thermolubric regime. In this state, thermal fluctuations are strong enough to frequently push the slider over potential barriers, leading to smooth motion and a linear relationship between force and velocity.

Average work per cycle normalized by thermal energy vs. sliding velocity, showing the crossover at $\langle W \rangle / k_B T \approx 1$.

This regime is also where the Jarzynski Equality is most accessible. Because the system frequently samples negative work events (the "tails" of the work distribution), the JE can be verified with a reasonable number of experimental trials. As $\langle W \rangle$ exceeds $k_B T$, the probability of these negative work events drops exponentially, making the JE practically impossible to verify without an astronomical number of samples.

Work probability distributions $P(W)$ for different regimes. The shaded area represents the negative work tails essential for the Jarzynski Equality.

Key Results and a New Friction Formula

The study yielded several significant results:

  • Universal Scaling: When normalized by temperature ($\beta \langle W \rangle$), data from various temperatures collapse onto a single curve when plotted against rescaled velocity, confirming the universal nature of the $k_B T$ crossover.
  • JE Verification: The authors quantified the "bias error" in the Jarzynski estimator, showing that the required sample size $N$ scales as $e^{\beta \langle W \rangle}$.
  • Parameter-Free Prediction: A major theoretical contribution is the derivation of a new formula for the linear friction coefficient ($\gamma_{eq}$). Unlike previous models that relied on empirical fitting, this formula uses only the potential geometry and system damping, matching simulation data within ~15% across three orders of magnitude.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the theory holds for single-degree-of-freedom systems, the connection weakens in massive multi-contact interfaces. In large systems, local "free lunches" tend to cancel out, making global negative work unobservable even during smooth sliding.

The authors suggest that these findings could be tested in experimental setups involving trapped cold ions, where thermolubricity is known but work distributions are unexplored, or in forced protein unfolding, where the Jarzynski Equality is a standard tool. Future work may also extend these analytical derivations to underdamped systems where inertial effects become significant.

Summary updated

Abstract

We discuss and qualify the connection between two separate phenomena in the physics of nanoscale friction, general in nature and relevant to experiments. The first is thermally assisted lubricity (TAL), i.e., the low-velocity regime where a nanosized dry slider exhibits a viscouslike friction despite corrugations that would otherwise imply hard stick--slip friction. The second is the occurrence of negative dissipated work (NDW) events in sampling the work probability distribution. The abundance, or scarcity due to insufficient sampling, of these NDW events implies experimental fulfillment or violation of the celebrated Jarzynski equality (JE) of nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. We show, both analytically and in simulations of the one-dimensional point slider Prandtl-Tomlinson model, that a general crossover can be individuated as the total frictional work per cycle crosses ${k}_{B}T$. Below such crossover, the TAL regime holds, the dissipation is essentially linear, and the numerical validation for the JE is feasible (i.e., does not require an exponentially large sampling size). Above it, the dissipation profile departs from linearity and gains its hard stick--slip features, and the mandatory sampling for the JE becomes exponentially large. In addition, we derive a parameter-free formula expressing the linear velocity coefficient of viscous friction, correcting previous empirically parameterized expressions. With due caution, the connection between friction and work tails can be extended beyond a single degree of freedom to more complex sliders, thus inviting realistic crosscheck experiments. Of importance for experimental nanofriction will be the search for NDW tails in the sliding behavior of trapped cold ions, and alternatively checking for TAL in the sliding pattern of dragged colloid monolayers as well as in forced protein unwinding.
BibTeX
@article{pellegrini2019thermally,
  author = {Franco Pellegrini and Emanuele Panizon and Giuseppe E. Santoro and Erio Tosatti},
  title = {{Thermally assisted lubricity and negative work tails in sliding friction}},
  journal = {Physical Review. B./Physical Review. B},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.99.075428},
}
Figure