Thermal spin-crossover and temperature-dependent zero-field splitting in magnetic nanographene chains

Yan Wang, Alejandro Pérez Paz, Emil Viñas Boström, Xiaoxi Zhang, Juan Li, Reinhard Berger, K. Liu, Ji Ma, Li Huang, Shixuan Du, Hong‐Jun Gao, Kläus Müllen, Akimitsu Narita, Xinliang Feng, Ángel Rubio Salvador, C. di PalmaarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Nanographene-based magnetism at interfaces offers an avenue to designer quantum materials towards novel phases of matter and atomic-scale applications. Key to spintronics applications at the nanoscale is bistable spin-crossover which however remains to be demonstrated in nanographenes. Here we show that antiaromatic 1,4-disubstituted pyrazine-embedded nanographene derivatives, which promote magnetism through oxidation to a non-aromatic radical are prototypical models for the study of carbon-based thermal spin-crossover. Scanning tunneling spectroscopy studies reveal symmetric spin excitation signals which evolve at Tc to a zero-energy peak, and are assigned to the transition of a S = 3/2 high-spin to a S = 1/2 low-spin state by density functional theory. At temperatures below and close to the spin-crossover Tc, the high-spin S= 3/2 excitations evidence pronouncedly different temperature-dependent excitation energies corresponding to a zero-field splitting in the Hubbard-Kanamori Hamiltonian. The discovery of thermal spin crossover and temperature-dependent zero-field splitting in carbon nanomaterials promises to accelerate quantum information, spintronics and thermometry at the atomic scale.

Introduction

In the quest for "designer quantum materials," nanographenes—precisely shaped flakes of carbon—are leading candidates due to their tunable magnetic properties. A primary goal for spintronics is achieving bistable spin-crossover (SCO): the ability of a material to switch between two different magnetic states (high-spin and low-spin) in response to an external stimulus like temperature. While SCO is well-known in metal-organic complexes, it had never been convincingly demonstrated in pure nanographenes. The challenge lies in stability; most magnetic organic radicals are highly reactive and typically "quench" their spin when placed on metal surfaces. This study addresses this by using antiaromatic molecules that become stable, magnetic radical cations only after transferring an electron to a gold substrate.

Methods

The researchers synthesized diaza-hexabenzocoronene (diaza-HBC) chains on a gold (Au(111)) surface using on-surface synthesis. This process involves the controlled heating of precursor molecules to induce cyclodehydrogenation and polymerization.

On-surface synthesis of diaza-hexabenzocoronene (diaza-HBC) chains.

To probe the magnetic states, the team employed Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and Spectroscopy (STM/STS), allowing for the measurement of electronic "fingerprints" (dI/dV spectra) at temperatures ranging from 2 K to 4.5 K. These experimental results were supported by Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to model orbital energies and a Hubbard-Kanamori Hamiltonian to explain how the "zero-field splitting" (the energy gap between spin states) evolves with temperature.

Key Insights and Mechanism

The core innovation is the use of 1,4-disubstituted pyrazine-embedded nanographenes. These are antiaromatic and unstable in their neutral state but become stable "non-aromatic" radicals upon oxidation by the gold surface. This electron transfer ensures the magnetic centers remain active even at the metal interface.

Mechanism of electron transfer and thermal spin-crossover transitions, showing the evolution of spin states with temperature.

The system exhibits a thermal spin-crossover transition. At higher temperatures (above 4 K), the molecules show a Kondo resonance (a peak at zero energy), characteristic of an $S=1/2$ low-spin state. As the system cools toward 2 K, this peak disappears and is replaced by symmetric excitation peaks, signaling a transition to an $S=3/2$ high-spin state. This shift is driven by a competition between exchange coupling ($J$) and a temperature-dependent splitting parameter ($D'$).

Results and Discussion

The study confirmed a transition from a high-spin $S=3/2$ state at 2 K to a low-spin $S=1/2$ state at temperatures above a critical $T_c \approx 3$ K. A significant finding is the temperature-dependent zero-field splitting (ZFS). For the $S=3/2$ state, spin excitation energies shifted significantly with temperature, at a rate of roughly 10 meV/K. The authors attribute this to "volumetric effects"—tiny structural changes or molecular vibrations (phonons) that alter the electronic environment. STM data supported this, showing a 0.4 Å difference in apparent molecular length accompanying the magnetic transition.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work represents the first demonstration of thermal spin-crossover in carbon-based nanographene chains. While the current transition occurs at cryogenic temperatures (2–4 K), it paves the way for all-carbon quantum spintronics and atomic-scale thermometry. Future research will focus on tuning the nanographene geometry to increase the transition temperature and further exploring the specific vibrational modes that drive the spin-crossover.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nanographene-based magnetism at interfaces offers an avenue to designer quantum materials towards novel phases of matter and atomic-scale applications. Key to spintronics applications at the nanoscale is bistable spin-crossover which however remains to be demonstrated in nanographenes. Here we show that antiaromatic 1,4-disubstituted pyrazine-embedded nanographene derivatives, which promote magnetism through oxidation to a non-aromatic radical are prototypical models for the study of carbon-based thermal spin-crossover. Scanning tunneling spectroscopy studies reveal symmetric spin excitation signals which evolve at Tc to a zero-energy peak, and are assigned to the transition of a S = 3/2 high-spin to a S = 1/2 low-spin state by density functional theory. At temperatures below and close to the spin-crossover Tc, the high-spin S= 3/2 excitations evidence pronouncedly different temperature-dependent excitation energies corresponding to a zero-field splitting in the Hubbard-Kanamori Hamiltonian. The discovery of thermal spin crossover and temperature-dependent zero-field splitting in carbon nanomaterials promises to accelerate quantum information, spintronics and thermometry at the atomic scale.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2024thermal,
  author = {Yan Wang and Alejandro Pérez Paz and Emil Viñas Boström and Xiaoxi Zhang and Juan Li and Reinhard Berger and K. Liu and Ji Ma and Li Huang and Shixuan Du and Hong‐Jun Gao and Kläus Müllen and Akimitsu Narita and Xinliang Feng and Ángel Rubio Salvador and C. di Palma},
  title = {{Thermal spin-crossover and temperature-dependent zero-field splitting in magnetic nanographene chains}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.20996},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.20996},
}

Loading related content...

Figure