Thermal resistance matrix representation of thermal effects and thermal design in multi-finger power heterojunction bipolar transistors

Dongyue Jin, Wanrong Zhang, Liang Chen, Qiang Fu, Ying Xiao, Renqing Wang, Xin ZhaoChinese 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a "thermal resistance matrix" to model heat distribution in multi-finger power transistors. By optimizing the spacing between these fingers, they demonstrate a significant improvement in thermal stability and power handling capability, paving the way for more robust high-power electronic devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Multi-finger power transistors, crucial for high-power applications, suffer from a critical issue: self-heating. When these transistors dissipate power, they generate heat. In multi-finger designs, heat from one finger can transfer to adjacent ones (thermal coupling), leading to uneven temperature distribution. This unevenness can cause "thermal instability," where hotter fingers draw more current, generating even more heat, potentially leading to device failure or reduced performance. The paper aims to provide a systematic way to understand and mitigate these thermal effects, particularly in heterojunction bipolar transistors (HBTs), by developing a comprehensive thermal model and using it to optimize device layout.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development and application of a "thermal resistance matrix" ($[R_{ij}]$). This matrix quantifies two key thermal phenomena:

  • Self-heating thermal resistance ($R_{ii}$): How much a single finger heats up due to its own power dissipation.
  • Thermal coupling resistance ($R_{ij}$ for $i \neq j$): How much heat from finger $j$ contributes to the temperature rise of finger $i$.

The authors derive this matrix by solving the heat flow equation in a 3D multi-finger structure, considering specific boundary conditions (e.g., ambient temperature at the chip bottom, heat source on the top surface). They then use this matrix to analyze how finger spacing affects thermal resistance. Crucially, they employ this matrix to design a new layout for a 10-finger HBT with non-uniform finger spacing, aiming to optimize thermal performance. This involves an iterative process where they calculate finger temperatures and power dissipation, then adjust spacing, and repeat until an optimal configuration is found.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical modeling and simulation of a 10-finger HBT.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Thermal Resistance Matrix is Key: The $[R_{ij}]$ provides a powerful, unified framework to describe both self-heating and thermal coupling, offering a more complete picture than previous methods.
  • Finger Spacing Matters Significantly: Increasing the spacing between fingers generally reduces both self-heating ($R_{ii}$) and thermal coupling ($R_{ij}$). This is because wider spacing widens the heat dissipation path and reduces heat transfer between adjacent fingers.
  • Non-uniform Spacing is Optimal: While uniform spacing is common, the paper demonstrates that strategically varying the spacing can lead to superior thermal performance. Specifically, increasing spacing in the central fingers (where heat tends to concentrate) and potentially decreasing it at the edges can significantly improve thermal stability.
  • Thermal Stability Enhances Power Handling: By reducing peak temperatures and improving temperature uniformity across fingers, the optimized device can operate at higher power levels without compromising reliability.

Key Results

  • The thermal coupling resistance ($R_{ij}$ for $i \neq j$) was found to decrease exponentially with increasing finger spacing, particularly for spacings larger than 10 µm.
  • For a 10-finger HBT, optimizing the finger spacing from a uniform 10.8 µm to a non-uniform pattern (7.8, 8.8, 10.8, 13.8, 14.8, 13.8, 10.8, 8.8, 7.8 µm) resulted in:
  • A lower peak temperature (reduced by 3.76 K at Ic=150 mA, VCE=5V).
  • A significant improvement in temperature uniformity (50.52% improvement).
  • A substantial increase in power level uniformity (51.33% improvement).
  • As collector-emitter voltage (VCE) increased from 5V to 7V, the benefits of the non-uniform spacing became even more pronounced, with peak temperature improvements reaching up to 14.91 K and temperature profile uniformity improving to 61.88%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The thermal model assumes a constant temperature for each emitter finger's average temperature and relies on solving the heat flow equation with specific boundary conditions. Real-world scenarios might involve more complex heat distributions within each finger.
  • Material Properties: The calculations are based on specific material properties (e.g., thermal conductivity of the substrate). Variations in these properties could affect the results.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this research provides a valuable guide for designing thermally stable power HBTs. Future work could involve extending this thermal resistance matrix approach to other types of power transistors or exploring more complex non-uniform spacing patterns. Further experimental validation of the simulation results would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The thermal resistance matrix including self-heating thermal resistance and thermal coupling resistance is presented to describe the thermal effects of multi-finger power heterojunction bipolar transistors. The dependence of thermal resistance matrix on finger spacing is also investigated. It is shown that both self-heating thermal resistance and thermal coupling resistance are lowered by increasing the finger spacing, in which the downward dissipated heat path is widened and the heat flow from adjacent fingers is effectively suppressed. The decrease of self-heating thermal resistance and thermal coupling resistance is helpful for improving the thermal stability of power devices. Furthermore, with the aid of the thermal resistance matrix, a 10-finger power heterojunction bipolar transistor (HBT) with non-uniform finger spacing is designed for high thermal stability. The optimized structure can effectively lower the peak temperature while maintaining a uniformity of the temperature profile at various biases and thus the device effectively may operate at a higher power level.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jin2011thermal,
  author = {Dongyue Jin and Wanrong Zhang and Liang Chen and Qiang Fu and Ying Xiao and Renqing Wang and Xin Zhao},
  title = {{Thermal resistance matrix representation of thermal effects and thermal design in multi-finger power heterojunction bipolar transistors}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1056/20/6/064401},
}

Loading related content...

Figure