Thermal Properties and Fire Resistance of Cement Base Material for Road Pavement Based on Finite Element Analysis

Chenglong MaInternational Journal of Heat and Technology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a numerical framework using Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and Python to simulate how cement-based road pavements respond to extreme heat and fire. By integrating transient heat conduction equations with mechanical stress-strain models, the research successfully predicts internal temperature gradients and structural deformations, validated by experimental data with a high degree of accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Road pavements are often viewed as static slabs of stone, but they are complex chemical and mechanical systems. When exposed to high temperatures—whether from extreme weather or vehicle fires—the cement-based materials (concrete, grout, mortar) undergo significant physical and chemical shifts.

The primary challenge is "temperature stress." Different components within the cement matrix have varying thermal expansion coefficients. As heat rises, these components expand at different rates, leading to internal cracking, mass reduction, and a sharp decline in structural durability. While much research exists on building fires, the author notes a significant gap in understanding the fire resistance of road-specific cement materials. This paper aims to fill that void, providing a predictive model to help engineers design more resilient infrastructure and better maintenance protocols.

Methods

The author employs a multi-staged approach combining theoretical physics, numerical simulation, and physical experimentation:

  1. Thermal Modeling: The study starts with the one-dimensional transient heat conduction equation to analyze temperature gradients. It utilizes standard fire curves (ISO 834 and ASTM E119) to simulate realistic fire scenarios, including a cooling phase where the flame begins to extinguish—a detail often overlooked in simpler models.
  2. Finite Element Analysis (FEA): Using Python, the author built a model that sub-divides cement specimens into 1mm² units. The simulation uses 4-node PLANE13 thermal coupling units to calculate how heat moves from the surface to the core via conduction, convection, and radiation.
  3. Mechanical Analysis: The model doesn't just look at heat; it calculates "total strain" as the sum of mechanical strain ($\rho_F$) and thermal strain ($\rho_T$). By applying the principle of virtual work and iterative programming, the model predicts the bending moments and vertical deflections of the pavement under fire.
  4. Experimental Validation: To ensure the model's "real-world" utility, the author measured the internal temperature rise of three physical specimens and compared these results against the FEA predictions at nine distinct coordinates.

Datasets

The study relies on primary experimental data generated by the author:

  • Internal Temperature Rise Data: Recorded from three cement specimens at depths of 30mm, 60mm, and 90mm.
  • Analytical Benchmarks: The FEA results were compared against classical analytical solutions for heat conduction to verify the algorithm's precision.
  • Standard Fire Curves: The ISO 834 and ASTM E119 temperature-time datasets were used as the environmental input for the simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Early-Stage Surge: Both the model and experiments showed that internal temperatures rise most rapidly during the early stages of fire exposure. This suggests that the "thermal shock" in the first few minutes is the most critical window for structural damage.
  • Gradient-Driven Rise: The primary driver of internal temperature increase isn't just the external heat, but the change in the internal temperature gradient. As the duration of high heat increases, the rate of change in the gradient decreases.
  • Mesh Sensitivity: The research highlights that increasing the number of layers in the FEA model significantly improves the convergence rate. For engineers, this means that while finer grids require more computing power, they are essential for capturing the non-linear thermal stress at the pavement's surface.
  • Proximity Matters: There is a non-linear relationship between flame proximity and displacement. Points closer to the flame showed massive, rapid vertical shifts, while points further away remained relatively stable (less than 50cm displacement), even as the fire continued.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy: The maximum relative error between the FEA attained solutions and the analytical solutions was only 0.152, confirming that the Python-based model is a reliable proxy for physical testing.
  • Consistent Evolution: Experimental results across three different specimens showed nearly identical evolution laws, proving the reproducibility of the thermal response in road cement.
  • Convergence: The thermal stress calculations successfully converged to the reference solutions as grid size decreased and layer numbers increased, providing a blueprint for future simulation settings.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges a few key simplifications that could be refined in future iterations:

  • Ignoring Cracks: The simulated curves are "smooth" because the model currently ignores the physical peeling and cracking of the cement during the fire. In reality, these cracks would change the thermal conductivity of the material mid-fire.
  • Internal Heat: The model assumes the cement itself produces no inherent heat ($W=0$). While generally true, certain chemical decompositions at extreme temperatures might be exothermic or endothermic.
  • Future Direction: The author suggests that further research should incorporate the "peeling" effect of road cement in high-temperature environments to create an even more realistic structural failure model.

Reference: Ma, C. (2023). Thermal Properties and Fire Resistance of Cement Base Material for Road Pavement Based on Finite Element Analysis. International Journal of Heat and Technology, 41(1), 271-277. https://doi.org/10.18280/ijht.410131

Summary updated

Abstract

The physical and chemical properties of cement base material for road pavement will undergo changes in high temperature environment, so improving the high temperature resistance and fire resistance of cement base material is very important for reducing the loss of road projects caused by high temperature.In actual engineering projects, maintenance measures are often adopted to repair the damaged components so that the roads could be used continuously, however, research on the thermal properties and fire resistance of cement base components of road pavement is insufficient, therefore, in view of this blank, this paper aims to study the thermal properties and fire resistance of road cement base material based on finite element analysis.At first, this paper measured the temperature inside the road cement base during the process of environmental thermal fatigue, analyzed the law of the response of cement base to the temperature changes under the action of relative humidity in the micro environment, and figured out the delay time of such response and the changes of internal temperature gradient.Then, this paper selected proper thermal parameters of road cement material and the stress-strain relationship under compression or tension in high temperature environment, and used the software Python to perform finite element analysis on the fire resistance of road cement base specimens.At last, the corresponding experimental results were given and the validity of the constructed model was verified.
BibTeX
@article{ma2023thermal,
  author = {Chenglong Ma},
  title = {{Thermal Properties and Fire Resistance of Cement Base Material for Road Pavement Based on Finite Element Analysis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Heat and Technology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.18280/ijht.410131},
}
Figure