Thermal Performance and Energy Saving Benefits of Photovoltaic-Cool Roof: A Case Study in Shanghai Area

Qinglin Yang, Yang He, Lukai Zhou, Mengmeng Dai, Wenze Wu, Shisheng Chen, Ruijie Liu, Zhexin Wei, Changbang Luo, Yiwei LuBuildings 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the combined benefits of photovoltaic (PV) panels and cool roof technology (PVCR) for energy savings in Shanghai's hot-summer and cold-winter climate. By conducting field experiments and developing a validated numerical model, the research demonstrates that PVCR systems significantly reduce building cooling loads and improve thermal comfort compared to conventional roofs, offering a promising solution for sustainable urban development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Global warming and the urban heat island (UHI) effect are driving up building energy consumption, particularly for cooling. While both photovoltaic roofs (PVR) and cool roofs (CR) offer energy-saving potential, research on their combined application (PVCR) is limited. Crucially, the synergistic interactions between PV modules and high-reflectivity cool roof surfaces, and how these influence thermal performance and energy savings, have not been fully understood, especially in diverse climatic regions like Shanghai's hot-summer and cold-winter zone. This paper aims to fill this gap by experimentally and numerically evaluating the PVCR system's performance and identifying optimal design parameters.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Field Experiment: Four roof configurations were tested on an office building in Shanghai: Photovoltaic-Cool Roof (PVCR), Photovoltaic Roof (PVR), Cool Roof (CR), and Asphalt Roof (AR). Detailed measurements of surface temperatures, air temperatures, solar radiation, and wind speed were collected over several clear days in summer and winter.
  • Numerical Modeling: A coupled heat transfer model was developed to simulate the PVCR system. This model integrates established models for PV roofs and cool roofs, explicitly accounting for key interactions:
  • Shading effect of PV modules on the cool roof.
  • Multiple shortwave radiation reflections between PV modules and the roof.
  • Longwave radiative exchange between PV modules, the cool roof, and the sky.
  • Convective heat transfer and the influence of the cool roof's high solar reflectance on PV module temperature.
  • Aerodynamic effects of PV modules on airflow.

The model was validated against the experimental data. Subsequently, the validated model was coupled with a building energy simulation platform (THERB) to assess annual energy savings. Sensitivity analyses were performed on PV array spacing and installation height.

Datasets

The study utilized meteorological data for Shanghai, China, including annual precipitation, average annual global solar radiation, typical summer outdoor air temperatures, and average annual relative humidity. Experimental data collected from the field tests on the four roof configurations served as the primary dataset for model validation. Building envelope and service settings data for a typical commercial office building were also used for the simulation phase.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Cooling: The PVCR system demonstrates a significant synergistic cooling effect, outperforming both standalone PVR and CR systems. The high reflectivity of the cool roof layer significantly reduces the roof surface temperature, and the PV modules further enhance this by providing shading.
  • Diurnal Temperature Stability: PVCR systems lead to smaller diurnal temperature fluctuations on the roof surface, which can extend the service life of roof structural layers.
  • PV Module Temperature Dynamics: While PVCR generally leads to lower average PV module temperatures, a short-term peak temperature increase can occur around solar noon in summer due to enhanced reflected shortwave radiation from the cool roof. This effect is transient and does not negate the overall cooling benefit.
  • Backside Radiation Matters: The high reflectivity of the cool roof significantly increases the solar radiation received by the back surfaces of PV modules, a factor largely absent in PVR systems with conventional roofs. This is particularly important for bifacial PV modules.
  • Optimization Potential: PV array spacing and installation height are critical parameters for optimizing PVCR performance, influencing both energy demand and electricity generation.

Key Results

  • Daytime Cooling: PVCR achieved a remarkable daytime cooling effect, with a maximum roof surface temperature reduction of 29 °C compared to the asphalt roof (AR).
  • PV Module Temperature: PV modules on the PVCR system exhibited a lower average temperature by 0.15 °C compared to those on an asphalt roof.
  • Annual Energy Savings:
    • Compared to an asphalt roof, the PVR roof saved 1683.97 kWh of electricity annually.
  • The PVCR roof saved 3005.34 kWh annually.
  • PVCR also increased annual PV production by 1244.55 kWh compared to PVR.
  • Model Validation: The developed numerical model accurately reproduced the temporal variations of measured parameters (roof and PV module temperatures) with RMSE values generally below 2 °C and R² values above 0.87.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Increasing PV array spacing from 0.3 m to 0.5 m led to increased AC energy consumption but also increased solar power generation and total energy savings. Increasing installation height decreased AC energy consumption and increased solar power generation and total energy savings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Building Type: The study focused on a typical office building (low-rise). Future research should investigate PVCR performance in high-rise buildings, commercial, and industrial structures, as these may have different roof structures, ventilation, and load constraints.
  • Cool Roof Variety: Only one type of cool roof surface was tested. Further investigation into different high-reflectivity surfaces and their mechanisms is needed.
  • Surface Durability and Cleanliness: The long-term performance and influence of surface cleanliness on PV module efficiency were not addressed and warrant future study.
  • Climate Diversity: The study was conducted in Shanghai's hot-summer and cold-winter zone. While the model is transferable, further experimental validation across diverse climatic regions is necessary to fully understand PVCR's global applicability.
  • Bifacial PV: While the study touched upon bifacial PV, a more in-depth comparative analysis with monofacial PV across various conditions would be beneficial.

The authors suggest expanding the performance database through more field experiments and numerical studies to cover different building types and climatic zones, enhancing the universality and engineering reference value of PVCR applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Driven by the combined effects of global warming and the urban heat island (UHI) effect, building energy consumption has been rising steadily in recent years. The photovoltaic-cool roof (PVCR) system has emerged as an effective solution for urban energy conservation and carbon reduction. However, existing research on the energy-saving benefits of PVCR remains relatively limited, and none of these studies have considered the interaction between photovoltaic modules and high-reflectivity roofs (also called cool roof, CR). Therefore, field experiments were conducted to compare the thermal performance of the PVCR system against that of three conventional roof configurations, including photovoltaic roof (PVR), asphalt roof (AR), and CR. The results demonstrate that the PVCR system achieves a remarkable daytime cooling effect, with a maximum temperature reduction of 29 °C compared to the AR system, and maintains lower temperature fluctuations throughout the entire day. In addition, the findings reveal that the photovoltaic modules exhibit a lower average temperature when installed on the cool roof, with a temperature decrease of 0.15 °C relative to the asphalt roof. A numerical model incorporating the photothermal interaction between a high-reflectivity surface and PV modules was developed and validated with experimental data. The numerical model considers the interactions between the photovoltaic (PV) modules and the high reflectivity surface, including shortwave radiation reflection, longwave radiative exchange, and convective heat transfer. The sensitivity analysis indicates that a change in the spacing and height of the PV arrays from 0.3 m to 0.5 m increases the relative energy-saving efficiency of the system. The conclusions drawn in this paper can provide a reference for the application of the PVCR system in hot-summer and cold-winter areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2026thermal,
  author = {Qinglin Yang and Yang He and Lukai Zhou and Mengmeng Dai and Wenze Wu and Shisheng Chen and Ruijie Liu and Zhexin Wei and Changbang Luo and Yiwei Lu},
  title = {{Thermal Performance and Energy Saving Benefits of Photovoltaic-Cool Roof: A Case Study in Shanghai Area}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings16040762},
}
Figure