Thermal Management for a Stadium Power Supply Container Using a Rack-Level Air Cooling Strategy

Yue Dong, Yi Ding, Karem Elsayed Elfeky, Yu Qi, Wenxiao Chu, Qiuwang WangEnergies 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of thermal management in stadium power supply containers, which house large battery energy storage systems. By developing a simplified porous media model and employing CFD simulations, the researchers propose and validate a rack-level air cooling strategy that significantly improves temperature uniformity within the battery cabinets, keeping overall thermal deviation within 1.0 K.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stadiums and large event venues rely heavily on robust power supply systems, especially for critical functions like lighting, audio-visual systems, and security. Battery energy storage systems (BESS) are increasingly integrated to ensure reliable power, often utilizing large arrays of batteries within shipping container-like enclosures. However, during charging and discharging, these batteries generate significant heat. Uneven temperature distribution within these densely packed battery modules can lead to performance degradation, reduced lifespan, and even safety hazards like thermal runaway. Existing centralized air-cooling systems for such containers face challenges with long air supply distances and complex ductwork. This paper aims to address these limitations by investigating and proposing a more efficient, rack-level thermal management strategy for these BESS containers.

Methods

The core of this research lies in computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations. To handle the complexity of numerous battery modules, the authors developed a simplified porous media model. This approach treats the battery modules within a cabinet as a porous zone, significantly reducing computational load while still capturing the flow resistance characteristics. The model was validated against experimental data for a data center cabinet, demonstrating good accuracy (within 10% error for pressure drop).

The study then simulated two main air-cooling strategies:

  1. Centralized Air-Cooling: This involved analyzing the impact of different air supply channel structures (specifically, the width of the bottom air channel) and varying inlet air speeds and battery heat loads on temperature distribution.
  2. Closed Cabinet Air Cooling (Rack-Level): This approach, which is the focus of the proposed solution, involves a heat exchanger within each cabinet. The paper investigated the placement of this heat exchanger (top, center, bottom) and introduced a novel wavy, tapered cabinet shell design inspired by bionics. This design aims to optimize airflow and minimize backflow, thereby enhancing cooling efficiency.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. For validation purposes, the authors referenced experimental data from a previous study by Chu et al. [27] on a standard 42U test cabinet simulating data center servers. This experimental data was used to validate the accuracy of their CFD modeling approach for air flow and temperature distribution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Porous Media Model is Key: The development and validation of a simplified porous media model for battery cabinets is a crucial step, enabling efficient CFD analysis of complex BESS configurations.
  • Bottom Air Channel Matters: For centralized cooling, the width of the bottom air channel significantly impacts flow uniformity. A reduction to 2/3 of the original size improved flow uniformity by 5% and reduced temperature standard deviation.
  • Higher Airflow, Better Uniformity: Increasing the cold air supply velocity (from 3 m/s to 8 m/s) effectively reduced the temperature standard deviation by 0.18 K, leading to better temperature uniformity.
  • Heat Load is a Major Driver of Non-Uniformity: As the charge-discharge ratio (and thus heat output) increases, temperature deviations become much more pronounced. At 0.5 C, the temperature deviation reached a significant 8 K.
  • Rack-Level Cooling is Promising: The closed cabinet approach with an internal heat exchanger offers localized control and reduces the impact of inter-cabinet temperature variations.
  • Bionic Design for Airflow: The novel wavy, tapered cabinet shell design is a key innovation. It effectively mitigates backflow issues common in rectangular cabinets, leading to improved air utilization and reduced temperature differences.

Key Results

  • Reducing the bottom air channel width to 2/3 of the original size in a centralized cooling setup improved inlet flow uniformity by 5%.
  • Increasing air supply velocity from 3 m/s to 8 m/s decreased temperature standard deviation by 0.18 K.
  • At a 0.5 C charge-discharge ratio, the temperature deviation of the entire cabinet reached 8 K.
  • The proposed wavy cabinet design, with the heat exchanger in the middle, showed a 4% increase in cold air energy utilization efficiency and a 0.7 K decrease in average cabinet temperature compared to a rectangular cabinet.
  • The wavy cabinet design reduced the internal thermal deviation of battery cabins by approximately 0.1 K, improving system safety.
  • The overall thermal deviation in the wavy cabinet design was controlled within 1.0 K.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation Limitations: The derived correlation expressions for resistance coefficients are noted to have limitations, specifically applying to battery cabin models with 2–4 columns and 2–4 rows of batteries, and an aspect ratio less than 1/2.
  • Experimental Validation of Novel Design: While the porous media model was validated, the paper primarily relies on CFD simulations for the novel wavy cabinet design. Further experimental validation of this specific design would strengthen the findings.
  • Focus on Air Cooling: The study focuses exclusively on air cooling. Future work could explore hybrid cooling strategies or the integration of advanced materials like phase change materials (PCMs) for enhanced thermal management.
  • Optimization of Parameters: While the study explores various parameters, further optimization of the wavy cabinet's helix parameters and heat exchanger placement could potentially yield even better results.
  • Scalability: Investigating the scalability of this rack-level cooling strategy to larger and more complex energy storage systems would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the airflow and thermal management of a compact electric energy storage system by using computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulation. A porous medium model for predicting the flow resistance performance of the battery modules in a battery cabinet is developed. By studying the influence of rack shapes, the effects of heat exchanger arrangements and other parameters on the airflow and battery thermal distribution are analyzed. When applying a larger bottom air channel, the inlet flow uniformity of each battery cabin in the cabinet increases by 5%. Meanwhile, temperature standard deviation decreases by 0.18 while raising the flow rate from 3 m/s to 8 m/s, indicating better temperature uniformity in the battery cabin. When the charge–discharge ratio reaches 0.5 C, the temperature deviation of the entire cabinet significantly increases, reaching 8 K. Furthermore, a rack-level thermal management scheme is proposed to effectively reduce the thermal deviation of the container electric energy storage system and improve the overall temperature uniformity. Results reveal that the rack-level thermal management of the wavy cabinet in the electric storage container can effectively improve the thermal uniformity of the distributed battery cabin, and the overall thermal deviation is controlled within 1.0 K.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2024thermal,
  author = {Yue Dong and Yi Ding and Karem Elsayed Elfeky and Yu Qi and Wenxiao Chu and Qiuwang Wang},
  title = {{Thermal Management for a Stadium Power Supply Container Using a Rack-Level Air Cooling Strategy}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/en17071654},
}
Figure