Thermal Load Analysis of Piston Damaged by Wall-Wetting Combustion in a Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine

Haiying Li, Yaozong Li, Yanzhao An, Yi Zhang, Zhicheng Shi, Weiqing Zhu, Yongping Qiang, Ziyu WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the causes of piston damage in heavy-duty diesel engines operating under cold conditions. By combining computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and finite element analysis (FEA), the study reveals that lower initial cylinder temperatures lead to increased fuel wall wetting and rough combustion, significantly elevating piston temperatures and thermal stress, particularly around the valve pocket.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy-duty diesel engines are experiencing increased piston erosion, a critical issue impacting engine durability and performance. This problem is particularly prevalent under cold operating conditions. While piston damage is known to be linked to thermal loads, the specific mechanisms by which wall-wetting combustion, a phenomenon exacerbated at low temperatures, contributes to this damage, especially the localized thermal stresses, remained unclear. This research aims to bridge this knowledge gap by simulating and analyzing the thermal behavior of pistons under these challenging conditions.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged computational approach:

  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): A detailed CFD model of a heavy-duty diesel engine combustion chamber was developed. This model incorporates various sub-models for droplet breakup, evaporation, collision, spray-wall interaction, turbulence (RNG k-e), and combustion (SAGE). The CFD simulations were used to analyze the in-cylinder fuel-air mixing, spray penetration, wall film formation, and combustion characteristics at different initial cylinder temperatures.
  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA): A 3D solid model of a prototype piston was created and meshed for FEA. This analysis focused on calculating the piston's thermal load. The heat transfer boundary conditions for the FEA were derived from the CFD simulations, specifically mapping the average gas temperature and heat transfer coefficients onto the piston surface at different stages of the combustion cycle. Both steady-state and transient thermal analyses were performed.

The CFD model was validated against experimental data for spray penetration and in-cylinder pressure. The FEA model was validated against experimental temperature measurements at various points on the piston.

Datasets

The study does not introduce new experimental datasets. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental data for validation: The CFD model was validated using experimental results from a constant-volume chamber for spray penetration and from an engine thermal performance bench for in-cylinder pressure.
  • Experimental temperature measurements: The FEA model was validated against measured piston temperatures at specific points, as depicted in Figure 6.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cold Starts Amplify Wall Wetting: Lower initial cylinder temperatures drastically increase the amount of fuel that adheres to the cylinder walls (wall wetting). This is a direct consequence of poor fuel atomization and slower evaporation at colder temperatures.
  • Wall Wetting Fuels Rough Combustion: The increased fuel film on the piston surface, combined with delayed ignition at lower temperatures, leads to a larger amount of premixed fuel-air mixture. This results in more intense, "rough" combustion events with rapid pressure rises.
  • Localized Hot Spots are Critical: The FEA results highlight that the highest piston temperatures and temperature fluctuations are not uniformly distributed. The throat of the valve pocket emerges as a particularly vulnerable area, experiencing significantly higher temperatures and amplitudes of temperature change as cylinder temperatures drop.
  • Temperature Gradients Matter: The study emphasizes that not only peak temperatures but also the temperature gradients within the piston material are crucial. Rapid temperature decay in the depth direction of critical areas like the valve pocket throat suggests localized thermal stress concentrations.
  • Exceeding 700K is a Tipping Point: Temperatures above 700 K on the piston surface are identified as a threshold where severe thermo-mechanical fatigue, creep, and micro-plastic deformation become significant, increasing the likelihood of damage and failure.

Key Results

  • Wall Wetting Increase: Decreasing the initial cylinder temperature from 380 K to 307 K increased the mass of fuel adhering to the wall by 73%.
  • Combustion Pressure: The maximum combustion pressure increased from 8.1 MPa (at 380 K) to 11.6 MPa (at 328 K).
  • Valve Pocket Temperature: When the initial temperature dropped from 350 K to 328 K, the highest temperature at the valve pocket throat increased by nearly 100 K, and its temperature fluctuation amplitude doubled.
  • Areas Exceeding 700K: In the case of 328 K initial temperature, areas exceeding 700 K were concentrated on the top surface of the piston, particularly around the valve pocket.
  • Evaporation Increase: The proportion of wall film mass that evaporates increased from 20.7% (at 380 K) to 70.7% (at 307 K).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The FEA model simplified the piston geometry by ignoring oil passages and some rounded corners. While validated, these simplifications might have minor impacts on the precise thermal distribution.
  • Material Properties: The study focuses on thermal load. A more comprehensive analysis could incorporate detailed material fatigue models and creep behavior under these extreme thermal cycling conditions.
  • Experimental Validation of Transient Behavior: While steady-state FEA was validated, further experimental validation of the transient temperature distributions and fluctuations under these specific cold-start conditions would strengthen the findings.

The authors suggest that understanding these thermal characteristics is crucial for designing more durable pistons and mitigating damage in heavy-duty diesel engines operating in cold environments. Future work could explore specific design modifications or control strategies to alleviate these thermal stresses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Piston damage is a frequent problem of engine durability and plays an important role in an engine’s performance design. Recently, a large amount of piston erosion has occurred in a series of heavy-duty diesel engines. To investigate the reason for the piston erosion, a study of the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) of the combustion process in the cylinder and finite element analysis (FEA) of piston was carried out under different initial temperatures. The results show that when the initial temperature decreases from 380 K to 307 K, the mass of wall-wetting increases by 73%, and the maximum combustion pressure increases from 8.1 MPa to 11 MPa; when the initial temperature decreases from 350 K to 328 K, the highest temperature at the throat of the valve pocket increases by nearly 100 K, doubling the temperature fluctuation; and in the case of 328 K, areas exceeding 700 K are concentrated on the top surface of the piston, and the temperature gradient in the depth direction of the throat position decays rapidly.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023thermal,
  author = {Haiying Li and Yaozong Li and Yanzhao An and Yi Zhang and Zhicheng Shi and Weiqing Zhu and Yongping Qiang and Ziyu Wang},
  title = {{Thermal Load Analysis of Piston Damaged by Wall-Wetting Combustion in a Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151914634},
}
Figure