Thermal Behavior and Kinetics of Shenmu Coal Pyrolyzed under Hydrogen-Rich or Methane-Gas-Rich Atmosphere

Chong Zou, Xi Li, Mengmeng Ren, Weian Wang, Hao WuEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how hydrogen (H₂) and methane (CH₄) atmospheres affect the thermal decomposition of Shenmu coal, revealing that these gases promote the release of volatile matter and reduce the energy needed for pyrolysis. The findings suggest that H₂ and CH₄ can selectively break certain chemical bonds in coal, influencing the composition of pyrolysis products and offering insights for optimizing coal conversion processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coal pyrolysis, a crucial process for converting coal into valuable products like tar and semi-coke, is significantly influenced by the surrounding atmosphere. While nitrogen (N₂) is a common inert atmosphere, the presence of reactive gases like H₂ and CH₄, often found in industrial pyrolysis reactors, can alter the reaction pathways and product yields. Understanding these atmospheric effects is vital for optimizing pyrolysis efficiency and product selectivity. This paper specifically addresses the need to quantify how H₂-rich and CH₄-rich atmospheres impact the thermal behavior and kinetic parameters of Shenmu coal, a low-rank coal with high volatile content, which is particularly suitable for tar extraction.

Methods

The researchers employed a thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) coupled with a quadrupole mass spectrometer (TG-MS) to simultaneously monitor weight loss and identify gaseous products during coal pyrolysis. This allowed them to track the release of various gases like CH₄, H₂, H₂O, CO, and CO₂ under different atmospheric conditions.

To analyze the pyrolysis kinetics, the study utilized the Distributed Activation Energy Model (DAEM). DAEM is a well-established method that accounts for the distribution of activation energies within the coal matrix, making it suitable for complex solid-phase reactions like pyrolysis. The researchers applied the Miura integral method, a simplified approach within DAEM, to calculate the activation energy (Ea) and the activation energy distribution function.

Additionally, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) was used to analyze the functional group composition of the raw coal and the resulting semi-coke samples, providing insights into how the different atmospheres affected the chemical structure of the coal.

Datasets

The study used Shenmu low-rank coal as the experimental material. Proximate and ultimate analyses of this coal are provided in Table 1. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the research focused on experimental data generated from the pyrolysis of this specific coal under controlled conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • H₂ and CH₄ as Pyrolysis Promoters: Both H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres significantly promote coal pyrolysis, shifting the weight-loss curves to lower temperatures compared to an N₂ atmosphere. This indicates that these gases facilitate the decomposition of coal.
  • Selective Bond Cleavage: H₂ appears to preferentially promote the cleavage of CH-like functional groups by providing reactive hydrogen. Conversely, both H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres seem to inhibit the breakdown of oxygen-containing functional groups (like carbonyl and C-O), which is detrimental to the production of CO and CO₂.
  • Reduced Activation Energy: Pyrolysis under H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres requires less energy (lower activation energy) compared to N₂. This is a key finding for energy efficiency in coal conversion.
  • Non-Gaussian Activation Energy Distribution: The study found that the activation energy distribution under H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres does not follow a typical Gaussian distribution, suggesting a more complex kinetic behavior than initially assumed by some models.
  • H₂ vs. CH₄ Effects: While both gases promote pyrolysis, H₂ showed a slightly stronger effect in promoting volatile release and reducing activation energy compared to CH₄.

Key Results

  • Weight Loss Promotion: The H₂ atmosphere led to a higher weight loss in the second and third stages of pyrolysis (above 380 °C) compared to N₂.
  • Gas Product Enhancement: Release of H₂, CH₄, and H₂O was significantly stronger under H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres than under N₂.
  • Activation Energy Reduction: The activation energy for pyrolysis under H₂ and CH₄ was lower than under N₂. Specifically, Ea for H₂ was concentrated in the range of 175–215 kJ/mol, and for CH₄, it was 225–230 kJ/mol, both lower than the 250–275 kJ/mol range observed for N₂.
  • Narrow Activation Energy Distribution: The activation energy distribution was found to be narrow under H₂ and CH₄, unlike the broader distribution often seen with Gaussian models.
  • Heating Rate Impact: Increasing the heating rate shifted the pyrolysis weight-loss curves to higher temperatures, a common observation in thermal analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the activation energy distribution obtained via DAEM did not conform to the Gaussian function, which is a common assumption. This suggests that while DAEM is effective, the underlying kinetic model might need further refinement for these specific atmospheric conditions.

Future work could focus on:

  • Detailed Mechanistic Studies: Further investigating the specific chemical reactions and intermediate species involved in the promotion and inhibition effects observed under H₂ and CH₄ atmospheres.
  • Optimization of Pyrolysis Conditions: Using these kinetic insights to optimize pyrolysis parameters (temperature, pressure, gas composition) for maximizing desired product yields (e.g., tar) and minimizing unwanted byproducts.
  • Broader Range of Coal Ranks and Atmospheres: Extending this research to other types of coal and a wider range of gas compositions to develop more generalized models for coal pyrolysis.
  • Industrial Scale-Up: Investigating how these findings translate to larger-scale industrial pyrolysis processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pyrolysis characteristics of Shenmu coal under an atmosphere containing H2 (40%) and another containing CH4 (40%) were studied via a thermogravimetric analysis, and the kinetic parameters of pyrolysis were calculated by using a distributed activation energy model (DAEM). The results showed that H2 promoted the cleavage of CH-like functional groups by providing reactive hydrogen groups to combine with CH groups and –OH groups in the coal. However, the H2 and CH4 atmosphere inhibits the cleavage of oxygen-containing functional groups such as carbonyl groups and C–O groups, and this is unfavorable to the production of CO2 and CO. The pyrolysis weight-loss rate of raw coal decreases with the increase of the heating rate, and the weight-loss curve shifts to the high-temperature region. At the same conversion rate and pyrolysis temperature, the activation energy of pyrolysis under the H2 and CH4 atmospheres is lower than that under the N2 atmosphere, and the activation energy does not conform to the Gaussian distribution. The activation energy of pyrolysis was distributed in a narrow range, in which the activation energy of the H2 and CH4 atmospheres was concentrated in the range of 175–215 kJ/mol and 225–230 kJ/mol, respectively, and the activation energy of the H2 atmosphere was lower than that of the CH4 atmosphere under the same conversion rate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zou2023thermal,
  author = {Chong Zou and Xi Li and Mengmeng Ren and Weian Wang and Hao Wu},
  title = {{Thermal Behavior and Kinetics of Shenmu Coal Pyrolyzed under Hydrogen-Rich or Methane-Gas-Rich Atmosphere}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16052339},
}
Figure