Abstract
Even though the rare-earth tritellurides are tetragonal materials with a quasi-two-dimensional band structure, they have a "hidden" one-dimensional character. The resultant near-perfect nesting of the Fermi surface leads to the formation of a charge density wave (CDW) state. We show that, for this band structure, there are two possible ordered phases: A bidirectional "checkerboard" state would occur if the CDW transition temperature were sufficiently low, whereas a unidirectional "striped" state, consistent with what is observed in experiment, is favored when the transition temperature is higher. This result may also give some insight into why, in more strongly correlated systems, such as the cuprates and nickelates, the observed charge ordered states are generally stripes as opposed to checkerboards.
Introduction
In condensed matter physics, many layered materials exhibit charge density waves (CDWs)—periodic modulations of electron density. A long-standing question is why some materials choose a unidirectional (stripe) order, which breaks the square symmetry of the underlying lattice, while others choose a bidirectional (checkerboard) order that preserves more symmetry. Rare-earth tritellurides ($RTe_3$) are a perfect "laboratory" for this question. They have a nearly square lattice, yet experiments consistently show they form stripes. This paper explains the microscopic driving force behind this symmetry-breaking and determines the conditions under which stripes are favored over checkerboards.
Theoretical Model and the "Hidden" 1D Character
The authors employ a tight-binding model to describe the electronic structure of the Tellurium (Te) planes using $p_x$ and $p_y$ orbitals. Crucially, they account for the high anisotropy of these orbitals—electrons hop much more easily along the length of the orbital ($t_{||}$) than across it ($t_{\perp}$).
Even though the physical lattice is 2D, the electronic "highway" is effectively 1D. Because $p_x$ and $p_y$ orbitals do not hybridize significantly, the system behaves like two perpendicular sets of 1D wires. This "hidden" 1D nature is central to understanding the nesting instabilities of the Fermi surface.
Nesting Vector Competition
The electronic response, or susceptibility, identifies two primary candidates for the CDW wavevector:
- $Q_1$: This vector nests one set of orbitals perfectly but ignores the other. This would lead to a checkerboard phase if both $p_x$ and $p_y$ were to order independently.
- $Q_2$: This vector nests both sets of orbitals moderately well. Because $Q_2$ "consumes" the entire Fermi surface, it prevents the perpendicular direction from ordering, leading to stripes.
Phase Selection and Results
Using Ginzburg-Landau theory and a mean-field free energy expansion, the authors show that the selection between these phases is temperature-dependent. At very low temperatures, the "perfect" nesting of $Q_1$ might win. However, at higher temperatures (or stronger coupling), the "efficiency" of $Q_2$ in gapping the entire Fermi surface makes the stripe phase more stable.
The resulting phase diagram (Figure 4) shows that for realistic coupling strengths, the system transitions directly from a symmetric metallic state to a unidirectional stripe phase. The predicted stripe wavevector $Q_{CDW} \approx (0.71\pi, 0.71\pi)$ matches experimental observations from X-ray scattering and ARPES. Furthermore, the transition is predicted to be second-order (continuous), consistent with recent data.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This theory provides a robust explanation for the observed stripe phases in $RTe_3$ and offers insights into charge ordering in more complex materials like cuprates and nickelates. However, the "hidden 1D" nature implies that 1D fluctuations (Luttinger liquid-like behavior) should be significant, which may require more advanced treatments beyond mean-field theory. Additionally, the authors propose the existence of a "stripe nematic" phase at temperatures above $T_c$, where rotational symmetry is broken while translational symmetry is restored—a prediction that awaits further experimental validation.
Summary updated