Theory of self-resonance after inflation. I. Adiabatic and isocurvature Goldstone modes

Mark P. Hertzberg, Johanna Karouby, William G. Spitzer, Juana C. Becerra, Lanqing LiPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops a theoretical framework for "self-resonance" in the early universe after inflation, focusing on multi-field models with internal symmetries. It reveals that the resulting "Goldstone modes" (adiabatic and isocurvature) can become unstable at long wavelengths, with the instability typically favoring one mode over the other, offering new insights into the dynamics of the post-inflationary universe.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard cosmological model, particularly inflation, successfully explains the large-scale structure of the universe. However, the period immediately following inflation, when the universe transitions from rapid expansion to a hot, dense state (reheating), is less understood. This transition can involve phenomena like "parametric resonance," where quantum fluctuations in the inflaton field itself can grow rapidly, leading to "self-resonance." While self-resonance has been studied, this paper addresses the need for a more general theory, especially for multi-field models and various potential shapes, and aims to understand the conditions under which this resonance is efficient and affects large-scale structures. Specifically, it investigates how the spontaneous breaking of time-translation and internal symmetries during inflation leads to specific modes (adiabatic and isocurvature) and their stability.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of analytical techniques and numerical simulations. They analyze the equations of motion for scalar fields in a multi-field setting, focusing on the linearized perturbations around a background inflaton field. A key technique is the application of Floquet theory, which is used to analyze the stability of systems with periodic coefficients, particularly relevant for the oscillating inflaton background. They introduce the concept of an "auxiliary potential" for isocurvature modes, allowing for a unified treatment with adiabatic modes. This involves time-averaging the background dynamics to define effective "sound speeds" that govern the stability of these modes at long wavelengths. They also explore both radial and circular background field evolutions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Goldstone Modes and Self-Resonance: The spontaneous breaking of time-translation and internal symmetries by the oscillating inflaton background naturally leads to massless (gapless) modes: adiabatic (energy density) and isocurvature (number density). These modes are crucial for understanding self-resonance.
  • Complementary Instabilities: A central finding is that the instability band for self-resonance at long wavelengths typically exists for either the adiabatic or the isocurvature modes, but rarely both simultaneously. This offers a powerful way to distinguish between different cosmological scenarios.
  • Auxiliary Potential for Isocurvature Modes: The introduction of an "auxiliary potential" for isocurvature modes is a novel approach that allows their behavior to be analyzed using similar tools (sound speed, pressure arguments) as adiabatic modes, simplifying the theoretical framework.
  • Sound Speed as a Stability Indicator: The stability of these modes at long wavelengths is directly linked to the sign of their respective "sound speeds," derived from time-averaged pressure and energy density. A negative sound speed indicates an exponentially growing instability.
  • Circular Motion and Q-balls: The analysis extends to circular background field motion, which is relevant for the formation of Q-balls. This regime reveals a "catastrophic instability" under certain conditions, even for homogeneous perturbations.

Key Results

  • Adiabatic Mode Stability: For a positive quartic coupling ($\lambda > 0$) in a simple dimension-4 potential, the adiabatic mode is stable at long wavelengths, characterized by a positive sound speed. For a negative quartic coupling ($\lambda < 0$), the adiabatic mode becomes unstable, exhibiting a large instability band.
  • Isocurvature Mode Stability: The isocurvature modes show the opposite behavior. For $\lambda > 0$, they exhibit a large instability band, while for $\lambda < 0$, they are stable. This complementarity is a key takeaway.
  • Power Law Potentials: For power-law potentials $V(\phi) \propto \phi^q$, instability in the adiabatic mode occurs for $q < 1$, while instability in the isocurvature mode occurs for $q > 1$.
  • Circular Motion Instability: For circular backgrounds, a catastrophic instability is identified when the potential satisfies a specific condition related to its curvature, particularly relevant for Q-ball formation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Long Wavelengths: The analysis primarily focuses on long-wavelength modes, where the Goldstone theorem is most directly applicable. The behavior of shorter wavelengths and their connection to particle production (preheating) is deferred to Part 2 of the series.
  • Idealized Symmetries: The paper assumes an internal rotational symmetry (O(N)) for the potential. Future work could explore the effects of breaking this symmetry, which is crucial for phenomena like baryogenesis.
  • Non-Canonical Kinetic Terms: While Appendix VIII briefly touches upon non-canonical kinetic terms, a full analysis of their impact on self-resonance is not presented.
  • Connection to Quantum Mechanics: The paper lays the groundwork for understanding self-resonance from a more fundamental quantum mechanical perspective, which is the focus of Part 2.
  • Observational Consequences: The authors suggest that these instabilities could lead to enhanced power spectra at early times, potentially leaving imprints on gravitational waves or other astrophysical phenomena, warranting further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a theory of self-resonance after inflation. We study a large class of models involving multiple scalar fields with an internal symmetry. For illustration, we often specialize to dimension-four potentials, but we derive results for general potentials. This is the first part of a two part series of papers. Here in part 1 we especially focus on the behavior of long-wavelength modes, which are found to govern most of the important physics. Since the inflaton background spontaneously breaks the time-translation symmetry and the internal symmetry, we obtain Goldstone modes; these are the adiabatic and isocurvature modes. We find general conditions on the potential for when a large instability band exists for these modes at long wavelengths. For the adiabatic mode, this is determined by a sound speed derived from the time-averaged potential, while for the isocurvature mode, this is determined by a speed derived from a time-averaged auxiliary potential. Interestingly, we find that this instability band usually exists for one of these classes of modes, rather than both simultaneously. We focus on backgrounds that evolve radially in field space, as set up by inflation, and also mention circular orbits, as relevant to $Q$-balls. In part 2 [M. P. Hertzberg et al., Phys. Rev. D 90, 123529 (2014)] we derive the central behavior from the underlying description of many-particle quantum mechanics, and introduce a weak breaking of the symmetry to study corrections to particle-antiparticle production from preheating.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hertzberg2014theory,
  author = {Mark P. Hertzberg and Johanna Karouby and William G. Spitzer and Juana C. Becerra and Lanqing Li},
  title = {{Theory of self-resonance after inflation. I. Adiabatic and isocurvature Goldstone modes}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.90.123528},
}
Figure