Theoretical study of phase stability, crystal and electronic structure of MeMgN2 (Me = Ti, Zr, Hf) compounds

Mohammad Amin Gharavi, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling, Per EklundJournal of Materials Science 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores new potential thermoelectric materials, MeMgN₂ (where Me is Ti, Zr, or Hf), as alternatives to scandium nitride (ScN). Using first-principles calculations, the researchers found these compounds to be stable and exhibit promising semiconducting properties, including large Seebeck coefficients, suggesting their potential for thermoelectric applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Thermoelectric materials are crucial for converting waste heat into electricity, but their widespread adoption is limited by efficiency and cost. Scandium nitride (ScN) shows promise due to its high Seebeck coefficient, but its relatively high thermal conductivity hinders its overall performance. This motivates the search for new materials that retain ScN's desirable electronic properties while possessing lower thermal conductivity, ideally achieved by incorporating heavier elements to scatter phonons more effectively. This study investigates ternary nitrides of the form MeMgN₂ (Me = Ti, Zr, Hf) as potential candidates, aiming to predict their stability and thermoelectric characteristics.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, specifically using the projector augmented-wave (PAW) method and the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional for exchange-correlation effects. They calculated formation enthalpies for a vast number of potential crystal structures to construct phase diagrams and identify thermodynamically stable stoichiometries and structures. For the stable compounds, they computed band structures to determine their electronic behavior (semiconducting or metallic) and band gaps. Furthermore, they utilized Boltzmann transport theory with the constant relaxation time approximation to predict the Seebeck coefficient and power factor at room temperature and 600 K. The software packages VASP, Pymatgen, and BoltzTraP were instrumental in these calculations.

Datasets

The study utilized the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD) and the Materials Project database as sources for known crystal structures and formation enthalpies of binary compounds, respectively. No new datasets were introduced in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ScN as a starting point: The paper builds upon the interest in ScN for thermoelectrics, acknowledging its strengths (high Seebeck coefficient) and weaknesses (high thermal conductivity).
  • Ternary nitrides as a solution: The investigation into MeMgN₂ compounds, where heavier transition metals (Ti, Zr, Hf) replace Sc, is motivated by the potential for enhanced phonon scattering.
  • Two competing crystal structures: For TiMgN₂, ZrMgN₂, and HfMgN₂, the calculations reveal that the stable compounds can crystallize in either a trigonal NaCrS₂ superstructure or a monoclinic LiUN₂ prototype structure.
  • Semiconducting nature confirmed: All three compounds are predicted to be semiconductors, a prerequisite for thermoelectric applications.
  • Tunable band gaps: The NaCrS₂ structure generally leads to indirect band gaps, while the LiUN₂ structure can result in direct band gaps, offering potential for tuning electronic properties.
  • Promising thermoelectric potential: The predicted large Seebeck coefficients and power factors for these compounds suggest they could rival or surpass existing thermoelectric materials like ScN.

Key Results

  • Phase Stability: The phase diagrams indicate that the MeMgN₂ stoichiometry is thermodynamically stable for TiMgN₂, ZrMgN₂, and HfMgN₂.
  • Crystal Structures: TiMgN₂ is predicted to favor the NaCrS₂ structure. ZrMgN₂ and HfMgN₂ show competition between the NaCrS₂ and LiUN₂ structures, with very close formation enthalpies.
  • Band Gaps:
    • TiMgN₂ (NaCrS₂): Indirect band gap of 0.26 eV.
  • ZrMgN₂ (NaCrS₂): Indirect band gap of 0.89 eV.
  • ZrMgN₂ (LiUN₂): Direct band gap of 0.46 eV.
  • HfMgN₂ (NaCrS₂): Indirect band gap of 1.19 eV.
  • HfMgN₂ (LiUN₂): Direct band gap of 0.77 eV.
  • Thermoelectric Properties: All three compounds exhibit large Seebeck coefficients and promising power factors, especially near the Fermi level, suggesting potential for high thermoelectric performance.
  • Trend with Transition Metal: Lattice parameters, cell volume, and band gap generally increase from Ti to Zr, and then slightly decrease from Zr to Hf, consistent with periodic trends and the concept of lanthanide contraction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Relaxation Time Approximation: The calculation of power factors relies on the constant relaxation time approximation, which is a simplification. Experimental determination of the relaxation time is needed for more accurate predictions.
  • Experimental Synthesis: While the calculations predict stability, experimental synthesis of these compounds is still required to validate these findings and explore their practical applications. The authors suggest physical vapor deposition as a potential synthesis route.
  • Metastable Phases: The possibility of TiMgN₂ crystallizing in the LiUN₂ structure as a metastable phase is noted, warranting further investigation.
  • Further Studies: The authors encourage future theoretical and experimental studies to delve deeper into the thermoelectric properties and potential applications of these newly identified compounds. Specifically, understanding the role of the f-orbital electrons in HfMgN₂ and exploring doping strategies for HfMgN₂ are suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Scandium nitride has recently gained interest as a prospective compound for thermoelectric applications due to its high Seebeck coefficient. However, ScN also has a relatively high thermal conductivity, which limits its thermoelectric efficiency and figure of merit (<i>zT</i>). These properties motivate a search for other semiconductor materials that share the electronic structure features of ScN, but which have a lower thermal conductivity. Thus, the focus of our study is to predict the existence and stability of such materials among inherently layered equivalent ternaries that incorporate heavier atoms for enhanced phonon scattering and to calculate their thermoelectric properties. Using density functional theory calculations, the phase stability of TiMgN<sub>2</sub>, ZrMgN<sub>2</sub> and HfMgN<sub>2</sub> compounds has been calculated. From the computationally predicted phase diagrams for these materials, we conclude that all three compounds are stable in these stoichiometries. The stable compounds may have one of two competing crystal structures: a monoclinic structure (LiUN<sub>2</sub> prototype) or a trigonal superstructure (NaCrS<sub>2</sub> prototype; R <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mover><mml:mrow><mml:mn>3</mml:mn></mml:mrow> <mml:mrow><mml:mo>¯</mml:mo></mml:mrow> </mml:mover> </mml:math> mH). The band structure for the two competing structures for each ternary is also calculated and predicts semiconducting behavior for all three compounds in the NaCrS<sub>2</sub> crystal structure with an indirect band gap and semiconducting behavior for ZrMgN<sub>2</sub> and HfMgN<sub>2</sub> in the monoclinic crystal structure with a direct band gap. Seebeck coefficient and power factors are also predicted, showing that all three compounds in both the NaCrS<sub>2</sub> and the LiUN<sub>2</sub> structures have large Seebeck coefficients. The predicted stability of these compounds suggests that they can be synthesized by, e.g., physical vapor deposition.
BibTeX
@article{gharavi2017theoretical,
  author = {Mohammad Amin Gharavi and Rickard Armiento and Björn Alling and Per Eklund},
  title = {{Theoretical study of phase stability, crystal and electronic structure of MeMgN2 (Me = Ti, Zr, Hf) compounds}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Science},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/s10853-017-1849-0},
}
Figure