Theoretical studies on RNA recognition by Musashi 1 RNA-binding protein

Nitchakan Darai, Panupong Mahalapbutr, Peter Wolschann, Vannajan Sanghiran Lee, Michael T. Wolfinger, Thanyada RungrotmongkolScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational modeling to investigate how the Musashi-1 (MSI1) protein recognizes and binds to RNA. By simulating MSI1's RNA-binding domains (RBD1 and RBD2) with various RNA sequences, the researchers identified key interactions and quantified binding affinities, offering a deeper molecular understanding of this crucial RNA-protein interaction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Musashi proteins (MSI1 and MSI2) are vital regulators of gene expression, particularly in stem cell maintenance and proliferation, and have been implicated in various cancers and viral infections like Zika. While it's known that MSI proteins bind to specific RNA sequences, particularly those containing the UAG motif, a detailed molecular understanding of how this specificity arises and the precise binding energetics for different RNA sequences has been lacking. This knowledge gap hinders our ability to fully grasp MSI's role in normal biology and disease, and to develop targeted interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged computational approach:

  • Protein Structure Prediction: They used AlphaFold2, a cutting-edge AI tool, to predict the 3D structures of MSI1's RNA-binding domains (RBD1 and RBD2). These predicted structures were then compared to experimentally determined structures to validate the approach.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Using the AMBER software package, they simulated the dynamic behavior of MSI1 RBD1 and RBD2 in complex with several RNA pentamer motifs (GUAGU, GUUGU, GGAGU, and GAUGU). These simulations allowed them to observe how the protein and RNA interact over time.
  • Binding Free Energy Calculations: The Solvated Interaction Energy (SIE) method was used to quantitatively estimate the binding affinities of the MSI1-RNA complexes. This method approximates the binding free energy by considering various interaction terms, including electrostatic and van der Waals forces, as well as solvation effects.

Datasets

The study utilized existing experimental data for validation and as starting points for simulations:

  • NMR Structures: Experimental NMR structures of MSI1 RBD1 bound to GUAGU (PDB ID: 2RS2) and MSI1 RBD2 bound to GUAGU (PDB ID: 5X3Z) were used as the basis for the simulations.
  • AlphaFold2 Predictions: Predicted structures of MSI1 RBD1 and RBD2 were generated using AlphaFold2.
  • RNA Pentamers: The canonical GUAGU pentamer was studied, along with three alternative pentamers (GUUGU, GGAGU, and GAUGU) chosen based on their varying predicted affinities from previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Similarity: AlphaFold2 successfully predicted structures for MSI1's RNA-binding domains that were highly similar to experimentally determined structures, validating its utility for studying proteins with limited experimental data.
  • Central Role of Trinucleotides: The simulations reinforced the idea that the central trinucleotide sequence (like UAG) is the primary determinant of MSI1 binding affinity, with flanking nucleotides playing a less significant role.
  • Differential Binding Affinities: Not all RNA sequences are created equal when it comes to binding MSI1. The study revealed that certain RNA pentamers exhibit considerably higher binding affinities to MSI1's RBDs than others, highlighting a degree of sequence selectivity.
  • Residue-Specific Interactions: The analysis pinpointed specific amino acid residues within MSI1's RBDs (e.g., phenylalanines, tryptophans, arginines) that are crucial for interacting with different nucleotides in the RNA. These interactions involve a combination of hydrogen bonds, pi-stacking, and electrostatic forces.
  • RBD1 vs. RBD2 Nuances: While both RBDs share high sequence identity and similar binding principles, there are subtle differences in their interaction profiles and overall binding affinities for certain RNA motifs.

Key Results

  • Binding Free Energies: The SIE calculations provided quantitative binding free energy values (AGbind) for the MSI1-RNA complexes. For instance, MSI1-RBD1 showed a binding affinity of -16.77 ±0.66 kcal/mol for GUAGU, and MSI1-RBD2 showed -16.54±0.99 kcal/mol.
  • Sequence Preference: The study identified that GUUGU exhibited the highest binding affinity for MSI1-RBD1, while GUAGU showed the highest affinity for MSI1-RBD2 among the tested pentamers. GAUGU consistently showed weaker binding to both RBDs.
  • Structural Stability: The simulations indicated that the canonical GUAGU pentamer was well-accommodated and showed higher stability within the RBD binding sites compared to some of the alternative motifs.
  • Interaction Mapping: Detailed pharmacophore models and interaction maps illustrated the specific types and percentages of interactions (hydrogen bonds, pi-stacking, electrostatic) between individual residues and nucleotides for each RNA-protein complex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pentameric RNA: The study focused on pentameric RNA motifs. The authors suggest that future work should investigate the binding of longer RNA chains, which might better reflect the complexity of natural MSI targets and potentially involve interactions between both RBDs.
  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: While computational studies provide valuable insights, they are models. Further experimental validation is always crucial to confirm these findings in a biological context.
  • Zika Virus RNA: The paper mentions MSI's role in Zika virus replication and the need for better understanding of MSI-Zika RNA interactions. Future work could specifically focus on modeling MSI's interaction with the full Zika virus RNA genome or its relevant regulatory regions.
  • Inhibiting Replication: The authors highlight the potential for targeting MSI-Zika RNA interactions to inhibit viral replication, suggesting this as a promising avenue for therapeutic development.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Musashi (MSI) family of RNA-binding proteins, comprising the two homologs Musashi-1 (MSI1) and Musashi-2 (MSI2), typically regulates translation and is involved in cell proliferation and tumorigenesis. MSI proteins contain two ribonucleoprotein-like RNA-binding domains, RBD1 and RBD2, that bind single-stranded RNA motifs with a central UAG trinucleotide with high affinity and specificity. The finding that MSI also promotes the replication of Zika virus, a neurotropic Flavivirus, has triggered further investigations of the biochemical principles behind MSI-RNA interactions. However, a detailed molecular understanding of the specificity of MSI RBD1/2 interaction with RNA is still missing. Here, we performed computational studies of MSI1-RNA association complexes, investigating different RNA pentamer motifs using molecular dynamics simulations with binding free energy calculations based on the solvated interaction energy method. Simulations with Alphafold2 suggest that predicted MSI protein structures are highly similar to experimentally determined structures. The binding free energies show that two out of four RNA pentamers exhibit a considerably higher binding affinity to MSI1 RBD1 and RBD2, respectively. The obtained structural information on MSI1 RBD1 and RBD2 will be useful for a detailed functional and mechanistic understanding of this type of RNA-protein interactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{darai2022theoretical,
  author = {Nitchakan Darai and Panupong Mahalapbutr and Peter Wolschann and Vannajan Sanghiran Lee and Michael T. Wolfinger and Thanyada Rungrotmongkol},
  title = {{Theoretical studies on RNA recognition by Musashi 1 RNA-binding protein}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-16252-w},
}
Figure