Theoretical perspective on synthetic man-made life: Learning from the origin of life

Lu Peng, Zecheng Zhang, Xianyi Wang, Weiyi Qiu, Liqian Zhou, Hui Xiao, Chunxiuzi Liu, Shaohua Tang, Zhiwei Qin, Jiakun Jiang, Zengru Di, Yu LiuQuant. Biol 2023 · DOI

This paper explores the creation of synthetic life, proposing a "bottom-up from the origin of life" approach that mimics natural abiogenesis. It argues that by understanding and replicating the fundamental processes that led to life's emergence on Earth, we can better engineer artificial life forms.

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel approach to creating synthetic life by learning from the origin of life on Earth, focusing on building autocatalytic networks and physical compartments. It argues that this "bottom-up from the origin" strategy, distinct from current top-down or component-integration methods, offers a more fundamental path to understanding and engineering life.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The creation of synthetic life, or "man-made life," is a grand challenge in life sciences. Current approaches largely fall into two categories: the "top-down" method, which simplifies existing life forms, and the "bottom-up" method, which integrates pre-defined components. While these have yielded progress, they often presuppose existing life or its components. This paper addresses the gap by suggesting that a more fundamental understanding and creation of life can be achieved by emulating the natural processes that led to life's emergence from non-living matter. This involves understanding the theoretical underpinnings of abiogenesis and applying them to synthetic biology.

Methods

The paper reviews two primary approaches to synthetic life:

  • Top-down: Reducing the complexity of existing living systems to identify minimal life requirements. This includes efforts like synthesizing minimal genomes (e.g., JCVI-syn3.0) and altering existing complex organisms (e.g., single-chromosome yeast).
  • Bottom-up: Integrating well-defined components to build life. This involves understanding and assembling key properties of life such as metabolism, information/genetics, and compartmentalization.

The paper then proposes a third, novel approach: "Bottom-up from the origin of life." This strategy involves:

  1. Starting with the establishment of autocatalytic chemical reaction networks.
  2. Utilizing physical boundaries as initial compartments.
  3. Designing directed evolutionary systems. The ultimate goal is the emergence of independent compartments that lead to free-living systems, mirroring the natural origin of life. This approach leverages theories from origin-of-life research, such as autocatalytic sets and the "ladderpath theory" for complexity increase.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mimicking Abiogenesis is Key: The paper strongly advocates for learning from the origin of life as a guiding principle for creating synthetic life, suggesting that natural processes offer a robust blueprint.
  • Autocatalytic Sets as a Foundation: The concept of autocatalytic sets, where reaction products catalyze further reactions, is presented as a fundamental building block for self-replication and metabolism, a crucial step towards life.
  • Compartmentalization is Crucial, but Can Emerge: While compartments are essential for individuality, the paper suggests they don't need to be the starting point. They can emerge through evolution within autocatalytic systems, particularly in environments like alkaline hydrothermal vents.
  • Complexity Naturally Increases: The "ladderpath theory" provides a framework for understanding how systems can evolve from simple to complex, driven by the ability to generate new building blocks and replicate them. This offers theoretical support for the gradual emergence of life-like properties.
  • Bridging the Gap: The paper highlights a historical disconnect between origin-of-life research and synthetic biology, aiming to bridge this gap by applying theoretical models from the former to the latter.

Key Results

The paper is primarily theoretical and conceptual, outlining a research program rather than presenting experimental results. Its key "results" are the theoretical frameworks and arguments it puts forth:

  • Critique of Existing Approaches: It identifies limitations in current top-down and bottom-up synthetic biology methods, particularly their reliance on pre-existing life or components.
  • Proposal of a New Paradigm: It champions the "bottom-up from the origin of life" approach as a more fundamental and promising avenue.
  • Theoretical Support for the New Paradigm: It draws upon established theories like autocatalytic sets and the ladderpath theory to provide a conceptual foundation for how life-like properties (metabolism, compartment, information) could emerge.
  • Identification of Key Challenges: It pinpoints crucial challenges for this approach, such as defining individuality and achieving evolution, and suggests potential solutions rooted in origin-of-life research.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the proposed "bottom-up from the origin of life" approach is currently more theoretical than experimental. While some studies offer insights, there is limited direct experimental research following this specific idea.

Future work should focus on:

  • Experimental Validation: Designing and conducting experiments to build autocatalytic reaction networks with physical boundaries and observe the emergence of independent compartments and free-living systems.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: Applying quantitative models and tools from origin-of-life research to practical synthetic biology challenges.
  • Understanding Information Emergence: Further investigating how "information" (in both broad and narrow senses) emerges from non-living matter, a critical step towards creating truly synthetic life.
  • Facilitating Interdisciplinary Communication: Promoting dialogue between synthetic biologists, origin-of-life researchers, and theoretical physicists to accelerate progress.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{peng2023theoretical,
  author = {Lu Peng and Zecheng Zhang and Xianyi Wang and Weiyi Qiu and Liqian Zhou and Hui Xiao and Chunxiuzi Liu and Shaohua Tang and Zhiwei Qin and Jiakun Jiang and Zengru Di and Yu Liu},
  title = {{Theoretical perspective on synthetic man-made life: Learning from the origin of life}},
  journal = {Quant. Biol.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/qub2.22},
}
Figure