Theoretical Investigations on Shadow Band Correction Factors for Diffuse Radiation under Isotropic Conditions without Approximation

Haiying Cheng, Xuan Zhang, Ziqian Chen, Wenhong Sun, Kaiyan He, Hongfei Zheng, Yanxiu TangEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a new, more accurate theoretical framework for calculating shadow band correction factors for diffuse solar radiation measurements. By employing coordinate transformations without approximations, the authors provide a method that overcomes limitations of previous models, particularly in challenging conditions like high latitudes or when the sun's position makes older formulas unusable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately measuring solar irradiance is crucial for evaluating the performance of solar energy systems. Diffuse solar radiation, a key component of total irradiance, is often measured using a pyranometer equipped with a shadow band to block direct sunlight. However, calculating the correction factor needed to account for the portion of diffuse radiation blocked by the band has historically relied on approximate formulas (Drummond and Burek et al.). These approximations break down under certain conditions, such as specific combinations of latitude, sensor tilt, and solar declination, or when the shadow band geometry is not ideal. This limits the accuracy and applicability of diffuse radiation measurements in various scenarios.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of new, non-approximate expressions for shadow band correction factors. The authors achieve this by:

  • Coordinate Transformations: They meticulously transform the problem from a geometric perspective using spherical coordinates into different coordinate systems (horizon and equatorial). This allows for a more rigorous mathematical treatment.
  • Eliminating Assumptions: Unlike previous methods that made simplifying assumptions about the geometry of the shaded area (e.g., treating it as cylindrical) or the incident angle, the authors' approach avoids these.
  • Comprehensive Analysis: The paper systematically derives and discusses the correction factors in both horizon and equatorial coordinate systems, demonstrating that the results are consistent across both. They then explore various geometric configurations of the shadow band and sensor to cover all possible scenarios.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and comparisons with existing theoretical models and experimental data presented in cited works.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Approximations Matter: The study highlights how seemingly small approximations in geometric models can lead to significant discrepancies in correction factors, especially under non-ideal conditions.
  • Universality of New Method: The derived expressions are shown to be valid for all geometric configurations and solar positions, unlike older methods that have specific limitations.
  • Coordinate Systems are Equivalent: The theoretical work confirms that using either horizon or equatorial coordinate systems yields identical, precise correction factors, reinforcing the robustness of the approach.
  • Impact of Shadow Band Geometry: The paper implicitly shows that the ratio of the shadow band's width to its radius significantly influences the accuracy of older correction methods, with larger ratios leading to greater deviations.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy: For a horizontally placed sensor, the authors' method shows a maximum relative deviation of less than 2.3% compared to Drummond's expression.
  • Significant Improvement for Sloped Surfaces: When the sensor is on a sloped surface, the authors' results show considerable differences (up to 22% maximum relative deviation) compared to Burek's expression, indicating a substantial improvement in accuracy.
  • Overcoming Limitations: The new expressions can calculate correction factors in situations where Drummond's and Burek's methods fail, particularly when the sunrise solar hour angle cannot be determined.
  • Validation: The theoretical results are shown to be in good agreement with experimental data from Burek's paper and indirectly validated against Drummond's work.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Isotropic Assumption: The current work focuses on isotropic diffuse radiation conditions. The authors suggest that their theoretical framework could be extended to develop expressions for anisotropic conditions, which would be a valuable next step.
  • Computational Complexity: While more accurate, the derived expressions are mathematically complex. The paper implies that while Drummond's method might be simpler for specific, less demanding scenarios (e.g., small band-to-radius ratios, horizontal sensors), the authors' method is essential for higher accuracy and broader applicability.
  • Missing Data Points: The paper notes that in some figures, data points are missing for certain conditions (e.g., polar nights, specific latitude/day combinations where older formulas fail). This is a consequence of the limitations of the compared methods rather than the authors' new method.

Summary updated

Abstract

The precise measurement for irradiance is important for the performance evaluations of solar systems, because both beam and diffuse radiation measurements must be known to calculate the efficiency of a solar system. One of the widely used instruments for diffuse radiation measurement is a pyranometer with a ring. Hence, investigations on shadow band correction factors are necessary. The factors are normally calculated by the expressions of Drummond and Burek et al. under isotropic conditions. However, their calculation results are approximate. While the latitude φ, the inclination angle β and the declination δ are satisfied with the condition of |−tan(φ−β)tanδ|>1, the factors cannot be calculated by their expressions. In this paper, the expressions for the factors under isotropic conditions were obtained by coordinate transformations and discussed in two different coordinate systems without approximation. Our expressions can give precise correction factors in any case and overcome the disadvantages of their expressions. While the sensor is placed horizontally, the maximum relative deviation between the results by the expression in Drummond’s paper and by our expressions is less than 2.3%. When the sensor is placed on a sloped surface, the results by the expressions in Burek’s paper and by our expressions will have considerable differences in some ranges of slope angles and latitudes. The maximum relative deviation is more than 22%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2022theoretical,
  author = {Haiying Cheng and Xuan Zhang and Ziqian Chen and Wenhong Sun and Kaiyan He and Hongfei Zheng and Yanxiu Tang},
  title = {{Theoretical Investigations on Shadow Band Correction Factors for Diffuse Radiation under Isotropic Conditions without Approximation}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15197174},
}
Figure