Theoretical Insight on Anion Ordering, Strain, and Doping Engineering of the Oxygen Evolution Reaction in BaTaO2N

Zhenyun Lan, Tejs Vegge, Ivano E. CastelliChemistry 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational methods to explore how to improve the efficiency of BaTaO2N, a promising material for solar-driven water splitting. By applying strain and doping, researchers found that a small amount of tensile strain can significantly reduce the energy required for the oxygen evolution reaction, bringing it closer to the theoretical minimum.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solar-to-chemical conversion, particularly water splitting to produce hydrogen and oxygen, holds immense potential for sustainable energy. Oxynitride perovskites, like BaTaO2N, are attractive candidates due to their favorable electronic and optical properties. However, a major hurdle is the high energy cost (overpotential) required for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER), which limits their practical application. This paper aims to identify strategies to lower this OER overpotential in BaTaO2N by investigating the effects of surface structure, strain, and doping.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to investigate the OER mechanism on different surfaces of BaTaO2N. Specifically, they used the projector augmented wave (PAW) potentials within the VASP package and the Perdew-Burke-Ernserhof (PBE) functional for surface calculations. To determine the most stable surface terminations, they calculated surface energies. For the OER mechanism, they adopted a widely used four-proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) model. The theoretical overpotential (η) was calculated based on the Gibbs free energy changes of each step in the OER process. They also explored the impact of uniaxial strain (both compressive and tensile) and cationic doping (with Ca and Sr) on the OER performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on computational simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface structure matters: Different facets and terminations of BaTaO2N exhibit distinct OER performance. The Ta-exposed surfaces (TaO2N on (100) and TaON on (001)) were found to be the most stable and were therefore the focus of catalytic property investigations.
  • Strain is a powerful tuning knob: Applying even small amounts of tensile strain can significantly reduce the OER overpotential. Specifically, 1% tensile strain on the TaO2N-(100) surface brought the overpotential down to a near-ideal value.
  • Anion ordering influences reactivity: The different arrangements of oxygen and nitrogen atoms on the surface (anion ordering) play a crucial role in how reaction intermediates adsorb and how easily they can be transformed, directly impacting the OER overpotential.
  • Doping offers complementary benefits: While doping alone had a modest effect, combining it with strain showed promise in further reducing the overpotential, suggesting a synergistic approach.

Key Results

  • The clean TaO2N-(100) surface had a theoretical OER overpotential of 1.64 V, while the clean TaON-(001) surface was lower at 0.97 V.
  • Under realistic (photo)electrochemical conditions, the TaO2N-(100) surface with 1% tensile uniaxial strain in the [001] direction achieved a significantly reduced theoretical overpotential of 0.37 V. This is close to the theoretical minimum.
  • For the TaON-(001) surface, 4% compressive uniaxial strain in the [010] direction lowered the overpotential to 0.59 V under operational conditions.
  • The study highlights that the TaO2N-(100) facet, with appropriate strain engineering, offers a more promising pathway to achieving low OER overpotentials compared to the TaON-(001) facet.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Kinetic overpotential: The study focuses on the thermodynamic overpotential. Kinetic factors, which also influence reaction rates, are not directly addressed.
  • Experimental validation: While the strain values explored are experimentally accessible, the findings are based on theoretical calculations and require experimental verification.
  • Doping optimization: The study explored Ca and Sr doping, but a more comprehensive investigation into other dopants and their optimal concentrations could be beneficial.
  • Combined effects: While the paper suggests combining strain and doping, further detailed studies on the synergistic effects of various dopants and strain levels across different facets would be valuable.
  • Nitrogen evolution: The paper briefly mentions nitrogen evolution as a potential competing reaction but notes it is kinetically hindered compared to OER. Further investigation into this could be relevant for understanding overall material stability and performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Oxynitride perovskites such as BaTaO2N are among the most promising materials to achieve efficient direct solar-to-chemical conversion. Albeit photoelectrochemical water splitting has been demonstrated, the required overpotentials remain prohibitively large compared with the theoretically accessible values, particularly for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Here, we apply density functional theory (DFT) calculations to investigate the use of strain and cationic doping with Ca and Sr to optimize the OER theoretical overpotential. For the TaON-terminated BaTaO2N (001) surface, 4% compressive uniaxial strain can lower the theoretical overpotential to η = 0.59 V, under operational conditions. For the most stable TaO2N-(100) termination, 1% tensile uniaxial strain, which is perfectly accessible by experiments, is enough to reduce the theoretical overpotential from η = 0.43 V to η = 0.37 V under (photo)electrochemical conditions. This value is close to the minimum predicted theoretical overpotential and points out how strain engineering could be efficiently used to improve the electrocatalytic reactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lan2021theoretical,
  author = {Zhenyun Lan and Tejs Vegge and Ivano E. Castelli},
  title = {{Theoretical Insight on Anion Ordering, Strain, and Doping Engineering of the Oxygen Evolution Reaction in BaTaO<sub>2</sub>N}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.chemmater.1c00370},
}
Figure