The World’s First Experimental Simulation Technology and System of Solid Fluidization Exploitation of Marine Non-diagenetic Natural Gas Hydrate

Jinzhou Zhao, Na Wei, Haitao Li, Shouwei Zhou, Anqi Liu, Ping Guo, Kaisong Wu, Jun Zhao, Guorong Wang, Ning Wang2020 · DOI

This paper presents a paradigm shift in how we might extract "combustible ice"—natural gas hydrates—from the ocean floor. By moving away from traditional methods that risk environmental catastrophe, the authors introduce a "solid fluidization" approach and the massive experimental system used to prove its viability.

TL;DR

Researchers have developed and validated the world’s first "solid fluidization" system for extracting marine natural gas hydrates from unstable, non-diagenetic sediments. This method avoids the risks of seabed collapse and uncontrolled gas leakage by crushing solid hydrate into a slurry and transporting it through a closed pipeline for controlled decomposition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Natural gas hydrates (NGH) represent a massive unconventional energy reserve, but they are notoriously difficult to extract safely. Most marine hydrates are "non-diagenetic," meaning they are weakly cemented and lack a solid rock skeleton.

The industry standard extraction method, depressurization, works by lowering the pressure in the reservoir to trigger decomposition in situ. However, in non-diagenetic sediments, this causes the ground to lose its structural integrity. This leads to six major risks: well plugging from sand, massive gas leakage into the ocean and atmosphere (greenhouse effect), seabed landslides, and the potential destruction of drilling equipment. The authors sought a way to make this "uncontrollable" process "controllable."

Methods

The core innovation is the Solid Fluidization Exploitation method. Instead of letting the hydrate decompose in the ground, the team proposes:

  1. In-situ Crushing: Mechanically breaking the solid hydrate and surrounding sediment.
  2. Slurry Modulation: Mixing the fragments with seawater to create a pumpable slurry.
  3. Closed Transportation: Pumping the slurry up a closed pipeline.
  4. Controlled Decomposition: As the slurry rises, the natural decrease in pressure and increase in temperature causes the hydrate to decompose into gas and water inside the pipe, where it can be safely captured on a surface platform.

To test this, they built a massive Large-scale Physical Simulation Experimental System. This rig simulates a 1500m water depth and a 4500m pipeline. It features three main modules and 12 subsystems, including a reactor capable of preparing 1062-liter hydrate samples (the world's largest) in under 20 hours.

Datasets

The study does not use pre-existing datasets; instead, it generates a comprehensive experimental database to validate their multiphase flow models. This includes:

  • Physical Property Data: Variations in resistivity and acoustic velocity relative to hydrate saturation, particle size, and shale content.
  • Mechanical Data: Regularity of weight loss, torque, and crushing efficiency for rotating cutter heads.
  • Flow Dynamics: Experimental measurements of gas-liquid-solid multiphase flow (velocity, pressure, and gas holdup) across simulated vertical and horizontal pipelines.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Letting Nature Take Its Course": The strategy utilizes the environment rather than fighting it. It uses the natural temperature/pressure gradient of the ocean to drive decomposition during ascent and uses the specific gravity difference between hydrate and sediment for initial separation.
  • The Carrying Effect: One of the most interesting findings is that once decomposition begins in the pipe, the rising gas phase actually helps "lift" the remaining solid particles, reducing the critical displacement required for transport.
  • Controllability: By moving the phase change from the reservoir to a sealed pipe, the researchers transformed a geological hazard into a manageable engineering process.
  • Scale Matters: The authors emphasize that small-scale lab tests cannot capture the complex multiphase flow dynamics of a 4.5km pipeline, necessitating their large-scale physical simulator.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The team’s mathematical models for wellbore temperature and pressure showed high accuracy when compared to experimental results (errors as low as 0.34% for temperature and 2.86% for gas holdup).
  • Optimized Parameters: They determined that a high-pressure jet crushing displacement of 500 L/min and a jet cavity diameter of no more than 0.5m are optimal for safe rock carrying.
  • Field Success: The technology was successfully deployed in the Shenhu area of the South China Sea in May 2017 using the "Offshore Oil 708" ship. This marked the world's first successful field test of the solid fluidization method.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper proves the "scientific feasibility" of the method, several hurdles remain for commercialization:

  • Economic Viability: The energy cost of mechanical crushing and slurry lifting versus the volume of gas recovered needs further optimization.
  • Long-term Stability: The field test was a short-term "test exploitation." Future work must address the long-term wear and tear on crushing tools and pipelines in a corrosive marine environment.
  • System Upgrading: The authors note that further upgrading of the simulation system is required to promote the technology toward full-scale commercial development.

Summary updated

Abstract

technology leading the world's frontiers, and are expected to accelerate the commercial development of natural gas hydrate in China and even the whole world.
BibTeX
@misc{zhao2020worlds,
  author = {Jinzhou Zhao and Na Wei and Haitao Li and Shouwei Zhou and Anqi Liu and Ping Guo and Kaisong Wu and Jun Zhao and Guorong Wang and Ning Wang},
  title = {{The World’s First Experimental Simulation Technology and System of Solid Fluidization Exploitation of Marine Non-diagenetic Natural Gas Hydrate}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.46855/energy-proceedings-583},
}
Figure