The Willmore functional and instabilities in the Cahn-Hilliard equation

Martin Burger, Shun‐Yin Chu, Peter A. Markowich, Carola‐Bibiane SchönliebCommunications 2008 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates the finite-time stability of transition solutions in the Cahn-Hilliard (CH) equation through the lens of the Willmore functional. While the standard Ginzburg-Landau energy of the CH system is strictly non-increasing, the authors demonstrate that the Willmore functional—a measure of surface curvature energy—serves as a sensitive indicator of local instabilities. Through linear stability analysis and numerical simulations in one and two dimensions, the study shows that the Willmore functional increases during transient instabilities and decreases during stable phases. Furthermore, the authors prove the asymptotic decay of the Willmore functional in arbitrary dimensions, establishing global convergence to a stationary state without the need for the complex Lojasiewicz inequality.

Introduction

The Cahn-Hilliard equation is a fundamental model for phase separation in binary mixtures, such as oil and water or metal alloys. It describes how a concentration field $u$ evolves to form distinct domains separated by narrow transition layers. These layers, often referred to as "transition solutions," manifest as kinks in 1D or bubbles/droplets in higher dimensions.

A significant challenge in studying CH dynamics is that the standard Ginzburg-Landau energy functional used to derive the equation is monotonic; it always decreases over time. While this confirms the system is moving toward a global minimum, it fails to capture "superslow" local dynamics or transient moments where a boundary might temporarily wiggle or grow before settling. This paper proposes the Willmore functional as a diagnostic tool to fill this gap.

The Willmore Functional as a Stability Sensor

The Willmore functional $W[u]$ integrates the square of the mean curvature along the interface of the phase transition. The authors establish a rigorous theoretical link between this functional and the stability of the CH equation. By linearizing both the CH equation and the Willmore functional around a stationary solution, they prove that the sign of the Willmore functional’s time derivative matches the stability of the system's eigenvalues:

$$\frac{d}{dt}W[v](t) \ge 0 \iff \lambda > 0$$

In other words, if the Willmore functional is increasing, the system is experiencing a local linear instability. If it is decreasing, the transition is stable. This allows $W[u]$ to act as a "surveilling quantity" for the geometric health of the phase boundary.

Numerical Evidence of Transient Instability

To validate their theoretical findings, the authors performed numerical simulations using a semi-implicit finite element method. This method splits the potential into convex and concave parts to maintain stability while handling the fourth-order derivatives of the CH equation.

1D Kink Dynamics

In one-dimensional simulations, the authors applied sinusoidal perturbations to "kink" solutions. They discovered that the length of the perturbation's support is a critical factor for stability. Small supports were found to be stable, with the Willmore functional decreasing immediately. However, larger supports triggered a transient spike in the Willmore functional—a clear signal of finite-time instability—before the global energy minimization eventually forced the system back toward decay.

2D Bubble Dynamics

Similar behavior was observed in two dimensions with "bubble" solutions. When a circular phase boundary was subjected to sinusoidal perturbations, the Willmore functional increased temporarily. This increase corresponds to the boundary "incipiently tending away" from its equilibrium circular shape before eventually recovering. These results confirm that even systems destined for stable equilibrium can undergo significant transient fluctuations.

Global Convergence and the Balancing Functional

A major technical contribution of the paper is the proof of global convergence. Traditionally, proving that solutions of the CH equation reach a stationary state in $H^{-1}$ spaces requires the Lojasiewicz inequality, which is mathematically cumbersome.

The authors bypassed this complexity by introducing a "balancing functional" technique. They successfully proved that for any dimension $d \ge 1$, the Willmore functional asymptotically decays to zero. This confirms that the system will always reach a stationary state, providing a more accessible proof of convergence for the mathematical community.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study establishes the Willmore functional as a powerful monitor for the complex dynamics of the Cahn-Hilliard equation. Beyond theoretical interest, this has practical implications for fields like image processing. In "image inpainting," where the CH equation is used to fill missing data, the Willmore functional could serve as a real-time indicator of when an algorithm has reached a high-quality steady state.

Future research will focus on determining the specific asymptotic decay rates of the functional in arbitrary dimensions and extending numerical observations to 3D droplet instabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we are interested in the finite-time stability of transition solutions of the Cahn-Hilliard equation and its connection to the Willmore functional. We show that the Willmore functional locally decreases or increases in time in the linearly stable or unstable case respectively. This linear analysis explains the behavior near stationary solutions of the Cahn-Hilliard equation. We perform numerical examples in one and two dimensions and show that in the neighbourhood of transition solutions local instabilities occur in finite time. We also show convergence of solutions of the Cahn-Hilliard equation for arbitrary dimension to a stationary state by proving asymptotic decay of the Willmore functional in time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{burger2008willmore,
  author = {Martin Burger and Shun‐Yin Chu and Peter A. Markowich and Carola‐Bibiane Schönlieb},
  title = {{The Willmore functional and instabilities in the Cahn-Hilliard equation}},
  booktitle = {Communications},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.4310/cms.2008.v6.n2.a3},
}

Loading related content...

Figure