The Vulcan salute sign: a non-sensitive but specific sign for Morton’s neuroma on radiographs

Julien Galley, Reto Sutter, Christoph Germann, Christian W. A. PfirrmannSkeletal 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the "Vulcan salute sign" (interphalangeal toe divergence) on standard foot X-rays as a diagnostic marker for Morton's neuroma. While not a sensitive indicator, the sign proved highly specific, meaning its presence strongly suggests Morton's neuroma, though its absence doesn't rule it out. This offers a potentially useful, readily available radiographic clue for this common cause of forefoot pain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Morton's neuroma, a painful condition of the forefoot caused by nerve compression, is a common complaint. While MRI and ultrasound are considered the gold standard for diagnosis, conventional radiography is often the first imaging modality used due to its accessibility and lower cost. However, radiographs have traditionally been seen as having limited value for directly diagnosing Morton's neuroma, primarily serving to rule out other issues like fractures. This paper explores whether a specific visual cue on standard weight-bearing foot X-rays, the "Vulcan salute sign" (or V-sign), which describes the divergence of toes, can be a reliable indicator of Morton's neuroma, especially given the known mass effect of the neuroma.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective case-control study involving 100 patients diagnosed with Morton's neuroma via MRI (study group) and 100 patients without the condition (control group). Both groups underwent conventional weight-bearing dorso-plantar view radiographs of the foot. Two blinded musculoskeletal radiologists independently assessed these radiographs for the subjective presence of the "Vulcan salute sign" (V-sign) in the 2/3 and 3/4 interdigital spaces. They also measured interphalangeal angles (2/3 and 3/4) and the intermetatarsal angle I/V. Statistical analysis included t-tests and chi-squared tests to compare groups, with diagnostic performance metrics (sensitivity, specificity) calculated. Interobserver reliability for the V-sign was assessed using kappa statistics, and for angle measurements using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC).

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective data from 200 patients who had undergone both conventional radiography and MRI of the forefoot for clinical indications. The study group consisted of patients with MRI-proven Morton's neuroma (specifically in the 2/3 or 3/4 interspace), while the control group comprised patients without Morton's neuroma confirmed by MRI. No new datasets were created or introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Vulcan Salute" as a Radiographic Clue: The study validates the concept that the visual divergence of toes on a standard X-ray, termed the "Vulcan salute sign," can be associated with Morton's neuroma.
  • Specificity Over Sensitivity: The most striking finding is the high specificity of the V-sign. This means that when the V-sign is present on an X-ray, it's a very strong indicator that Morton's neuroma is likely present in that interspace.
  • Limited Role in Exclusion: Conversely, the V-sign has low sensitivity. This implies that a significant number of patients with Morton's neuroma will not show this sign on their X-rays. Therefore, a normal-looking X-ray (without the V-sign) cannot be used to definitively rule out the diagnosis.
  • Interphalangeal Angle Correlation: The study found that interphalangeal angles were significantly different between the groups, with larger angles in patients with Morton's neuroma, further supporting the visual observation of divergence.
  • Intermetatarsal Angle Irrelevance: Interestingly, the intermetatarsal angle I/V did not show a significant difference between the groups, suggesting that the overall width of the forefoot is not the primary driver of this specific toe divergence.
  • Reliable Reader Agreement: The study demonstrated good interobserver agreement for the V-sign (kappa = 0.78) and excellent agreement for angle measurements, indicating that the sign and measurements are reliably reproducible by different radiologists.

Key Results

  • V-sign Presence: The V-sign was found in 30% of patients with Morton's neuroma and only 3% of control patients.
  • Sensitivity: The overall sensitivity of the V-sign for diagnosing Morton's neuroma was approximately 30-33%.
  • Specificity: The specificity of the V-sign was very high, around 96-98%.
  • Interphalangeal Angles: Mean interphalangeal angles were significantly larger in the Morton's neuroma group compared to the control group (e.g., 2/3 angle: 7.9° vs. 5.4°).
  • Interobserver Agreement: Kappa for V-sign was 0.78 (substantial agreement), and ICC for angle measurements was ≥0.94 (excellent agreement).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a key limitation: all patients included in the study had already undergone MRI for clinical indications. This means the study population might not perfectly represent a general population presenting with forefoot pain, potentially leading to a selection bias. Future work could explore the utility of the V-sign in a broader, unselected patient population and investigate its correlation with symptom severity and neuroma size. The authors also suggest that while conventional radiography can be useful, it should be considered alongside clinical presentation, and MRI or ultrasound remain the best imaging methods for definitive evaluation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Vulcan salute sign on conventional radiographs is specific for Morton's neuroma.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{galley2021vulcan,
  author = {Julien Galley and Reto Sutter and Christoph Germann and Christian W. A. Pfirrmann},
  title = {{The Vulcan salute sign: a non-sensitive but specific sign for Morton’s neuroma on radiographs}},
  booktitle = {Skeletal},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s00256-021-03851-3},
}
Figure