The Vascular Impairment of Cognition Classification Consensus Study
Olivia Anna Skrobot, John T. O’Brien, Sandra E. Black, Christopher Chen, Charles DeCarli, Timo Erkinjuntti, Gary A. Ford, Raj N. Kalaria, Leonardo Pantoni, Florence Pasquier, Gustavo C. Román, Anders Wallin, Perminder S. Sachdev, Ingmar Skoog, Fernando Taragano, Jillian J. Kril, Margherita Cavalieri, K. A. Jellinger, Gábor G. Kovács, S. Engelborghs, C. Lafosse, Paulo Henrique Ferreira Bertolucci, Sônia Maria Dozzi Brucki, Paulo Caramelli, Tania C. T. Ferraz Alves, Christian Bocti, Tamàs Fülöp, David B. Hogan, Ging‐Yuek Robin Hsiung, Andrew Kirk, Lopa Leach, A. Robillard, Demetrios J. Sahlas, Qihao Guo, Jiang Tian, Laura Hokkanen, Hanna Jokinen, Sarah Benisty, Vincent Deramecourt, Jean‐Jacques Hauw, H. Lenoir, Marianna Tsatali, Magda Tsolaki, Uma Sundar, Robert F. Coen, Amos D. Korczyn, M. Altieri, Marzia Baldereschi, C. Caltagirone, G. Caravaglios, Antonio Di Carlo, Vittorio Di Piero, Guido Gainotti, Samantha Galluzzi, Giancarlo Logroscino, Patrizia Mecocci, Davide Vito Moretti, Alessandro Padovani, Toshiya Fukui, Masafumi Ihara, Toshiki Mizuno, Sooyoung Kim, Rufus Akinyemi, Olusegun Baiyewu, Adesola Ogunniyi, A. Szczudlik, António J. Bastos‐Leite, Horácio Firmino, João Massano, Ana Verdelho, L. S. Kruglov, M. Kamran Ikram, Nagaendran Kandiah, Estanislao Arana, José Barroso, T Calatayud, Alfonso J. Cruz‐Jentoft, Secundino López‐Pousa, Pablo Martínez‐Lage, María Mataró, Anne Börjesson‐Hanson, Elisabet Englund, Erika J. Laukka, Cheng-Wei Qiu, Matti Viitanen, Geert Jan Biessels, F.‐e. de Leeuw, Tom den Heijer, Lieza G. Exalto, L. Jaap Kappelle, Niels D. Prins, Edo Richard, Ben Schmand, Esther van den Berg, Wiesje M. van der Flier, Başar Bılgıç, Louise Allan, Judy Archer, Johannes Attems, Antony BayerAlzheimer2016 · DOI
Abstract: VICCCS proposes a consensus-based updated conceptualization of VCI intended to facilitate standardization in research.
Introduction: The Challenge of Standardization
For decades, the field of vascular-related cognitive decline has been hindered by a "Tower of Babel" problem. Researchers and clinicians frequently employed overlapping and sometimes contradictory terms—such as "vascular dementia," "multi-infarct dementia," and "subcortical dementia"—without a unified set of diagnostic criteria. This lack of standardization made it nearly impossible to compare results across different clinical trials or epidemiological studies. Furthermore, existing models often failed to account for the transition from mild impairment to severe dementia or the frequent overlap between vascular issues and neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s. The Vascular Impairment of Cognition Classification Consensus Study (VICCCS) was launched to bridge these conceptual gaps and establish a standardized framework for Vascular Cognitive Impairment (VCI).
Methodology
The study utilized a formal consensus-building process among international experts (the VICCCS participants). This structured multi-round survey approach, similar to a Delphi method, required participants to evaluate and vote on four primary areas:
Guiding Principles: The foundational logic for VCI classification.
Causative Mechanisms: Identifying biological processes to be formally recognized.
Nomenclature: Standardizing abbreviations and names for specific conditions.
Definitions: Crafting precise clinical descriptions for subtypes of "Major VCI."
A threshold of 67% agreement was established for any recommendation to be considered "consensus-supported."
Key Results and Recognized Mechanisms
The study successfully codified several high-consensus elements regarding the biological underpinnings of VCI. Notably, cerebral amyloid angiopathy, white matter hyperintensities, and mixed neurodegenerative forms (such as DLB with CVD) all received 93% support as recognized causes of VCI.
Consensus support for various mechanisms of cause in VCI.
Other mechanisms, such as microbleeds and microinfarcts, also saw strong support (89%), while more niche causes like chronic migraine received minimal consensus (9%).
Key Conceptual Shifts and Nomenclature
A primary goal of VICCCS was to refine the "O’Brien concept"—a previously established framework for VCI—into a more modern, clinically applicable system.
Comparison of VICCCS subtypes and descriptive terms with the O'Brien concept classification.
The study recommends "Major VCI" as the overarching term to replace "Vascular Dementia" (VaD), acknowledging that cognitive impairment exists on a spectrum of severity. Within this umbrella, four major subtypes were defined:
Post-stroke dementia (PSD): Specifically defined by a 6-month temporal window; cognitive decline must manifest within six months of a stroke to be classified as PSD.
Subcortical ischaemic vascular dementia (SIVaD): The group reached a 65% consensus to adopt SIVaD as the standard abbreviation, ending confusion between various acronyms like SIVD or SiVaD.
Multi-infarct (cortical) dementia (MID): Though included, this remains a point of discussion regarding its modern clinical utility.
Mixed dementias: The study moves toward a holistic "Mixed Dementias" category (e.g., VCI-AD), allowing clinicians to list co-occurring pathologies in order of their relative contribution.
Limitations and Future Directions
While VICCCS has provided a much-needed foundation, several areas remain for future refinement. There is a recognized need for evidence-based studies to further sub-divide "Mild VCI," as current consensus emphasizes that a diagnosis of Mild VCI does not necessarily predict progression to a specific dementia subtype.
Future work will focus on integrating specific biomarkers to better delineate PSD from other co-morbidities and developing a more systematic, step-wise approach to sub-typing patients based on the location of brain damage, etiology, and affected cognitive domains. By harmonizing expert opinion, VICCCS provides the clarity necessary for more consistent global research and improved clinical practice.
Summary updated
Abstract
VICCCS proposes a consensus-based updated conceptualization of VCI intended to facilitate standardization in research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{skrobot2016vascular,
author = {Olivia Anna Skrobot and John T. O’Brien and Sandra E. Black and Christopher Chen and Charles DeCarli and Timo Erkinjuntti and Gary A. Ford and Raj N. Kalaria and Leonardo Pantoni and Florence Pasquier and Gustavo C. Román and Anders Wallin and Perminder S. Sachdev and Ingmar Skoog and Fernando Taragano and Jillian J. Kril and Margherita Cavalieri and K. A. Jellinger and Gábor G. Kovács and S. Engelborghs and C. Lafosse and Paulo Henrique Ferreira Bertolucci and Sônia Maria Dozzi Brucki and Paulo Caramelli and Tania C. T. Ferraz Alves and Christian Bocti and Tamàs Fülöp and David B. Hogan and Ging‐Yuek Robin Hsiung and Andrew Kirk and Lopa Leach and A. Robillard and Demetrios J. Sahlas and Qihao Guo and Jiang Tian and Laura Hokkanen and Hanna Jokinen and Sarah Benisty and Vincent Deramecourt and Jean‐Jacques Hauw and H. Lenoir and Marianna Tsatali and Magda Tsolaki and Uma Sundar and Robert F. Coen and Amos D. Korczyn and M. Altieri and Marzia Baldereschi and C. Caltagirone and G. Caravaglios and Antonio Di Carlo and Vittorio Di Piero and Guido Gainotti and Samantha Galluzzi and Giancarlo Logroscino and Patrizia Mecocci and Davide Vito Moretti and Alessandro Padovani and Toshiya Fukui and Masafumi Ihara and Toshiki Mizuno and Sooyoung Kim and Rufus Akinyemi and Olusegun Baiyewu and Adesola Ogunniyi and A. Szczudlik and António J. Bastos‐Leite and Horácio Firmino and João Massano and Ana Verdelho and L. S. Kruglov and M. Kamran Ikram and Nagaendran Kandiah and Estanislao Arana and José Barroso and T Calatayud and Alfonso J. Cruz‐Jentoft and Secundino López‐Pousa and Pablo Martínez‐Lage and María Mataró and Anne Börjesson‐Hanson and Elisabet Englund and Erika J. Laukka and Cheng-Wei Qiu and Matti Viitanen and Geert Jan Biessels and F.‐E. de Leeuw and Tom den Heijer and Lieza G. Exalto and L. Jaap Kappelle and Niels D. Prins and Edo Richard and Ben Schmand and Esther van den Berg and Wiesje M. van der Flier and Başar Bılgıç and Louise Allan and Judy Archer and Johannes Attems and Antony Bayer},
title = {{The Vascular Impairment of Cognition Classification Consensus Study}},
booktitle = {Alzheimer},
year = {2016},
doi = {10.1016/j.jalz.2016.10.007},
}