The utility of high-frequency 18 MHz ultrasonography for preoperative evaluation of acral melanoma thickness in Chinese patients

Nianzhou Yu, Kai Huang, Yixin Li, Zixi Jiang, Siliang Liu, Yuancheng Liu, Xiaowan Liu, Zeyu Chen, Renliang He, Tianhong WeiFrontiers in Oncology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Our study suggests that high-frequency 18 MHz ultrasonography is an effective tool for the preoperative evaluation of AM thickness. The HFUS measurements correlated well with the histopathological thickness measurements, making it a valuable and reliable method for clinicians to assess the thickness of melanoma lesions preoperatively.

Introduction

Acral melanoma (AM), which develops on the palms, soles, and under nails, is the most common subtype of melanoma in Chinese populations, accounting for over 50% of cases. The "Breslow thickness" (the depth of the tumor) is the single most important factor in determining a patient's prognosis and the width of the surgical margin required.

The challenge lies in the preoperative phase. Traditional biopsies can sometimes underestimate tumor depth due to sampling errors. While ultrasound is increasingly used for skin cancers, its utility for AM is less studied because the unique anatomy of the hands and feet—specifically the very thick outer layer of skin (stratum corneum)—can interfere with standard imaging. This study evaluates whether an 18 MHz frequency probe provides the optimal balance for navigating these anatomical hurdles.

Methods

Researchers conducted a retrospective study of 105 patients (109 total lesions) at Xiangya Hospital between 2017 and 2021. Preoperative thickness was measured using a 5–18 MHz linear transducer, with two sonologists independently scanning lesions to identify maximum thickness. These measurements were compared against the "ground truth" provided by histopathological examination after surgical removal. The team used Spearman’s correlation coefficients to measure agreement and calculated the Positive Predictive Value (PPV) to assess how often ultrasound correctly categorized tumors into thickness brackets defined by National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) guidelines.

Comparison of clinical (A), ultrasound (B), and pathological (C) images for two thick ulcerated nodular melanomas on the plantar side.

Key Results and Insights

  • Strong Correlation: The study found a Spearman’s correlation coefficient of 0.83 between ultrasound and pathology, indicating a high degree of reliability.
  • The "Goldilocks" Frequency: While very high-frequency probes (50 MHz+) offer superior resolution, they lack the penetration depth needed for the thick calloused skin of the soles and palms. The 18 MHz probe proved effective by balancing resolution with sufficient depth.
  • High Surgical Accuracy: If surgeons had relied solely on ultrasound measurements to plan margins, 90.8% of patients would have received the correct surgical margin. This suggests HFUS could potentially reduce the need for secondary surgeries.
  • Predictive Value: The Positive Predictive Value (PPV) was highest for very thick tumors (>4 mm) at 89.7%. Accuracy was lower for tumors in the 1–2 mm range (PPV of 50%), where ultrasound tended to slightly overestimate thickness.

Discussion and Limitations

The primary limitation is the overestimation of thinner lesions (1–2 mm), possibly due to inflammatory cell infiltration at the base of the tumor being interpreted as dense tumor mass. As a retrospective study from a single center, these findings require further validation through multi-center prospective trials. Future research could also compare 18 MHz probes directly with higher-frequency (20–50 MHz) probes to determine if a multi-frequency approach improves accuracy for thinner melanomas.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study suggests that high-frequency 18 MHz ultrasonography is an effective tool for the preoperative evaluation of AM thickness. The HFUS measurements correlated well with the histopathological thickness measurements, making it a valuable and reliable method for clinicians to assess the thickness of melanoma lesions preoperatively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2023utility,
  author = {Nianzhou Yu and Kai Huang and Yixin Li and Zixi Jiang and Siliang Liu and Yuancheng Liu and Xiaowan Liu and Zeyu Chen and Renliang He and Tianhong Wei},
  title = {{The utility of high-frequency 18 MHz ultrasonography for preoperative evaluation of acral melanoma thickness in Chinese patients}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2023.1185389},
}
Figure